An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Obama Declares National H1N1 Swine Flu National “Emergency”

It’s now official and in a stage beyond just warnings: President Barack Obama has declared swine flu a national emergency:

President Barack Obama has signed a proclamation declaring swine flu a national emergency, the White House said Saturday.

“In keeping with the administration’s proactive approach to H1N1 Flu, President Obama last night signed a proclamation declaring 2009-H1N1 Influenza a national emergency,” it said in a statement. “The proclamation enhances the ability of our nation’s medical treatment facilities to handle a surge in H1N1 patients by allowing, as needed, the waiver of certain standard federal requirements on a case-by-case basis.”

Officials described the move as similar to a declaration ahead of a hurricane making landfall.

On Friday, federal health officials said more Americans have been vaccinated against seasonal flu this fall than ever before by this time of year.

Sixty million people have gotten the winter flu vaccine — probably because they’re paying more attention to flu warnings in general, thanks to swine flu. It’s an unprecedented number of seasonal flu shots for October; most usually aren’t given until later in the fall.

And this strain is particularly vicious:

The flu has infected millions of Americans and killed nearly 100 children in the U.S. The chief of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said Friday that over a thousand people have died as a result, with 46 states reporting widespread H1N1 activity.

“Since the beginning of the pandemic, we’ve seen more than 1,000 deaths and 20,000 hospitalizations,” said Dr. Thomas Frieden, head of the CDC. “We expect it to occur in waves, but we can’t predict when those waves will happen.”

Sixty million Americans have been vaccinated against the seasonal flu this year, but an additional vaccine against H1N1 has been in short supply. About 120 million doses were expected to be made available by the middle of October, though only 11 million doses have been shipped to health departments for use.

Personal note: In my nonblogging incarnation, apart from writing I do often do programs in schools in my entertainer incarnation. October is the most germ-risk month each year (one year I got double pneumonia due to picking up ailments at schools and was hospitalized for 10 days while on the road). This year, it’s clear the schools in California are more at risk than ever — and here in San Diego swine flu is emerging bigtime at schools:

Outbreaks of swine flu have occurred in at least 29 schools in San Diego County over the past three weeks, it was reported Thursday.

Some of the affected schools have been hit with absentee rates of 20 percent of more in a particular class, grade or across the student body, The San Diego Union-Tribune reported.

County public health officials told the newspaper that the flu being caused by the H1N1 virus is likely circulating at all other local campuses but further testing is needed to confirm it.

“We know this virus is widespread throughout the community, and that includes our schools,” Deputy Public Health Officer Dr. Dean Sidelinger said.

The number of people hospitalized countywide with swine flu since the pandemic began earlier this year stands at 348 as of Wednesday afternoon.

But just as EVERYTHING in the United States these days MUST be politicized, swine flu has been no exception. Despite the advice of experts and doctors, some high profile pundits seemingly pooh-pooh the idea of getting a H1N1 flu shot. The Scripps Howard News Service has an interesting column on this. Here’s the beginning of it:

Forget about Bill Maher and Glenn Beck. Go get a flu shot — especially if you belong to a group most at risk for the disease. The vaccinations are safe, they are effective and they build a wall of protection for you and your community.

Maher, a left-wing comedian, wrote on Twitter recently: “If u get a swine flu shot ur an idiot.”

Beck, a conservative talk show host for Fox News, raised the possibility that the neurological disease Guillain-Barre Syndrome would break out. “How much do you trust your government?” Beck asked. “I think that’s the main question.”

Think about it for a moment. Glenn Beck? Bill Maher? Or the best scientists in the country?

We’ll go with the scientists. They believe the swine flu vaccine is safe. They believe Americans who are most at risk should receive it.

Indeed: Americans can now look at themselves their loved ones can ponder whether they think the shot is some evil government plot (does it contain a mind control drug that’ll make someone too centrist or too left wing or implant a GPS like tracking device in their arms?) or perhaps something that might stave off a unwanted recuperation at home, a costly hospital stay or perhaps a funeral for one of their children.

A difficult choice?

  • JSpencer
    It will always be a "difficult choice" for those who give short shrift to science and common sense. The rest of us will get the shots. ;-) Btw, I'm not surprised Beck made his comment, but would have expected Maher to have more on the ball.
  • DLS
    It assuages the panicky people subject to hysteria, anyway, and provides the superficial appearance that Something is Being Done. (It's also an admission that ObamaCo is now in Katrina mode about handling this matter, including the public relations disasters it is experiencing. [chuckle])
  • DLS
    Who would take advice from anyone substituting "U" for "you," and lower instead of upper case?
  • DaGoat
    Officials described the move as similar to a declaration ahead of a hurricane making landfall.

    I would describe it as noticing there is a hurricane after your roof has blown away. The H1N1 is already here and we don't even have enough vaccine for the high-risk kids, let alone the healthy kids, pregnant women, caregivers, etc. Any effort to paint this as a success for Obama is pure spin.
  • pacatrue
    Any move to paint this as a failure for Obama is pure spin. Maybe some things are not about Obama.
  • It isn't too late and this stance from President Obama is fine. The whole successful/not successful angle is irrelevant in my opinion. There seems to be issues in the mass manufacturing of the vaccine that is slowing things down.

    But government (both sides) have been slow on the uptake. I don't think that scientists in general were trying just scare everyone when they declared we would be where we are now concerning H1N1 spreading months ago. But as always, the political posturing slows things down.
  • Almoderate
    Now before I say this, let me say that I think panicking due to the flu is completely ridiculous. I wouldn't have called it a national emergency. It's the flu-- swine or not. Yes, it's particularly nasty, but it's still the flu. It's not sudden death if you're the typical person who catches it. You won't love it, but it's not a death sentence. It's the flu.

    That being said, I get the flu shot these days. Ever since I was pregnant I got it. Why? Well, nobody is going to argue that science is perfect, but as my doctor told me, there are far more (and worse) problems caused due to complications with the flu than problems caused due to complications with the flu shot. I like my odds with the shot better.
  • DLS
    "It isn't too late and this stance from President Obama is fine."

    I view the "national emergency" stuff as PR-related hype. I never was caught up in the storm of earlier sensationalism about H1N1 or any panic about getting vaccinated (or thought much of the other related stories such as requiring health-service workers to get vaccinated). I also don't view it as a government conspiracy. (Government bungling, maybe, but much of it is just indicative of the whole administration.)
  • TheMagicalSkyFather
    I searched everywhere for the flu shot for the last few weeks, and as of yesterday I have H1N1 and it sucks lol.
  • DaGoat
    Any move to paint this as a failure for Obama is pure spin. Maybe some things are not about Obama.

    Obama's administration had considerably more warning about this than Bush ever did with Katrina. The government predicted 120 million H1N1 vaccines by now, we have 11 million. Even allowing for production problems their estimates were way off. Will Sibelius play the Michael Brown role?

    The saving grace is that despite the deaths, which are tragic, so far the H1N1 flu isn't even as bad as many of the seasonal varieties. The great majority of people do fine.
  • Silhouette
    What are your symptoms Magical Sky Father?
    [and why was the constitutional question thread closed for further comment?]
  • I have no idea why that thread was closed Sil but it's open now. Thanks for the heads up.
  • I view the "national emergency" stuff as PR-related hype.


    Ya most likely. But I don't have a huge problem with it. Seems like a CYA statement to me. Put it out there just in case.
  • TheMagicalSkyFather
    Earlier in the week I thought I had just eaten something I was allergic too but now I have random bouts of chills convulsions and fever that are far beyond normal for a flu. It will give me time to watch some movies though lol.
  • JSpencer
    Hope you're feeling better soon. Not much fun being under the weather... regardless of the cause.
  • I hate to be the one to pee in the pool, but this is way overblown.

    I've seen people comparing this to the 1918 flu, which infected one out of every three persons in the world and killed at least fifty million. To date, only 5,000 people have died throughout the entire world. Each death is a tragedy, but we have to keep this in perspective. All together, there are only 414,000 laboratory confirmed cases.

    This is serious, of course. But it isn't the dire impending doom it's being made out to be. It surely isn't a national crisis. H1N1 hits earlier that normal flu, but it also peaks earlier - and it tends to peak six weeks after it first hits. That means it should be peaking in the next week or two.
  • The "national emergency stuff" is not PR-related hype. It is an administrative step taken so that hospitals and local governments are able "to speedily set up alternate sites for treatment and triage procedures if needed to handle any surge of patients..." (NY Times). Such a step is akin to the President declaring a particular geographic site a "disaster area" after a hurricane, say, or a tornado - the disaster-area designation makes available funds from FEMA towards immediate aid and future reconstruction.

    I am a bit confused about why people are worried, however. A normal flu season kills 36,000 and hospitalizes 200,000. This flu has killed 1,000 and has hospitalized 20,000. And they are saying it is already at its peak. Doesn't that mean it is less virulent than the "normal" seasonal flu? Can anyone explain this to me (nicely)?
  • archangel
    HI T-Steel and Sil, there was no shut down of the constitutional question thread from what I can tell. The comments came in pretty regular in timing as I just checked their dock times. It might have been a glitch with something else Sil. It wasnt TMV.

    thanks

    dr.e
  • Leonidas
    Here is the comment on this issue that I wasn't happy with:

    When Sen. Jon Tester (D-Mont.) had his turn to question Sebelus, he raised the issue of whether the United States was "entitled" to the vaccine more than other nations. "Why should we be more entitled, the U.S. be more entitled to that vaccine than some other country in the world?"


    Tester was reffering to Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius and her policy that:
    “What we said is once we have 40 million doses (of the vaccine), the donation can start,”

    Well I'll tell you what right, we are paying for it. In fact those 40 million doses do not meet the full US demand. So if you think about it, the government will be taking the tax money of some American citizen who could use the vaccine to pay for a foreigner to get the vaccine before they do. Sebelus's position here is bad enough, Testor's is ridiculous.
  • TheMagicalSkyFather
    What the hell, did he just zoom to the left of Fiengold?????
  • Leonidas
    I dunno, I had a pretty good impression of Testor before this and was very happy with him defeating Conrad Burns for the Senate seat. I thought him to be a reasonable moderate, I'm not so sure now.
  • DLS
    I thought the funniest part of this episode so far was that this declaration was made to streamline operations and reduce paperwork, etc., requirements. (So far, none in the media reporting that have felt moved to ask just what those requirements are and whether they are cost-effective or even reasonably justified.)
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC