An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

DNC Protesters: Constitutional Rights Denied or Citizens’ Rights Denied?

Some say protesters, such as Code Pink and Recreate 68 and others, including small church groups and other groups no one has ever heard much about, are being denied their constitutional rights of freedom to assemble, and freedom of speech. Many protest groups have sued to gain access to convention gathering sites in Denver so they can be ’seen’ and ‘heard’ by conventioneers, pols, and newsmedia. Up close.

Like abortion protesters, kind of. That close.

But the big D doesn’t want that kind of closeness.

Thus, it seems, some in the city of Denver and DNCC seem to think the protesters ought be marginalized– a word usually anathema to Dems– and instead be kept to outlying portions of Denver…. out of sight of the old stadium where Obama will formally ‘accept’ the nomination, and away from conventioneers…. and away from the Capitol building (which is in downtown Denver) and away from the Convention building. Just generally, away from , instead of “fish-eye lens” up close.

The Denver Manager of Safety says it’s for safety’s sake. Some say Denver can’t handle the crush. One wonders at the wisdom of bringing in a huge convention where people are worried about ‘the crush’ of humanity. Denver is a small city laid out on a grid with skyscrapers on both sides of the downtown streets. These create tall, close-walled canyons with no easy ingress or egress…for gathering together, for marching—for hurrying toward or away from, if need be.

Freedoms of speech and assembly motivated Martin to cross the bridge even though there were NO concerns for the safety the marchers via the City government of Selma. I wonder if anyone reads history any more, learning form previous fatally chosen trajectories by ‘those in charge.’

The protesters have filed for and been granted all the proper permits months ago. It appears the protesters have attempted to follow the letter of the laws of Denver County in negotiating their presences.

But,
Last week The Mayor decreed that the protesters, some 50k expected, would not be allowed to sleep in the park.
The protesters said, Really? Watch this. We’re sleeping in the park.
Mayor Hickenlooper, said, Really? Watch this… we’ll turn all the sprinklers on.
The protesters said, Really? Watch this… we’ll overturn the dumpsters over the sprinkler heads to let them drown the grass underneath them

and so it goes. Or doesn’t. Love.

Denver is a small town in many ways. Good people. Often, laid back. Most of us have at least two pair of cowboy boots in the closet even though we no longer run cows.

But something else is at play here. Profound scripting by and of the DNCC in many ways I’ll be detailing more about as the week goes on. Certainly what has been built up here in Denver by the DNCC and the Mayor’s office makes it seem that the Democratic Convention is no longer a “people’s event,” but rather a petrified diorama that people are invited to come “look at.” But only up close…IF they promise to behave in a certain codified way. And then only a coveted few. A lottery of sorts for public attendance.

Those of us who live in the Rockies have listened to these back-and-forth arguments about protesters going on and on and ON for months now… for instance: Yes you can march, but only to the corner of ‘walk and don’t walk’ a quarter mile shy of the convention center, completely out of range of the crowd. Then you have to stop right there and turn around and go back the way you came.

I recognize the need for safety. And order. I’ve many friends in both PD and FD who are stalwart souls. I want them and the conventioneers and the protesters, all to be safe too. But, there’s something odd about the Demmies seeming to be so concerned that they begin treating valid protesters as sort of a “pre-criminal” element, if not some kind of ‘repeat offender’ organism.

Maybe it’s a clang because the generation of Demmies who are now in their late 40s, 50s and early 60s enjoined thousands of protests for the last many years, beginning with civil rights workers ‘rights, and coming straight through to war protests in this time. Those Dems’ fathers and mothers often marched on strikes with unions, or while attempting to gain the right to have or keep a union.

Protesting is in the Demmies’ blood.

Surely political evolution isn’t based on ‘I got mine, but I will impede yours.’ Vox populi re Constitutional rights, that is.

  • Rambie
    I remember that GOP convention did pretty much the same thing in 2004 (or was it in 2006) by having the designated protest zones blocks away from the convention site. It was the one in New York if memory serves.

    I'll use a few of the counter arguments from before: Are these groups being denied somewhere to assemble? There is nothing in the constitution about distance in the right to assemble.

    If a case can be made that this isn't for safety sake then I'll agree it smells of dirty tricks, but may not be a constitutional issue.
  • StockBoySF
    Yup, sounds positively Republican and echoes of Bush's and McCain's town hall meetings where only the faithfully pledged are allowed in.

    If Denver can't handle the conventioneers and concomitant folks, then Denver should not have encouraged the Dems to choose them as the convention city.
  • RememberNovember
    Must be the thin air up there.
  • I wonder if, in the future, kids will use the snotty comeback "It's a free country!"
  • spirasol
    Well the more one knows the less likely one is willing to go out there and protest. The degree of police and FBI infiltration, pre-event leader arrests, pepper spray, rubber bullets, shock sticks, gas, batons and other bizarre forms of weapons used in ways most dangerous (pepper spray at point blank range), aggressive, authoritative cops, random arrests. And fences, we now love fences, imaginary and real ones, divide and conquer, get 'em up there, fences everywhere.

    AND if you are willing, presumably to protest the long-past-gone transition of this country from a representative democracy to an oligarchy, facist in leaning, funded by corporations that manage to not pay taxes-- well if you are still willing, and apparently some are, you will be placed in an overly small space far from the object of protest where you will be filmed and photographed for purposes of protecting the country from domestic terrorists. AND when all is said and done, major media will make mere mention of your effort, with a brief video showing hippie types being escorted away in view of a broken window. And of coarse someone will be arrested for the unpatriotic act of burning the flag (now against the law, I believe) while around the corner, the dems, and by extension, the rest of congress pick apart what remains of the constitution. Folks, like it or not, we have wandered far past the point of protest, into the crazed idealistic frame of revolution. Did I say that? no, no, only kidding. I'm too fat. too old, to slow, to alone and lonely..too illogically intuitive with messy feelings.........
    This message sponsored by the committee to elect McCain
  • Ghostdreams
    Yup, yup. The GOP did the same and worse last cycle around. Not to mention they kicked people from their own party OUT of the convention.
    Log Cabin Republicans were told that the GOP didn't want them OR their money, so OUT they went (Log Cabin Repubs are a gay republican group and, of course, the GOP under Bush certainly didn't want THOSE kind of people there).
    At the rate we're going, there won't BE any debate about anything in the world of USA politics. Everything will be decided before hand, and although the people will be allowed to vote, their votes won't really count. Everything will be decided by the electoral college and the vote's cast by the regular American won't be worth the price of a cup of coffee....oh wait ..
    That's happened already, huh? :P
    Freedom was such a great idea. Too bad it's getting swept under the rup and trampled to death. :(
    Just my two cents worth,
    Ghost
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC