An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

More Negative News Trouble For Sarah Palin

Yet another unflattering story is out about Republican Sen. John McCain’s Vice Presidential pick Gov. Sarah Palin — and whether or not it pans out and has “legs,” it’s yet one more indication of how the fact that while there is debate over how thoroughly McCain vetted Palin, she is most-assuredly going to be vetted by the mainstream media and tabloid press now. ABC News reports:

Gov. Sarah Palin is already facing ethical questions over her firing of the Alaska public safety commissioner, and now she faces questions over the firing of a longtime local police chief.

After taking over as Mayor of the small town of Wasilla, Palin fired the longtime local police chief. The former police chief, Irl Stambaugh says he was fired because he stepped on the toes of Palin’s campaign contributors, including bar owners and the National Rifle Association.

Stambaugh’s lawyer, William Jermain, says the chief tried to move up the closing hours of local bars from 5 a.m. to two a.m. after a spurt of drunk driving accidents and arrests.

“His crackdown on that practice by the bars was not appreciated by her and that was one reason she terminated Irl,” said Jermain.

In his 1997 lawsuit, Stambaugh also alleged that his stand on restricting concealed weapons upset the NRA.

“Mayor Palin has stated on several occasions that the National Rifle Association encouraged her to fire Chief Stambaugh because of his stance against the concealed weapons legislation,” the lawsuit claimed.

Palin says she was up against entrenched insiders when she was elected mayor of Wasilla in 1996.

“We had a lot of people that were kind of dead wood,” said Colleen Sullivan Leonard, a staff member in Palin’s office. “We needed people with new energy and a new vision.”

A judged ruled she had the right to fire the police chief for any reason. But, ABC notes, “Palin is now facing similar allegations in the state capitol, that politics played a role in her firing of the Alaska public safety commissioner, Walter Monegan.”

The significance of this story is not really the story in itself. It’s that an intensive media vetting has now begun — and since she is a new “product” on the national political scene, there could be a drip-drip-drip of stories heading up to the election. If the campaign or supporters try to squelch stories, that will become a story.

Although it has been reported that her partisan supporters will dismiss negative press as sexism on the part of the media, that charge won’t stick if there’s a steady stream of stories. And it’s unlikely to encourage swing voters who don’t already want her to vote for the GOP ticket.

  • elrod
    Charges of sexism only apply if the criticism of her delivered in a sexist fashion. There were certainly some comments re: Bristol's pregnancy that crossed the line into sexism, especially when some men questioned whether or not she could balance work and home life. But most of these criticisms have absolutely nothing to do with gender and everything to do with her fitness for office.
  • superdestroyer
    Is winning a lawsuit really a bad thing? If the Police Chief serves at the will of the mayor, then he should do what he is told. Do you really want to promote the idea that everyone in government can do what they want instead of following the future policies of the Obama Administration?
  • jwest
    It’s hard to imagine how Sarah Palin was able to become the most popular governor with the highest approval ratings in the country.

    Perhaps the people of Alaska need to read the NY Times more.
  • Silhouette
    It isn't so hard to understand why Palin was so popular in AK. People there respect and admire people with moxy, grit and who kick ass...even if it's "controversial" to the liberal left. AK is nothing like San Francisco.

    Attacking Palin on minutia like this will do no favors for the Obama campaign. None of it is enough to disqualify her. She's "queer" and she's here...lol...so get used to it. You won't make anyone hate her who doesn't already. She is the standing choice of VP for the GOP and that won't change.

    The issues of this campaign are more important. If you focus on them, Obama will win. If you focus on her, Obama will lose. Obama has already pissed off enough women. Attacking another woman as unfit to lead, no matter what, will at the very least conjure up old feelings of malice for Obama amongst former Clinton supporters...a sour taste in the mouth..

    The last thing he needs right now.
  • JSpencer
    18 months provides a very limited opportunity to discover ability for long-term delivery.

    It's clear to see the partisans don't want to see her be properly vetted. Fortunately the process will happen regardless.
  • joegandelman
    If you read the post again the issue is media vetting. This wasn't a post about her poll ratings or any other issue. I'm pointing to a process that has clearly begun, not doing a post about her qualifications or debating how popular she was in the polls.
  • jwest
    Joe,

    This was a simple statement of fact thrown in to add texture to your article.

    May I suggest that the first paragraph could have read:

    “ABC News has launched yet another attack on the most popular governor in the United States, potential Vice Presidential candidate Sarah Palin. Under the guise of “vetting”, yet another liberal media outlet has engaged in the politics of personal destruction.”

    Now, doesn’t that have a better flow to it?
  • elrod
    Palin is not anywhere near 80% approval rating anymore. Since Troopergate hit, her approval numbers are in the 60s and dropping.

    You want very high approval ratings? Look at John Hoeven of ND, Jim Manchin of WV, Phil Bredesen of TN, Jodi Rell of CT. Palin is no longer in that group.
  • jrysk
    Never mind all this nonsense. The real news is that Palin faked her own pregnancy. Trig is the son of Bristol, Palin's daughter, and Todd, Palin's husband. Trailer trash!
  • Potfry
    "perhaps the people if Alaska need to read the NY Times more."

    This could be, perhaps, my favorite unintentionally funny quote of the entire presidential campaign.
  • CStanley
    Elrod, do you have any links to polling info? There's at least one poll that was done just over a month ago that had her at 80% (down from apparently being in the 90s for most of her term prior to that.)
    http://www.haysresearch.com/oc072508.htm

    Are you saying that that poll's an outlier, or has she taken a nosedive just within 30 days? I've seen some reports that her approval ratings are now around 65%, which still isn't too shabby.
  • daveinboca
    Yep, the Dems and their compliant MSM outliers like this blog keep throwing up the mud on Palin & hoping it will stick to the wall.

    Where's the due diligence on Syrian billionaire Rezko & his contributions to Obama, the ethereal inexperienced pixie-dust candidate of the party of ginormous government that wants to take over our lives? Obama still hasn't repudiated Ayers. He still plays down his mother, whose death he refused to attend in '96 because of "schedule conflicts."

    Obama is totally unexamined moral rubbish, and Sarah will help keep the authoritarian big govt Dems from taking over our lives. The Dem MSM strains for the gnat with Sarah & swallows the camel with Obama.
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    Just one (or two) comment(s) on Sarah Palin and her teen age daughter's pregnancy:

    I agree that minor children of politicians should be off limits. But what I deeply resent is the hypocrisy of those who are now crying the;loudfst about "leaving the kids alone."

    For example, I heard Rush Limbaugh doing his hysterical, hypociritcal bit this morning about the evil left going after 17-year old Bristol.

    And lo-and-behold, in 1993 this man "on loan from Godddd," "America's youth role model," (before he got caught using illegal prescription drugs) etc., etc., said the followiong about the then 13-year old Chelsea Clinton:

    "Here is a Limbaugh joke: Everyone knows the Clintons have a cat. Socks is the White House cat. But did you know there is a White House dog?" And he puts up a picture of Chelsea Clinton.

    Talk about hypocrisy of the highest (or lowest) order.!
  • Jim_Satterfield
    CS, it's hard for a Republican in Alaska to not have good approval ratings. They have to work at it.
  • Obama is totally unexamined moral rubbish

    Totally unexamined? Even you can't possibly believe that.
  • Potfry
    Actually, it was through examining him that I arrived at the conclusion he was moral rubbish.
  • AustinRoth
    So, Rush (indefensibly, I admit) makes a joke in poor taste about Chelsea's looks, and you wish to equate that to the widespread rumor-mongering about Bristol and her Mom surrounding Trig, and now the slams against Bristol keeping her child (and the implications that somehow the new pregnancy is being faked to cover the truth about Bristol/Trig)?

    Neither issue covers itself with glory, but there is a huge gap in both the scale of or involvement, and the seriousness of the issues, of what is being contrasted.
  • AR,
    Don't forget, McCain made a similar joke himself ;-)

    In any case, I don't think one excuses the other. But then again I don't see Dems or lefties slamming Bristol for anything. Although any evidence is welcome, so I can add them to my douchebag list.
  • AustinRoth
    McCain's was funnier. :-)
  • Heh... not denying that :-)
  • kritt11
    AR and Chris

    Either the family's off limits or its not--- you can't get outraged in one case and snicker cynically about the other.
  • jwest
    D.E.,

    I’ll bet that if you track down the source of that Rush Limbaugh story, you’ll find it to false.

    It’s much more typical of a liberal website depiction of Rush.
  • CStanley
    kritt- I agree, the Chelsea Clinton jokes (and prior to that, Amy Carter) were indefensible.
  • AustinRoth
    kritt - I can too. I still say there is a world of difference between a tasteless (but funny) joke, and what has been tossed around about Bristol.

    Part of the reason is that I don't get my knickers tied up in knots about un-PC jokes, and see humor in a different light than the humorless PC crowd. Hell, I even know N-word jokes that I find funny!

    I also feel that Rush is much more indefensible, as he did tell his joke on air, as compared to McCain, who told a joke in private, then it was leaked to make him look bad.
  • Dan2
    jwest,

    You would lose that bet.

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/l...

    Kids should be off limits, for Dems and Reps alike.
  • jwest
    Dan2,

    I stand corrected.

    I’ve been listening to Rush for years and never heard him say anything like this.

    Oh well, it’s in the WaPost, so it must be accurate.
  • orrick
    I find it funny that the first thing that the RNC said upon disclosing that Bristal is Pregnant was. (Bristal had decided to keep the Baby) and marry the Father. The key words DECIDED TO KEEP. Funny if were up to her Mother that Decision would be outlawed.
  • Leonidas
    Yeah I'm still waiting for this polling data of Elrod's, the lowest approval rating I found for her is 76%.
  • GeorgeSorwell
    I agree with many people here that the children should be out of bounds.

    But it does seem to me that John McCain is trying to have both ways.

    On the one hand, his campaign is complaining about the negative coverage of the daughter's pregnancy.

    On the other hand, here he is, greeting the arrival of the daughter and baby-daddy to St Paul--as television cameras capture this public embrace.

    It's not just hypocritical, it's completely disgusting, in light of their own complaints about how these youngsters aren't public figures.

    I guess McCain feels he must be gaining some kind of political advantage.

    How does he get away with it?
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    You would not happen be a ditto head, would you?

    The post was not addressing the "scale of involvement," it was merely addressing the hypocrisy on the part of the Republicans' icon--their mascot, their idol, The One who gives them all their talking points.
  • AustinRoth
    Not in the least.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC