An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Ponder This: McCain on the Conflict between Georgia and Russia

He…accused Putin of wanting to restore Russia to the days of czardom, when a monarchy exerted broad control over parts of Asia and eastern Europe.

“I think it’s very clear that Russian ambitions are to restore the old Russian Empire. Not the Soviet Union, but the Russian Empire.” (CNN)

Cf. John McCain is your new jalopy

  • pacatrue
    I'm not completely sure McCain's wrong. I take his distinction between the Russian Empire and USSR to be one of political governance, meaning Putin (who's really still in control) doesn't want any socialist style government, but he does want a strong Russian nation flexing influence around the world through commercial and military might (sort of an American neocon view... he throws out expecting controversy) and authoritarianism at home. However, I've seen no signs yet that Putin wants to retake places like the Ukraine or Latvia. Instead, he prefers that they are "in the sphere of influence" and take broad orders from Moscow.
  • DLS
    Ukraine (and Belarus) is more likely to be snagged or strong-armed into compliance than the Baltics. The New York Times reports (and I agree) that the West will likely press first and foremost to retain Western allegiance in the Baltics and then press hard in central Europe (Poland and Czech Republic, etc.) to combat the menace there.

    You know, we really should have the Russians kicked out of Kaliningrad (Konigsburg). That as well as expelling them from Georgia would be befitting.

    We aren't going to do that, though. Not only because it's excessive but because we cannot and even if we could, we would not. Too bad. Bruno needs to be taken down.
  • Read the real smart people who actually know stuff about that area of the world. Given that the Russian military's budget is about $33 billion dollars (probably one-tenth of its budget in 1988), and given that the U.S. (the self-proclaimed last superpower) has at least $623 billion allocated for our military, I doubt all the hyperbole from John McCain and clueless news types who holler "The Russians are coming! The Russians are coming!" is really true. Russia hasn't got the money, the equipment, or the trained soldiers to dominate like it did during the Cold War. Regional power, sure. Superpower, no.

    P.S. I don't mean to be realistic, DLS, but you and what army? (Actually, I do mean it.) The U.S.? The ones who are in Iraq and Afghanistan? The E.U.? If they did that, they might as well slit their throats, given that Russia has control over about 25% of Europe's oil and natural gas supply, and has shown willingness to use that control as a weapon before.
  • DLS
    We aren't going to do much about Russia. Too weak and they are an ally against terrorism, at least nominally.
  • DLS
    (We're too weak)
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC