An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Miss California and the Insanity of American Politics

A lot of you out there have finally and officially lost your minds. I can’t help you any more. I know that now, and I’m just going to have to accept it. Strangely enough, I had to learn this lesson at the alter of Carrie Prejean, first runner up in this year’s Ms. USA pageant. During her failed bid for the crown, the bejeweled baton and the flowers (or whatever it is they get at these things) she grabbed her fifteen minutes of fame by answering a question from Perez Hilton on gay marriage. She was instantly transformed into an internet political sensation and we all lined up on the familiar sides of the fence to pull her apart.

This is when the world turned on its collective ear. The conservative Republicans lined up on her side. She was being unfairly attacked for her core, conservative, Christian values by the godless, heathen faggots and commies of the Militant Left. But what was it that she really said?

I think it’s great that Americans are able to choose one or the other. We live in a land where you can choose same-sex marriage or opposite marriage,” Prejean said. “And you know what? I think in my country, in my family, I think that I believe that a marriage should be between a man and a woman. No offense to anybody out there, but that’s how I was raised.”

On his blog the next day, Hilton called Prejean a vulgar name and said that Miss USA is supposed to help unite Americans, not divide them. He suggested her response may have cost her the Miss USA crown.

One of the first comments I heard from outraged liberals was a complaint over her referring to same sex unions as “opposite marriage.” If you are riding on that particular bus, pull the emergency brake, get off and read once more what she actually said. “I think it’s great that Americans are able to choose one or the other. We live in a land where you can choose same-sex marriage or opposite marriage.

When she said “opposite marriage” she was talking about traditional, heterosexual marriage. It’s the “opposite” of same sex marriage.

She was also quite adamant about the her happiness over the fact that Americans “are able to choose.” She wasn’t, as I read it, trying to dictate to anyone else what they should do. She was rejoicing in Americans living in a land where they could choose. She simply indicated that she would most likely choose to marry a man. That’s how she was raised. Your mileage may vary.

How did we get here? How is the Right defending her and the Left attacking her? She posed topless for a bunch of pictures! I’m ALL in favor of that, thank you. She’s a model. She got paid to do that and did it without apology. She was an adult at the time. But look who is attacking her and who is defending her!

I’m living in Bizzaro World now. Somebody please tell me who put the brown acid in the coffee.

  • Silhouette
    I suggest we forget about the woman altogether and focus on the judge who "punished" her for one and only one reason: being opposed to his agenda.

    This is what fascists do. The real brain-twister is how the liberal left embraces fascism without the blink of an eye as long as its an agenda they're after. Personally, I find the middle-ground way more comfy, and sane...
  • roro80
    Huh??? Who thought "opposite marriage" meant same sex marriage? I dunno, that's not what anyone anywhere I've been has thought. Besides which, of course, unless you live in one of 4 states, you DON'T get to choose between same sex marriage and "opposite marriage". Kind of like Henry Ford's Model-T, ("you get to choose any color you want as long as that color is black") gay couples get the "choice" of not getting married, or getting married to someone they don't love. Of course, all this took on a fully different meaning, going beyond just standing up for what she believes, at the point when she decided to join the ranks as a lobbyist against gay marriage.

    Don't care a lick about whether or not she posed nude, but she should probably stay away from the whole right-wing meme of "if gays get married they'll encroach on my religion because serving gay people in the course of my job is against Christian values". You know, unless she thinks having a job that requires booby shots are within Christian values.
  • roro80
    Silhouette -- Do you know anything about pageant rules? All contestants have to sign on to agree to what the judges decide, no questions. Contestants are given the names of all judges beforehand, and one of the things that is recommended is that the contestants do some research on the judges beforehand. Perez Hilton, while being a sleezy jerk in so many ways, for long before being a Miss USA judge, was fully within his rights as judge to decide that her answer wasn't up to snuff, for any reason.
  • nahummer
    Tried my best to ignore the whole firestorm, easy enough from over here in Europe. But I did notice the same thing as mentioned in the article, that her response seemed to support same sex couples, at least choice. I do think that although most Americans don't ever travel outside their national borders, they do often cross state lines, therefore they do have the choice, wherever they live. Hilton was the wacko in my eyes and the liberals who jumped on her displayed all the intolerance I complain about when I see it from the right.
  • Thank you Jazz. Thanks so much for your post. This damn outrage (from the Left and Right) that comes from micro-parsing EVERYTHING someone says, with the added personal attacks for spice, is entirely too freakin' old, depressing, and tiring.
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    Let me just say that Carrie the Model and Joe the Plumber make a very eloquent, attractive, savvy, informed, persuasive, unprejudiced, open-minded, powerful, image-building couple for the Conservative cause.
  • StockBoySF
    Jazz, that's pretty much what I said in response to a post by mikkel on a related subject a couple days ago. My comment (in part):

    "I didn't comment on the original Ms. California flap because I was engaged in other things at the time. I saw it and thought, "big deal."
    ... "Personally I think this is the right answer (though I am confused how she can say in this land we can choose.... but then she goes on to say that "In my country.... I think [marriage] should be, between a man and a woman")."

    "The way I read this she is validating the right for others to choose and she is personally saying that she is for marriage between a man and a woman. This meets my criteria of having respect for others' beliefs."

    My position is that I don't care what you like or don't like as long as you allow me the same freedom. If you are a guy and don't believe in same-sex marriage or sex with another guy, then don't go to bed with another guy, or marry him. But also don't vote to limit my freedoms to choose. Don't mess with me and I won't mess with you.

    So yes, Jazz, I agree with you that it does seem like we are living in Bizarro World now.
  • mlhradio
    ...because it is so much easier to talk about a wannabe beauty queen and her irrelevant views on a minor social topic, than it is to actually discuss the important, pressing issues that America faces today.

    Now all we need is for some three-year-old little girl with blonde curls to go missing for a couple of days so that the media can hyperventilate and we can get distracted even more.
  • StockBoySF
    I wish people would leave her alone and relegate her to her proper place- as a beauty queen.
  • itinerant_interlocutor
    I believe that she was only 17 when she posed for the topless photos, which is obviously a problem, as she was not a legal adult. also, the terms of her contract stated that she needed to disclose whether she had ever posed nude or semi-nude for photos, and she failed to do so.
  • Mu111
    this thread is useless without pictures...
    I got the feeling that Perez Hilton was still smarting from the voter's decission on Prep 8, but this time he could do something about it and stick it to someone.
  • Rudi
    The problem is not with vacous beauty queens and failed plumbers; it's with the politicians and pundits which use these lightweights to push their agenda without a serious or intellectual argument to validate their positions. If I want serious conservative thought I'll read Larison. Let's not mix American Idol Politics with reasoned thought. Bill Buckley laughs...
  • FrequentPoster
    Excuse me, but the young model-ette has joined the anti-gay Mormon front group, National Organization for Marriage. Not exactly a paragon-ette of tolerance and acceptance. Then the nearly naked pic is published, which she explains as a modeling shot taken when she was a teenager. Now, now!

    Who's her sponsor? Is that an enhanced breast, at the age of 17? And how many "modeling" pictures feature a shampoo bottle tucked into the lower left-hand corner? I'm afraid that Carrie P. dug herself a bit deeper. And the website says they've got more pictures, so I'd say this story has some, er, legs.
  • DIPSONA
    A very good article on how the Judges in US behave.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC