An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Jew, Muslim and Christian: It is God Who is Being Murdered – L’Orient Le Jour, Lebanon

It’s one of the most perplexing paradoxes of the human condition: Why do people formed to worship a perfect, loving, omniscient, omnipresent god continue to murder one another in that very god’s name, millenia after millenia?

Shaming his mostly Muslim and Christian readers with a global exposition of this madness, Nagib Aoun of Lebanon’s L’Orient Le Jour points out the real casualty of this age-old contradiction.

For L’Orient Le Jour, Nagib Aoun writes in part:

The world has been mad since the very beginning. It went mad at the very moment Eve offered the forbidden fruit to Adam, and when Cain killed Abel. The madness has continued down the centuries, throughout all the years of disaster and distress, and won’t abate as long as man takes its madness for genius, its convictions for divine revelation, and its words as gospel.

“We need not go very far back. From a First World War in which soldiers went to their deaths with flowers inserted into the barrels of their guns; to a second global conflagration in which one man’s madness captivated the population and paved the way for the unthinkable- and for the Third World War that is now going on. It is a war of sacrificial terrorism in which thousands of people are killed or die in the name of Allah the Merciful. The body of evidence for the inevitable, as though it were written in the stars, is accumulating. Every day it’s more overwhelming – and every day there are more murderers.

“From Afghanistan to Iraq, from a bin Laden who thought he was the double-edged sword of Islam destined to punish infidels and eliminate “the new crusaders,” to a George Bush who claimed to be charged with a divine mission to eradicate evil, the religious factor is ubiquitous, always brandished to justify the unjustifiable and to buttress the legitimacy of dangerous adventures, of murderous expeditions.”


By Nagib Aoun

Translated By Helene Grinsted

November 12, 2009

Lebanon – L’Orient Le Jour – Home Page (French)

Is the world mad? Obviously it is totally and completely mad. It’s a mixed up world, given over to the hesitations of some and the destructive moods of others, all apparently oblivious to the world’s insanity, its schizophrenia.

READ ON AT WORLDMEETS.US, your most trusted translator and aggregator of foreign news and views about our nation.

  • dduck12
    "With or without religion, you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion."
    -- Steven Weinberg
  • Almoderate
    Regarding the Weinberg quote... I think it merely takes an excuse that is good enough. Religion merely provides a convenient and easy to use one. Those who start a war have their own motives-- money, power, revenge, etc. Look into the heart of every war ever started where we're told from a young age that there were noble causes (with the possible exception of SOME revolutions), and you will find not-so-noble beginnings. Even in cases where the lower and middle classes overthrow their leaders, you will find that they are often lead by someone who is motivated by putting himself into power.

    Religion isn't needed to hurt other people. It's just currently the easiest excuse that can be used to get other people to go along with it. Without religion, you can bet that something else would be used to manipulate the masses. Fear comes to mind.
  • dduck12
    Your point is well taken. The wolf often takes the cloak of religion to hide his evil intent.
  • roro80
    "I think it merely takes an excuse that is good enough"

    Hey Almoderate -- I would agree with your sentiment, but I think dduck12's first comment kind of speaks to the point. It's not that those whose hunger for power and wealth compel them to encourage violence would be diminished were there no religion, it's just that their ability to get others to join them despite their own lack of personal gain would be diminished.
  • ProfElwood
    The track record for Atheist leaders doesn't back that assumption.
  • roro80
    Hmmm...to which atheist leaders do you refer?
  • roro80
    On second thought, perhaps a better question would be: how does it compare to the track record for theist leaders?
  • dduck12
    The "religion" of those folks is the religion of power. They use any and all means to their ends, atheist or "real" theist.
  • "With or without religion, you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion."
    -- Steven Weinberg

    That's about the dumbest thing I've ever heard. Good people do bad things all the time, all it takes is the proper motivation, whatever that happens to be for that individual.
  • Hmmm...to which atheist leaders do you refer?

    Vladamir Lenin
    Josef Stalin
    Pol Pot
    Mao Zedong
    Kim Il Sung

    I would note that the atheism of these individuals did not lead them to commit atrocities. But neither did it protect anyone against which they turned their attention - and, to directly address the point made above, none of them couched their leadership in terms of religion.
  • Almoderate
    "...it's just that their ability to get others to join them despite their own lack of personal gain would be diminished."

    And as I said in my last sentence... Fear is a good motivator. Remind me again how we got into the Iraq War.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC