Pages Menu
Categories Menu

Posted by on Jan 10, 2008 in At TMV | 7 comments

A Sad Commentary on These Times


It is a sad commentary on the times in which we live that my initial reaction to a Pentagon report that Iranian fast boats had swarmed U.S. warships in the Strait of Hormuz on Sunday was disbelief. And that the incident was being used as a pretext to up the saber rattling instead of making a good-faith effort to engage Tehran diplomatically.

The Irani government downplayed the report, of course, and says that a U.S. video of the incident is a fake. I dunno. But I do know that after being lied to by my government with mind numbing regularity, it just isn’t possible to cast the U.S. as the good guy in this one.

The incident, of course, brings to mind the notorious Gulf of Tonkin Incident, a non-event that the Johnson administration used as a pretext for escalating U.S. involvement in the Vietnam War.

The so-called precipitating incident on August 4, 1964 actually occurred two days before the fabricated incident when North Vietnamese gunboats engaged the destroyer USS Maddox (see painting) in the South China Sea following covert U.S. attacks on North Vietnam. The U.S. used radio transmissions from the August 2 incident to argue that on August 4 the Maddox and destroyer USS Turner Joy were the targets of unprovoked attacks.

What is now certain is that on August 2 the Maddox fired on the gunboats first, the attack on the Turner Joy never occurred and a sonar technician who reported the firing of 22 North Vietnamese torpedoes confused them with the sound of the engine of his own ship.

How ironic that President Bush arrived in the Middle East this week not to engage in diplomacy with the country that can shut down the Strait of Hormuz, which is so crucial to world oil shipping, and restart its shuttered nuclear weapons program on a whim, but to rally opposition to it.

Cernig nails it at Newshoggers, writing that:

“We’re back to ‘bomb, bomb, bomb Iran’ because five ‘pimped out Boston Whalers’ — as Jules Crittenden puts it — got close to an Aegis cruiser, a mini-Aegis Arleigh Burke destroyer and a frigate with a combined firepower that could probably sink the entire Iranian Navy and down the entire Iranian Air Force. Now that really is absurd.”

Did I say what a sad commentary this is on the times in which we live?

Painting by E.J. Fitzgerald (January 1965)

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By :