An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

The Obama Speech

Well, if you didn’t know where Barack Obama stood, you can’t say that after tonight. Obama did a very good job of defining who he was as opposed to John McCain.

My initial thoughts:

  • While I may disagree with Obama, it was nice to hear when he accepted the nomination. The Dream really was realized a little bit tonight.
  • Obama talked about tax cuts for 95 percent of Americans and then talked about a bevy of programs. He said that he would get money from closing tax loopholes and making government more efficient. Okay, but you are also going to have to raise taxes on those other five percent quite dramatically if you are going to provide all these government programs.
  • The capital gains tax cut on small businesses makes sense. Good idea.
  • Obama was misleading about McCain’s environmental policy. McCain is probably one of the greenest Republicans out there. If you don’t believe me, check out Republicans for Environmental Protection.
  • He did a good job of trying to be anti-Iraq War and yet also showed that he would be tough on going after Osama.
  • I liked his trying to extend an olive branch on those on either side of the so-called culture wars.
  • Did anyone else notice that those supposed “Greek columns” looked like the portico of the White House?
  • All in all, Obama gave a strong speech. He toned down on the soaring rhetoric that was light on definition and took the fight to John McCain.

    It’s up to McCain to offer his vision next week just a few miles down the road from where I sit in Minnesota. We shall see if he can top Obama.

    • JSpencer
      Calling McCain one of the greenest republicans out there isn't a very impressive measure, except perhaps to other republicans. Rather than checking his creds at a partisan site, I suggest going to the independent league of conservation voters site. There we can see his environmental voting record is significantly less impressive than Obama's.
    • Leonidas
      Good commentary. Its funny to see Democrats attack McCain after years of praising him, and to watch them try to evoke the McCain=Bush myth. When they are confident enough in themselves maybe they can get around to an actual Obama vs McCain discussion, but I wouldn't count on it.

      McCain has voted with Republicans 83% making him the 65th most partisan Senator. Biden has voted with Democrats 96.6% of the time making his the 8th most partisan senator and Obama isn't far behind at 96% making him the 11th most partisan. So where is their self criticism? Does Obama = Pelosi? Does Biden = Reid? No thats not a message they want to get out is it?
    • GeorgeSorwell
      Give me a break!

      McCain has voted with Bush 90% of the time since 2001. He brought up his average by voting with Bush 95% of the time in 2007--the year he really had to pander to the base.

      McCain is pretty much the same as Bush!

      Annual averages since 2001 available at the link!!!
    • jchem
      I wouldn't be one to dispute McCain voting with Bush 90% of the time (I mean, facts are facts!). But Leonidas brings up a good point about how often Obama and Biden vote with their party (Pelosi and Reid). I wouldn't be surprised if we here more of this next week. That would be a sure fire way to rally their base.
    • GeorgeSorwell
      If you think Republicans have done a poor job leading our country, why would you vote for more of the same?

      Facts are truly facts.
    • jchem
      George,

      Where did you get the idea that I was going to "vote for more of the same"? I just pointed out how often the D's vote with each other and how I think the R's could use that next week. I mean, it's not like Pelosi and Reid are all that popular either.

      And speaking of facts:

      "When doing so, they [voters] may wish to consider that Obama's votes were in line with the president's position 40 percent of the time in 2007. That shouldn't be terribly surprising. Even the Senate's Democratic leader, Harry Reid of Nevada, voted with Bush 39 percent of the time last year...So to sum up, McCain has indeed voted to support the unpopular Bush 95 percent of the time most recently, but less so in earlier years. And Obama has voted pretty close to 100 percent in line with fellow Democrats during his brief Senate career."

      http://www.factcheck.org/askfactcheck/is_it_tru...

      It's obvious you have your preferred candidate; and that's great. But I have a hard time understanding how I can be accused of "wanting more of the same" by simply asking questions about both sides and looking for facts. Call me a right winger if you want because I don't share your zeal. True "moderation" indeed.
    • So where is their self criticism? Does Obama = Pelosi? Does Biden = Reid?


      Oh no... I bet Obama is quakin in his boots right now. Don't you dare compare him to two politicians that most people don't know!

      Meanwhile, Bush is very well known and absolutely despised by most of the country.
    • jchem
      "Don't you dare compare him to two politicians that most people don't know!"

      So Pelosi being the first female speaker of the House didn't garner any attention? And Reid being the Senate Majority Leader of a Senate with one of the lowest approval ratings in history?

      http://www.realclearpolitics.com/epolls/other/c...

      I guarantee you that between now and November, the Right's mouthpieces will make sure everyone in the country knows who they are.
    • jchem,
      Bush and Cheney have succeeded in "deballing" Congress. No one knows or cares who Pelosi and Reid are. I know some pretty liberal people, and after a week of Biden coverage, they still don't even know who he is.
    • jchem
      "I know some pretty liberal people, and after a week of Biden coverage, they still don't even know who he is."

      Great point Chris. But I'll put my money on the Repubs making hay out of Congress' performance since the Dems took over and their mouthpieces will chant the mantra. Bush will certainly dog them, but that won't stop them from bringing it up.
    • jchem,
      I don't mean to say that the GOP wont try, I just don't think it will be effective, or at least nearly as effective as the Bush albatross.
    blog comments powered by Disqus
    © 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC