“Life-and-death decisions must never be surrendered to machines. Killer robots must have no place in our future,” warns António Guterres, UN Secretary-General. He is referring to the growing global race to develop AI-powered drones and weapons capable of identifying, selecting and attacking targets without human intervention.
AI-assisted drones are already changing the nature of warfare, as demonstrated by Israel, Ukraine and the United States. The next step is the development of Lethal Autonomous Weapons Systems (LAWS), popularly known as killer robots, capable of deciding whom to kill without a human pressing the button.
At a time of multiple potentially catastrophic conflicts, disagreements among major military powers over regulating these weapons cast a troubling shadow over international humanitarian law, including the four Geneva Conventions of 1949 and their Additional Protocols of 1977.
“I urge you to seize this moment. Take action to prevent the use and spread of these merciless weapons,” Guterres told this week’s UN conference in Geneva. His message is clear: some decisions must remain human decisions, none more so than the decision to take a human life.
Existing laws of war establish what is prohibited in armed conflict. A new treaty would go further by defining which autonomous weapons should be permitted, under what conditions and with what degree of human control. Treaties banning or restricting chemical and biological weapons, anti-personnel mines and blinding laser weapons provide precedents.
But the United States, Russia and Israel oppose a legally binding agreement in its proposed form. Washington favors voluntary guidelines, while other military powers think existing rules of war are enough and a new treaty is unnecessary. The danger is that international regulation is falling far behind the speedy advance of lethal autonomous weapons technology.
Although there is not yet evidence of widespread deployment of fully autonomous weapons independently deciding whom to kill, the risks are profound. Machines could mistake civilians for combatants, responsibility for wrongful killings could become blurred, and automated responses could trigger rapid and unintended military escalation. The falling cost of this technology could also put increasingly sophisticated weapons in the hands of smaller states and armed groups, with serious implications for insurgencies as in Sudan, organized criminal violence by gangs as in Haiti, and terrorism.
But the issue goes beyond technology. It raises a much bigger question: does the morality underpinning the laws of war still have practical force in this century? Can international law restrain governments that possess the military, political and diplomatic power to resist accountability?
The concerns are not hypothetical. In March 2026, Human Rights Watch criticized statements by US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth about showing no quarter to enemies in Iran, as well as Trump’s threats against Iranian infrastructure vital for civilian life. Such rhetoric raises the disturbing possibility that military dominance is taking precedence over humanity, proportionality and responsibility.
It is relatively easy to respect humanitarian principles when little is at stake. The real test comes when political and military leaders believe that abandoning them will bring strategic advantage.
The danger is that we are moving towards a world in which powerful countries invoke international law against their adversaries but disregard it when it constrains their own actions. This is not merely hypocrisy; it threatens the foundations of international legitimacy.
The United Nations Charter, born out of the carnage of two world wars, was intended to establish a world order in which even powerful nations would be subject to common rules. Yet the United States, Russia and Israel, like other major military powers, do not make decisions about conducting war by asking whether the UN or the Geneva Conventions will approve.
That is the uncomfortable reality confronting humankind, with the Damoclean sword of nuclear annihilation hanging over it: what practical meaning do morality and the laws of war retain when those with the greatest power have the greatest ability to disregard them with impunity?
















