An Internet hub with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, indies, centrists, moderates, and right

Geithner’s Welcome Expired Long Ago

I told you so 7 months ago in my TMV post dated 3/19/09 and titled “It’s Time to Throw Geithner under the Bus.” Considering the growing chorus from the left, right and middle now calling for his termination or resignation, I re-read my original post. As always, I was prescient, accurate, and possibly clairvoyant on this matter.

Yours truly also predicted this entire economic collapse at least 5 years ago, but no one took me seriously. Prophets are never appreciated or heeded in their own times. However, I am not pleased that I was correct in my original assessment of Mr. Geithner 7 months ago because the entire country has suffered due to his incompetence, Wall Street Bias, and overall cluelessness towards the needs of Main Street and the vast majority of Americans.

Most politicians are quick to blame others (sometimes correctly) for political and economic problems but they never want to admit they were incorrect in any of their decisions or that they helped make those problems. Unfortunately hindsight is 20-20 and no one is clairvoyant except Madame Olga on the West Side of Cleveland. We all make mistakes – yours truly included – and it is better to quickly fess up publicly to those errors in judgment, change course and move on.

Too many politicians think an admission of error is a sign of weakness so they continue to proudly deny, blame others, obfuscate the real facts, and follow various stupid and discredited policies so as to not have to admit they made any mistakes. This applies to most of our elected leaders regardless of their political or economic positions. I wrote back on 3/19/09:

“Most people, including Presidents, have little or no control over circumstances or events. However, we are all judged by how we respond to them.”

Many in the general public want some genuine honesty from their politicians. Some voters will always punish our leaders for admitting mistakes because they themselves are unwilling to admit their private errors either. However, most people understand all too well our human imperfections. But we expect people to learn from their errors and move in another direction after taking full ownership of their mistakes.

President Obama would not fare poorly in 2010 or 2012 if he promptly admitted numerous errors he has made while in office – while avoiding admitting any more debatable or obvious mistakes made in U.S. history to which he was not a party. He could then promptly change his focus and move on with renewed public support. That would really distinguish him from other politicians and gain him public respect. There has been sufficient time now to fully judge Secretary Geithner. The President can now point to the worsening general economy and public anger over unregulated massive bailouts of Wall Street to justify his decision to part ways with his chief financial adviser.

I can list a number of policy and tactical mistakes the President has made since taking office, and so can most TMV readers. One major issue today is with those who aare key advisors to the President in making public policy with respect to our country’s financial and economic future. There are many independent and highly capable individuals in the U.S. without any direct ties to Wall Street or prior Administrations who could competently lead the U.S. Treasury Department. Secretary Timothy Geithner is not one of them.

The 2010 Midterm elections are less than a year a way because of Constitutionally-fixed federal elections every 2 years. Mr. Geithner is eminently disposable for the good of the country and for President Obama’s political survival. So Mr. President, please admit some of your mistakes (most people will likely forgive you), and throw Secretary Geithner under the bus – or at least ease him out the rear doors to some cushy Wall Street position where he can do no more harm to the nation.

Marc Pascal – the ever ranting sage in Phoenix, AZ who wishes everyone a pleasant weekend.



opinions powered by SendLove.to

4 Responses to “Geithner’s Welcome Expired Long Ago”

  1. sparkles43 says:

    http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/20/opinion/20bro…

    What Geithner Got Right
    By DAVID BROOKS
    Published: November 19, 2009

    Well, the evidence of the past eight months suggests that Geithner was mostly right and his critics were mostly wrong. The financial sector is in much better shape than it was then. TARP money is being repaid, and the debate now is what to do with the billions that were never needed. It now seems clear that nationalization would have been an unnecessary mistake — potentially expensive and dangerously disruptive.

    The course of events has vindicated the administration’s handling of its first big challenge. Obama could have flinched when the torrent of criticism was at its peak. But the president’s support for Geithner never wavered. Geithner never lost confidence in his policy. Rahm Emanuel mobilized to improve the presentation of the policy. The political team worked hard to deflect criticism from Geithner onto themselves.

    In retrospect, their performance during this trial was impressive.

    If you wanted to step back and define Geithner’s philosophy, you’d probably say that he starts with a set of fairly conservative instincts about the role of government, which put him on the centrist edge of the Democratic Party.

    Some administrations are staffed by hedgehogs, who are guided by a few core principles. But this one is staffed by foxes, who respond flexibly to situations. In the administration’s first big test, that sort of pragmatism paid off.

  2. dduck12 says:

    I also think Geithner is being pilloried unfairly by the party out of power. That is the usual scenario for politics.

  3. DLS says:

    I have no sympathy for Geithner, even with the fact of cheap-shot opportunism by Republicans (as well as lefties, incidentally, whose solutions to related problems are no better, and often may be worse).

    Morici has been great, about Geithner and other topics, as a rule:

    http://www.finfacts.ie/irishfinancenews/article…

    http://tradeandtaxes.blogspot.com/2009/03/peter…

    http://blogs.reuters.com/great-debate/tag/peter…

    (“Conservatives need a bad guy…”)

    http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601103…

  4. dduck12 says:

    Come on, the Reps would attack anyone, including JC, at this point. And if the shoe were on the other foot, the Dems (being the out party) would do the same.

© 2003-2011 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Mode Equity