An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

James Arthur Ray Books Are Cancelled: The Empire Builder on Money and Spirituality

James Ray who has a mega-spirituality business that revolves around ‘wealth getting,’ held a retreat in Arizona two weeks ago. For reasons not clear, he allegedly built an ungodly large 20×20 “sweatlodge,” and purported to be copying Native American sacred practices. He crammed 50 people into that skeletal structure covered by plastic tarps, and then, with the rocks smoking hot hot steam, seemingly would not allow anyone to leave, even though they complained they were ill and could not breathe. Three persons died and 21 were hospitalized.

We talked about this at themoderatevoice, especially being bewildered about the seeming lack of sorrow, lack of decent conduct and lack of hiatus in ‘business as usual’ with regard to the dead and their families. There was amazement to hear that participants in Mr. Ray’s program had paid 9-10k per person to attend a five day retreat. Then, there was also being taken aback by the seeming crass blog post that Mr. Ray put up on his website (see below), defending his empire while giving such seeming weak shrift to, again, the dead and the injured. Some who have spiritual practices in Buddhism spoke about karma and how this strange, delayed and sub-standard response by Mr. Ray to such serious and grievous issues… might boomerang back.

Today, it was announced by Hyperion book publishers that they are postponing the publication of two books by James Arthur Ray. Publishers Weekly, the time-honored rag that follows the latest events in mostly New York publishing, said the books were being ‘postponed,’ ….”following the author’s possible involvement in the deaths of three people and hospitalization of 21 others in a sauna-like sweat lodge at an Arizona resort last month.”

Hyperion had committed to release a paperback edition of Ray’s bestselling Harmonic Wealth: The Secret of Attracting the Life You Want, and a new book they hoped to flog onto the best seller “advice list”, scheduled to be published in December 2009, and entitled: The Seven Laws of True Wealth by Ray.

But when the news and accusations broke on October 9, “that Ray had led a “spiritual warrior” experience at a retreat center near Sedona, Ariz. in which 50 people crowded into a makeshift structure covered with blankets and plastic and heated with fiery rocks in the hopes of a spiritual cleansing—resulting in injuries and deaths…” Hyperion made fire of their own by hitting their brakes with full weight.

As a published author, I’ve learned through sad loss of innocence, a great deal of the code used to obfuscate in the field of publishing. You think the Vatican gives covert messages? I think the cardinals learned nuanced statements from the publishing industry. When the Hyperion spokesperson, Marie Coolman, said the books have been postponed until January 2011, this means in part, that the legal department is likely suddenly going over the contracts with a fine tooth comb looking for ways to dump these projects

…publishing being put off for 15 months re a ready and roaring bestseller ’sure thang,’ further indicates the publisher is likely not wanting to be associated with any person falling badly from grace (Think of James Frey) whom they were touting as the mini-god of getting rich…

and being particularly concerned too that the publishing company, right or wrong, could be named as an ‘accomplice’ via a lawsuit by injured or disgruntled former ‘followers’ of Mr. Ray, charging that the publisher promulgated, offering Ray as a trusted expert, as on the level…. thereby duping the public, and leading individuals into harm’s way.

Ray’s Harmonic Wealth was a New York Times bestseller on the “advice” list. Ray was a “featured expert” in the movie, The Secret, and has appeared on the Oprah show.

The story of the ‘get rich empire’ will, I believe, continue to unfold. On the one hand, I dont think in small or large endeavors one can control all variables, and surely even at the most proven expert sports courses, say tennis camp, I’ve heard there are often a full staff of doctors and nurses, for it is expected there might be injuries. So it’s not that exactly.

But, it is this: At the moment, the sheriff is still saying the deaths of the three people was not an accident, it seemingly was murder. From AP, “Arizona ….Yavapai County Sheriff Steve Waugh… investigating the deaths of two people during a sweat lodge ceremony led by self-help expert James Arthur Ray, says the fatalities are now being investigated as homicides… He said… Thursday, that the deaths of 38-year-old Kirby Brown of Westtown N.Y. and 40-year-old James Shore of Milwaukee were not accidental…”

The sheriff appears to think that not allowing people to leave when they cried out that they were suffering greatly, is tantamount to abject negligence of life, and with foreknowledge that people can die from heat stroke, even when told they are strong, and to stop acting weak, and to ‘warrior up’ instead.

Meanwhile, Mr. Ray, has declined to come on CNN to tell his story. But it appears the story will be told anyway… especially by those deposed who were actually in the “sweat lodge”…. and the story will be written down in court documents which will record the stories from many sides, most often devoid of varnish or gloss.

CORRECTION: Original title to this piece stated James Arthur Ray’s middle name was August. It has now been corrected, with special thanks to Sparrow.

______________
CODA
Here is the most recent blog post from Mr. Ray’s website. On October 20 2009, ten days after the loss of three lives and 21 others injured, he wrote:

For me, for the families and friends of the sick and deceased and for many people who believe in the important work we do, these have been the most difficult ten days of our lives.

People are throwing out accusations and disparaging me and our mission. Yet despite that, and despite considerable criticism, I have chosen to continue with my work. It’s too important not to. One of the lessons I teach is that you have to confront and embrace adversity and learn and grow from it. I promise you I am doing a lot of learning and growing. I have taken heat for that decision, but if I chose to lock myself in my home, I am sure I would be criticized for hiding and not practicing what I preach.

It means a great deal to me that so many of you have come to see me speak this week and last–that you are investing your time and energy into creating more fulfilling, successful and productive lives. It reaffirms my decision to continue my schedule and these event experiences.

I want to use this forum to address the families of those whose lives were lost, James, Kirby and Liz. I have reached out to all of the families personally, but feel the need to say more. I feel your pain. I accept your anger. And I pray for you all to have some measure of peace and comfort. I want you to know that I too want to know what happened that caused this horrible tragedy. My team and I are working with the appropriate authorities and have even hired our own investigators to find out the truth.

I believe the best way to honor their amazing lives and everlasting memory is to continue this important work. Please join me in a moment of silence to pay homage to their lives and to pray for the speedy recovery of others taken ill.

James Arthur Ray
President/CEO
James Ray International, Inc.

  • spirasol
    There will be payment, karma if you like..........but that is still not redemption. He needs to go sit in a quiet dark place alone.............and sweat. In time if he is lucky sitting there in the dark, there may come a tap on his shoulder....that would be his conscience trying to awaken the other parts.
  • tidbits
    "I want you to know that I too want to know what happened that caused this horrible tragedy." James Arthur Ray. Sounds like someone floating a legal defense.

    Followed by, "My team and I are working with the appropriate authorities and have even hired our own investigators to find out the truth." His lawyers already have their investigators on the case to track the authorities investigation and plant the seeds of his defense.

    His statement is self serving BS. Sounds like he and his legal team are anticipating criminal charges and/or civil litigation. Criminal: possibly criminally negligent homicide, but more likely manslaughter because of the added factor of refusing to allow people to leave. Murder is unlikely because of the difficulty proving specific intent to kill. Civil litigation could include negligence and perhaps punitive damages based on gross recklessness.

    Whatever the legal outcome, this should be a time to mourn loss, not use a purported statement of sympathy to set up your legal defense, Mr. Ray. Shame on you.





  • ordinarysparrow
    glad to hear this news about the books. . .would like him to be integral with his own teachings to start with. . .the books are one of the places that is likely to touch his heart first. . .

    here are a couple a quotes for tidbits that will make the dog growl. . . these where taken from a blog entry on the Huffington Post called; Health Care: What ever happened to Taking Personal Responsibility?
    Not only karma comes back but sometimes one's own words can bounce back and bite one's butt. . .

    "Dealing with Cause versus Effect

    If you're familiar at all with my work, you should know by now that "energy flows where attention goes."

    All the hoopla regarding death panels, rationing and discontinuing Medicare is the conversation about what to do with people who are sick. Do we let them die or live? Are they worth saving or not? Is this a conversation about health? I think not. The study of how to address sickness is not an advocacy, nor a solution, for health.

    In my letter to the president when he took office (click here to read it), I suggested we usher in a new era of responsibility. So far, I haven't seen it in any great measure, and this issue extends beyond health care alone.

    Banks and automotive companies that ran their businesses irresponsibly were bailed out with little accountability or with few constructs being put in place. In other words, "You screwed up, but you're not responsible or being held accountable."

    I don't know about you, but if I make poor financial decisions in my personal life or business, I've never found anyone (much less the government) ready to bail me out. I currently have a pretty hefty tax bill due to the state of California, and I'm pretty sure they're not going to let me off.

    And now, we're consumed with sick care. I'm not too excited to pay for a lung cancer case obtained by smoking two packs of Marlboros per day. What part of "smoking has been proven to cause lung cancer" is unclear?

    Likewise, I'm not excited to pay for triple bypass for a person who's spent a lifetime eating burritos, Krispy Kreme and Snickers, whose idea of a workout is clicking the remote on their television.

    If I sound insensitive, I apologize. Those who know me know I'm very sensitive to the needs of others. And please understand that needs and wants are not always the same thing.

    Sometimes true sensitivity and love is not continuing to enable individuals to continue with the behaviors that got them in a painful situation to begin with. I don't think many parents would allow their small children the opportunity to continually place their hands upon a hot stove.

    When we individually begin taking more personal responsibility for our own health and our own lives in every area, we feel more empowered, more inspired and alive and more in control. Transforming our government and our world begins with transforming our self.

    That's how you and I change the world."

    J.A. Ray

    Dr. E. i think James's middle name is Arthur instead of August?


    Read more at: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/james-arthur-ray/...
  • tidbits
    Sparrow - The dog always smiles, but sometimes the soul rages behind the smile.
  • Leebot
    Thank you for the update, Dr. E. I am struck how his blog post seems so much about ego, how much more concerned he seems about his own self-image. Very smooth, that bit about hiring his own investigators. What I'm hearing from him is a refusal to accept the personal responsibility he claims to value . . . he can't imagine what went wrong, "mistakes were made."

    I posted the link to this WashPo piece by sociologist and author Christine Whelan on the other thread but thought it worth repeating, and she also has a similar well-written column on Huffington Post where she is a contributor.

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/ar...

    http://www.huffingtonpost.com/christine-whelan/...

    The comments are worth reading too -- quite a few posters share anecdotal stories from their own experiences which expands my own understanding.

    This passage from Whelan caught my attention:

    "At the ritual's conclusion, seemingly unaware of the bodies of the unconscious lying around him, Ray emerged triumphantly, witnesses said, pumping his fist in the air because he had passed his own endurance test. "

    Hubris is the word that comes to mind.
  • roro80
    "(Think of James Frey)"

    Oprah should totally get this Dr. back on her show to make him admit his wrong doing and make him apologize, just like she did with Frey. I doubt not that she could do it. I really do adore Oprah, but sometimes I think she can be very damaging with her "medical woo", bringing people with clearly unscientific/spiritual "cures" for medical issues to national attention. This is just one example of this taken to extremes.

    Anyway, my heart goes out to the families of those who died.
  • spirasol
    Yea, Oprah is a cultural icon and it is hard not to love her...........but it was she who brought Dr. Phil into your living room too.

    If it were possible to send Ray to a new age Siberia I doubt it would do much good. He is made from the same fabric as so many others..........he speaks from the same positivity culture as so many others who came before him and will follow him. There are people out there asking the right questions, writing books that challenge the underlying ethos. I'm not sure if it makes a dent, but folks are trying.

    I have difficulty comprehending criticism of Ray hiring a lawyer. What else would someone do in as litigious a society as ours. Were we not so, we might be able to dispense with all the defending, and get more easily to the heart of the matter.
  • Ghostdreams
    I just want to know why he's not been picked up and arrested.
    The cops are saying it's murder. So who are they saying is responsible for the murder or is it murder by bad decision making, so that doesn't count?
    What are they doing down in Arizona??
    Three people are dead and this jerk is off doing "workshops?"
    What can this possibly say about our justice dept? I think it says a lot. Something to the effect of, "If you have money, you can get away with murder." (literally)
    Pathetic.
    :(
    Thanks for the update Doc.
    Ghost
  • Leebot
    Hi Ghostdreams,

    I have some law enforcement background so hope you don't mind my responding to your questions. The police have not said this was a murder, they are in the process of investigating. Detectives are investigating the incident as a possible homicide, which means they have to follow a specific set of investigative protocols that come to bear where there may be some culpability. Such investigations can take time, police may need to delay interviewing key eyewitnesses until they have sufficiently recovered. In addition, it usually takes several weeks for full autopsy results (including toxicology tests) to be available to the forensic examiner, whose findings will be important. According to a news source, the investigators themselves have said it would take several weeks to complete their investigation. I would rather see the police take the time they need to conduct a thorough and proper investigation because if charges are eventually filed against Mr. Ray, the case needs to stand on its own legs in a court of law in terms of strength of evidence, but also in terms of procedure. Nothing worse than to have a case like this dismissed on a technicality.

    Arrests cannot be made based upon mere suspicion; the police will require probable cause. They may not be at that point yet, but that doesn't mean it won't happen eventually. In any event Mr. Ray is not required to cooperate with them or submit to an interview. I think it speaks volumes about him that he has not, although I'm sure he is operating upon standard legal advice. Regardless of how the criminal investigation unfolds, Mr. Ray and/or his organization will almost certainly be sued in Civil Court.
  • Leebot
    Read this on a Sedona news website:

    Sheriff’s Office seeks information
    Yavapai County Sheriff’s Office detectives are trying to find and interview previous attendees, staff and workers at James Arthur Ray’s Spiritual Warrior retreats or his similar events.
    Anyone with information should contact YCSO online at www.ycsoaz.gov or by calling Yavapai Silent Witness at (800) 932-3232.
  • johncurtis
    “The Self-Help Movement has become the Self-Destruct Movement!”

    There was a time when the answers to life’s challenges were simple. We learned to make our own decisions based on common sense, family values and religion, and we learned good judgment from life experience and through the sound advice of family and friends.

    Now, however, Self-Help gurus have brainwashed us into believing that they know what is best for us, our marriages and our families. These self-proclaimed experts make millions while offering up their generic advice without any solid evidence to support their claims.

    The common sense once readily available to all of us has been hijacked. Self-Help has evolved into a “quasi-religious” cult following through the systematic commercialization of positive psychology and sound mental health.

    The Self-Help Movement has become the Self-Destruct Movement by diminishing or destroying our ability to explore, interpret, assess, create, judge, choose and evolve on our own. We have given up the freedom to live life, and build healthy marriages and families based on our unique history, values and life experience. Instead many (desperately) search outside themselves for someone to tell them how to be happy, what they should value and how they should act.

    Being a “happier person” or having a “healthier family,” whatever that means, are often the goals of consumers of Self-Help products. Yet studies continue to show that to be happy and healthy is simple but not necessarily easy. Few of us want to do the hard work necessary to change, so we keep searching for an easier way offered by the latest guru, sometimes with deadly consequences.

    The Solution: A Return to our (Common) Senses! The best way out of this learned “self-helplessness” is to go cold turkey. Stop watching ALL Self-Help shows now, and quit reading any more Self-Help books, at least until you have applied what you read in the last one.

    Begin, instead, to reclaim your natural, God-given ability to think for yourself. The common sense that was once readily available to all of us is still there free of charge and waiting to be applied to just about any challenge we might face in life… all you have to do is use it.

    John Curtis, Ph.D. is the founder of Americans Against Self-Help Fraud - http://selfhelpfraud.com/
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC