Pages Menu
Categories Menu

Posted by on Apr 14, 2006 in At TMV | 1 comment

A Legal Immigrant Looks At Illegal Immigration

Boston Globe columnist Cathy Young looks at the illegal immigration controversy in a MUST READ POST on her blog. Here’s a tiny portion:

I am a legal immigrant myself. As many of you know, I came here with my family in 1980 from the Soviet Union; at the time, we automatically received refugee status on the grounds that we feared persecution in our native country. (Which, actually, was not even technically accurate: the Soviet Jews coming here at the time had to fear persecution only if they wanted to openly practice Judaism — which, for my non-religious family, was not an issue — or if they were political dissidents.) And that is something I tremendously appreciate, but I am also aware of the fact that I got a special break due to Cold War politics, and that a lot of people around the world who had as good a claim to fleeing oppression or persecution did not get the same break. So my reaction is not “but I came here legally!” but more like, “There but for the grace of God…”

I understand that we need more effective border control, particularly in the age when terrorism is a real concern. I know there are other concerns about the economic and social impact of uncontrolled immigration (though I haven’t studied the issue enough to have a strong opinion on how justified those concern are). But I also know that anti-immigrant panic has been, again and again, responsible for ungenerous and sometimes downright inhumane policies unworthy of America.

Read the whole thing.

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By :