An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Laura Bush Criticizes Excessive Partisanship, Praises Obama

iiiiiuuyynmkkj.jpg

Former first lady Laura Bush has lamented excessive partisanship and defended President Barack Obama in an interview with CNN that will probably cause her to be labeled a RINO who just doesn’t get in some parts of the talk radio political culture.

In fact, in the interview she shows that she not only does get it but is quite astute politically about the trending in Washington. She also provides an insight into one of the factors that perhaps caused her husband to adopt his own criticized political style.

Here are the relevant parts of the wide-ranging interview:

Former first lady Laura Bush praised the performance of her husband’s successor Monday, breaking with many Republicans in telling CNN that she thinks President Obama is doing a good job under tough circumstance.

She also criticized Washington’s sharp political divide during an interview covering a range of topics….

The typically reserved former first lady defended Obama’s decision to deliver a back-to-school speech to students, putting her at odds with many conservatives afraid that the president will use the opportunity to advance his political agenda.

“I think he is [doing a good job],” Bush said when asked to assess Obama’s job performance. “I think he has got a lot on his plate, and he has tackled a lot to start with, and that has probably made it more difficult.”

Michelle Obama is also “doing great,” she said, in part by turning the White House into a comfortable home for her family.

Bush didn’t completely dismiss the concerns of some conservatives but noted that controversial Education Department plans recommending that students draft letters discussing what they can do to help Obama had been changed.

“I think there is a place for the president … to talk to schoolchildren and encourage” them, she said. Parents should follow his example and “encourage their own children to stay in school and to study hard and to try to achieve the dream that they have.”

Bush indicated that she didn’t think it was fair for Obama to be labeled a “socialist” by critics and expressed her disappointment with the intensely polarized nature of contemporary American politics.

But it’s clear she has been thinking about the “why” of this:

Part of the reason for the polarization, she said, was the increase in the number of congressional districts dominated by either strongly conservative or liberal voters.

“We’ve seen that for the last eight years, certainly, and we’re still seeing it,” she said. “That’s just a fact of life.”

Bush conceded that after her husband was elected president, he was unable to replicate his success as governor of Texas in reaching across the aisle to Democrats.

“He was disappointed that that was not the way it worked out in Washington,” she said. “I’m sure President Obama didn’t expect it to be that way [either]. … All of us need to do what we can to come together on issues.”

What? Respecting and working with “the enemy?” (Time for Rush and Glenn to diss the Bushes as not being real Republicans..)

PERSONAL NOTE: I can attest to what she said about Bush in Texas. When Bush was governor I did many shows in Texas, once spending nearly 6 weeks in that wonderful state. Republicans and Democrats (and I met several Democrats who were extensively involved in state politics or had spouses deeply involved in it) praised GWB for his ability to talk to both sides and affability. One Democrat sadly noted:”The Governor has done some things right but the downside is that his being in office has led to so many Democrats being replaced by conservative Republicans in elections and by appointment.” Bush was considered a skilled politician who was well-liked and had expanded his party’s brand name due to the way he operated and the way Democrats responded to his overtures and olive branches.

Among other things in the interview, Laura Bush defended her husband’s record on foreign affairs and said former Vice President Dick Cheney has a right to speak out and defend the previous administration, and that his defense is appreciated.

What is the larger significance of her comments? Two things:

  • It further illustrates a divide between talk radio political culture Republicans and other Republicans who may passionately wish to see a Republican in office but aren’t willing to manufacture any incident to go after Obama or demonize him at the drop of a tin-foil hat. This divide could shift, depending on the issue or event. But there are still Republicans, thoughtful and/or highly ideological, who want to engage the Democrats on actual issues as opposed to trying to defuse Obama by triggering waves of outrage, demonization and denunciations on every issue that can remotely provide an opportunity.
  • It provides proof that there is indeed a moderate center in America that often transcends specific policies but involves the kind of democracy America has been and has long aspired to be and the way Americans deal with differences. In his must-read book, Leading from the Center: Why Moderates Make The Best Presidents, political scientist Gil Troy surprises some ideologues by including Ronald Reagan as a moderate President. Why? Because, Troy argues, Reagan was willing to ignore the most extreme elements of his party and stand up to their criticism by and reaching across party lines to try and pass some legislation.

    Additionally, it can be argued that there has long been an unspoken consensus on how American politics operates, with boundaries on what is sheer partisanship and what pushes the envelope. In the case of the school furor, the envelope was pushed off the table — and you can still read and hear all kinds of rationalizations now about what it was “really” about when the frenzy reached its peak. But, like Laura Bush, a large chunk of Americans — including thoughtful Republicans who may be centrists, progressives or conservatives — can’t have their memories reprogrammed by the revised or finessed assertions of a writer or a broadcaster now that the text of a speech praised by Newt Gingrich and Joe Scarborough has come out.

    Laura Bush’s interview is important because it underscores again how political parties and liberals and conservatives may passionately disagree and argue about the role of each party in creating the foreign policy and financial in which the United States is now mired.

    But there is a zone where partisanship goes beyond partisanship into something uglier that can backfire on those who indulge in it — and Laura Bush’s comments helped define it again.

    Hopefully, Laura Bush is for the verbal hits she’s likely to receive since he or she who disagrees must be discredited, demonized or defined in the eyes of some.

    Hopefully the “some” is fewer than the total.

    TROY’S BOOK IS HIGHLY RECOMMENDED:

    • TheMagicalSkyFather
      The Repubs went after Clinton and destroyed 8 years. The Dems went after Bush and destroyed 8 years. We could call a truce now, at least until we can get the mess that caused sorted out or we can go after Obama for 8 yrs and then the next Repub for another 8 but at some point we will not have a country left to bicker over. Many things have to get done and quickly or this nation will not survive, if we could come together and be respectful to one another and get them done we could go back to fighting but the last 16 yrs have nothing to do with reality. They have been propaganda wars and as such a bastardization of free speech, one that I will not infringe on legally but I may pop someone in the mouth for it if they do it near me because from my point of view they are sowing the seeds of our own demise in their hope to gain temporary power.
    • Father_Time
      You could always tell that she is more intellegent than her husband. Clearly she would have been a better President IMO.
    • D. E.Rodriguez
      Thanks Joe, I watched the interview. You summarized it perfectly.

      While I can not and will not say similar things about her husband, I have always considered (and continue to do so) Laura Bush to be a true Southern Lady.

      Dorian
    • CStanley
      Laura Bush shows herself to be a class act, as usual.

      She also touches on an important truth- the reason that neither Obama nor Bush has been able to 'change the tone' in DC or to be a 'uniter, not a divider'. Even when people are able to transcend partisanship on the local or state level, the differences on the national scene are way too broad. The sooner we accept that, and get back to debating real issues and philosophies instead of name calling, or hyperfocusing on how 'mean and ugly' those guys from across the aisle are, the sooner we can get down to the important business of the country's future.
    • DLS
      Laura Bush also reminds me to ask aloud how many Demmies as well as others now regret Hillary Clinton and more grown-ups, who learned harsh lessons about reality in the 1990s, aren't in charge.
    • smithmj
      Laura Bush is still a class act.
    • Rambie
      "Laura Bush shows herself to be a class act, as usual."

      Agreed CStanley, She's consistently shown herself to be a class act.
    • Rambie
      *sigh* I think she was talking to you DLS. I see you've kept your fingers in your ears and your eyes shut yet again.
    • D. E.Rodriguez
      "Laura Bush also reminds me to ask aloud how many Demmies as well as others now regret Hillary Clinton and more grown-ups, who learned harsh lessons about reality in the 1990s, aren't in charge."

      How nice it would be to one time, for a change, keeo one thread of discussion, classy, positive, upbeat and DLS-"Demmies"-free...
    • Lit3Bolt
      I don't like "Demmies." It sounds diminutive. How about "Dem-ons!"
    • kritt11
      If more moderates would speak up when the wing nuts are out of line, we might not be a 50/50 country. This is the most honest thing I've seen Laura Bush say.

      Moderates in this country are drowned out by all of the partisan bickering, and we as a country lose big time.
    • christoofar
      Quite a few good observations by the Former First Lady. We sure need more like her...on both sides of the aisle.
    • DLS
      Boy, the kids are touchy, still. Hopefully the health care stuff will be resolved and temper this soon.
    blog comments powered by Disqus
    © 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC