• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • Mission Statement
  • Commenter Rules
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
  • Account Access
The Moderate Voice

The Moderate Voice

An Internet hub with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, indies, centrists, moderates, and right

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Politics
  • Society
  • Arts & Entertainment
  • Media
  • Inspiration and Living
  • Economy
  • International
  • Movie Reviews

Sikhs in America: A religious community long misunderstood is mourning deaths in Indianapolis mass shooting

Sikhs in America: A religious community long misunderstood is mourning deaths in Indianapolis mass shooting

Posted on April 18, 2021
Poll: Most Americans want to end lifetime Supreme Court appointments but nix expanded court.

Poll: Most Americans want to end lifetime Supreme Court appointments but nix expanded court.

Posted on April 18, 2021
GOP Struggling To Harm Biden

GOP Struggling To Harm Biden

Posted on April 17, 2021
Vaccination rates break down along party lines

Vaccination rates break down along party lines

Posted on April 17, 2021
Are mass shootings an American epidemic?

Are mass shootings an American epidemic?

Posted on April 16, 2021
Another US mass shooting leaves eight dead in Indianapolis

Another US mass shooting leaves eight dead in Indianapolis

Posted on April 16, 2021
… and the Oscar goes to … Are they kidding?

… and the Oscar goes to … Are they kidding?

Posted on April 16, 2021
Afghanistan: It’s Done. No More. 3.0  (UPDATE)

Afghanistan: It’s Done. No More. 3.0 (UPDATE)

Posted on April 15, 2021
U.S. imposes wide array of sanctions on Russia for ‘malign’ actions

U.S. imposes wide array of sanctions on Russia for ‘malign’ actions

Posted on April 15, 2021
Minnesota officer who shot Black man after traffic stop charged with manslaughter

Minnesota officer who shot Black man after traffic stop charged with manslaughter

Posted on April 14, 2021
‘Time to end the forever war’: Biden to start U.S. Afghanistan pullout on May 1

‘Time to end the forever war’: Biden to start U.S. Afghanistan pullout on May 1

Posted on April 14, 2021
U.S. calls for pause to J&J COVID-19 vaccine over rare blood clots

U.S. calls for pause to J&J COVID-19 vaccine over rare blood clots

Posted on April 13, 2021
Biden walks tightrope with bipartisan talks on $2 trillion infrastructure bill

Biden walks tightrope with bipartisan talks on $2 trillion infrastructure bill

Posted on April 12, 2021
Entitled

Entitled

Posted on April 12, 2021
Thank You, Sir, May I Have Another? (UPDATED)

Thank You, Sir, May I Have Another? (UPDATED)

Posted on April 11, 2021
Will Bunch: If GOP, Mitch McConnell really wants ‘woke’ corporations out of politics, here’s how

Will Bunch: If GOP, Mitch McConnell really wants ‘woke’ corporations out of politics, here’s how

Posted on April 9, 2021
You are here: Home / Breaking News / Appeals Court Says Health Care Mandate Valid

Appeals Court Says Health Care Mandate Valid

June 29, 2011 by PATRICK EDABURN, Assistant Editor 5 Comments

In 2-1 vote the US 6th District Court Of Appeals has ruled that the mandate provision of Health Care Reform is valid.

As a bit of background, the Commerce Clause gives Congress the power to ‘regulate commerce among the several states’. It has been determined that this allows them to regulate any activities with a significant impact on interstate commerce.

One of the key cases that set down this rule was Wickard v. Filburn which had to do with government regulations on wheat farming. The law said a farmer could only grow so much wheat and Wickard was growing too much so he faced a fine. Wickard argued that since he was growing wheat for his own use and had no intention to sell it that it had nothing to do with interstate commerce.

The court ruled that since by growing the wheat he would not be buying wheat then he was in fact having an impact on the market by removing himself from it.

Needless to say this was and remains a controversial ruling, especially among conservatives who believe in a more limited federal government. But in the last 60 years only two laws have been struck down as being beyond the scope of the commerce clause.

In United States v. Lopez the Supreme Court struck down a law banning guns near schools while in United States v Morrison it struck down a law allowing women who were attacked to sue the attacker in federal courts.

The court determined that both laws had more to do with criminal activity that commerce, so the laws were struck on those grounds. But the rulings did not strike down the general rule that the Commerce Clause is extremely broad in scope and authority.

The commerce clause is important because the individual mandate has been a key dispute for the opponents of Health Care Reform who state that the government does not have the authority to make people purchase health insurance. Those supporting the reform counter that the government does have the power to regulate commerce and that the mandate falls under that category.

The Appeals Court seemed to agree with the latter view, taking the position that since the broad purpose of Health Care Reform was to regulate the health care/insurance market that Congress could do what was needed to achieve that goal (IE covered by the commerce clause under Wickard doctrine).

The key parts of the ruling were stated as follows

“Congress had a rational basis for concluding that the minimum coverage provision is essential to the Affordable Care Act’s larger reforms to the national markets in health care delivery and health insurance.”

“The activity of foregoing health insurance and attempting to cover the cost of health care needs by self-insuring is no less economic than the activity of purchasing an insurance plan,” the decision states. “Thus, the financing of health care services, and specifically the practice of self-insuring, is economic activity.”

More details to follow but neither side should read too much into this. We are likely to have courts ruling both ways until the case makes it to the US Supreme Court in 2012 or 2013.

Filed Under: Breaking News, Health, Law

Primary Sidebar

Donate to TMV

The TMV Feed

 Subscribe in a reader

Archives

Categories

The Latest

Most Commented Posts (7 or so days)

Copyright 1998 - 2020 The Moderate Voice. Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in