An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

George Will on Conservatives’ Criticism of Obama’s Iran Response

From the Department of Credit Where Credit Is Due:

YouTube Preview Image

And Will is not the only conservative pushing back against the Obama critics:

Stifling and corrupt religious autocracy has seen its international standing diminished, and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who is among other things a Holocaust denier, has in effect been rebuked by half his country, and through free speech, that most painful way to lose your reputation, which has broken out on the streets. He can no longer claim to speak for his people. The rising tide of the young and educated seems uninterested in reflexively hating the West and deriving their meaning from that hatred.

To refuse to see all this as progress, or potential progress, is perverse to the point of wicked. To insist the American president, in the first days of the rebellion, insert the American government into the drama was shortsighted and mischievous. The ayatollahs were only too eager to demonize the demonstrators as mindless lackeys of the Great Satan Cowboy Uncle Sam, or whatever they call us this week. John McCain and others went quite crazy insisting President Obama declare whose side America was on, as if the world doesn’t know whose side America is on. “In the cause of freedom, America cannot be neutral,” said Rep. Mike Pence. Who says it’s neutral?

This was Aggressive Political Solipsism at work: Always exploit events to show you love freedom more than the other guy, always make someone else’s delicate drama your excuse for a thumping curtain speech.

Mr. Obama was restrained, balanced and helpful in the crucial first days, keeping the government out of it but having his State Department ask a primary conduit of information, Twitter, to delay planned maintenance and keep reports from the streets coming. ,,,

Via Ben Armbruster at Think Progress.

  • Let us also consider that the current political climate in Iran is, in no small part, due to the intervention into Iranian politics by the American government.
  • GerSan
    Let us not. The current situation in Iran is largely taking place because the people are tired of living under a dictator. Much of the country was not yet born the last time America had anything to do with the country.
  • DaGoat
    I have mixed feelings on this. Intellectually and logically Obama is right, and that strong comments from the US may just make things worse for the protesters.

    On the other hand strong images such as the Iranian woman dying from her gunshot wound and protesters being beaten deserve strong responses. Obama's subdued statements (his second statement was a bit stronger) haven't reflected the horror many Americans feel seeing those images.

    I can't be critical of Obama on this but I can't be completely satisfied either.
  • casualobserver
    @Much of the country was not yet born the last time America had anything to do with the country.


    Do you mean to tell me Ruhollah Khomeini was not a CIA plant?
  • cassiewonders
    please forgive my lack of an operating set of caps keys...

    iran's history is so mysterious to americans that we tend to only digest what happens in that nation through the eyes of successive u.s. presidents. since the iran hostage situation in 79-80, americans have seen iran only as a nation under the rule of despots who hate the west. persia's glorious past and troubled empires are not on the conversational plates of most americans. that being said, obama is right to withhold stronger condemnation and let this crisis in iran play out under the control -- however tragically gained -- of the iranian people. some iranians might wish for the united states to show more visible support, but in the long run, they must take charge of their own country in their own way.
    i have often wondered how iraq would have changed had we never invaded that nation and allowed the iraqi people to eventually -- no matter how slow it seemed to the westerner's impatient character -- offload saddam hussein. i honestly feel that iraqis, a highly educated and sophisticated people -- would have made the decision to not tolerate appointed heirs to saddam's regime. it would have been messy and ugly and dangerous, but they would have shifted their nation's future on their own terms.
    thus i feel that way about iran now. the iranian people are strong and full of tradition and courage through centuries of both hardship and glory. they are suffering now. do we add to the suffering by compelling their corrupt government to portray us as somehow egging on the protests and thus stomping down even harder than they already have to silence their citizens...hard to say for sure, but all i believe tells me that each nation on this earth has to allow its own citizens the freedom to take down their dictators and end their own suffering. when those troubles do not breach foreign borders, but remain civil war or just civil strife, i believe we must let it all unfold as only the people of each nation believe it should -- for better or for worse.
  • With no offense intended to Kathy in particular, I have to go write a column about George Will and how tired I am of hearing condescending comments about his writing.
  • joeaudio
    George Will deserves nothing BUT condescension.
    He is a hack, a political tool.
    His lives in the same category of tools as the late Tim Russert, who's utility as a tool was revealed during the Libby trial. Cathie Martin testified that he (Russert) was a very reliable tool for "getting the message out."
    Any self respecting journalist would have retired and gone off to hide in a corner after that revelation.
    But not Timmy. Nor will George ever admit to being a tool.
    Show your respect for him if you want to be ridiculed by people who think, instead of regurgitating republic talking points.
    Tool or Fool, what's the difference?
  • DLS
    Psst! Hey, Kathy. George Will just wrote and had published a column about Obama and the "public option" obvious move toward federal health care for everyone.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC