An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Poll: Independent Voters Unenthusiastic About Obama And McCain

This was supposed to be the Presidential year when independent “swing” voters would be excited about having two purportedly less-traditional politicians to choose from — Democratic Sen. Barack Obama and Republican Sen. John McCain. But a new poll suggests that independent voters are not particularly enthusiastic about either one of them.

This political tidbit is noted by the Boston Globe which points to a new poll making the rounds about the political enthusiasm gap:

The oft-noted enthusiasm gap that favors Democrat Barack Obama becomes starkly apparent in a new poll out today.

But the more telling finding in the survey by the Associated Press and Yahoo News is that many independents — who typically decide presidential elections — are not very excited and are very undecided.

Only 21 percent of independent voters — being targeted by both Obama and Republican John McCain — said they find the election interesting — down from 31 percent in November — and just 7 percent say it’s exciting. About a quarter support each candidate, about 40 percent remain undecided, and half say they could still change their minds.

This is why both campaigns see independent voters as a potent group that must be wooed and won. But both campaigns will have trouble doing this as they do what politicians according to the conventional political wisdom must do once they win primaries: shore up their bases and yet try to expand their bases. In Campaign 2008 this means you see Obama largely tip-toeing to the middle and McCain tip-toeing with one foot to the middle and his other to the right — which can prove awkward, indeed.

The net result for both: the two candidates are generating so many flip-flops now that their output threatens to shut down an outsourced flip-flop factory in China.

The other result: the carefully-nurtured images of two different yet not totally dissimilar candidates (the 2000 McCain Maverick, and the pre-nomination-locked-up Obama Change) are now fading away as they become perceived as two politicians largely practicing politics as usual.

And this is likely to continue: both sides are about to go negative, bigtime…

The poll also underscores again Obama’s problem with some Hillary Clinton supporters:

The poll also found that supporters of Hillary Clinton are still cool toward Obama, who is trying to unite Democrats. Just 12 percent of former Clinton loyalists say they are excited about the campaign, one-third the excitement level among Obama’s longer-term backers.

And then there’s the supposed lead of this poll — which actually amounts to a big “NO DUH!”

Among each candidate’s core supporters, Obama’s — African-Americans, Democrats, and liberals — are more enthusiastic and have become more excited about the race since fall than whites, Republicans, and conservatives, who tend to support McCain.

Even though their impact is pooh-poohed by some partisans on both sides (until the votes are actually counted and it shows their impact) both camps will be going after independent voters.

Who are now apparently concluding this is just one more typical political year dominated by typical politicians.

  • FlaLady
    The more I read about Obama, the more convinced I am he is a total fraud! He has spent his entire career in preparation for being elected President, without regard to the office itself, but just to satisfy his enormous ego! From taking credit for Emil Jones legislation to plump up his skeletal resume, to hiring 300 foreign policy advisers to prepare his talking points on a daily basis. They even provide him with possible questions and appropriate answers! Can this man even think for himself? Whose decisions will he be making if he gets elected POTUS? Whose puppet is he? Unfortunately, I don’t believe he cares about America or Americans. He is just in it to feed his already over-inflated ego. No experience, no qualifications, NOBAMA.
  • PWT
    The only people that are enthusiastic about this election are the Obama supporters (Barack Straps).
  • jwest
    It is true that independents will decide the outcome of this election.

    These are people who don’t pay attention during the primaries, who (according to Pew Research) are in the group of citizens that don’t know who the vice president is, who Nancy Pelosi is, or who the governor of their state is.

    They will have to choose between a guy who knows a guy who says we are in a “mental recession”, or the guy who attended a church for 20 years led by some crazy black preacher shouting “God Damn America”. Picture both of these commercials running every two minutes between the convention and the election.

    Remember, these aren’t Keith Olbermann viewers. They couldn’t tell you the three branches of government if you waterboarded them. They don’t know or want to know anything about politics and the only thing they are sure of is that they are going to vote in November.

    Good luck with these voters.
  • SteveK
    FlaLady and PWT have written the perfect comments to this style of "bait the reader to look moderate" journalism... Silly replies full of mean spirited BS.

    "Barack Straps" what a "McCain in the ass" comments like this are PWT... can't you do better?
  • elrod
    Here's a thought about Independents. They are different as a whole now than a year ago because of the long primary season. Big polls have shown a major shift in party ID over the last two years where Dems have a 10 point edge on Republicans, with Independents somewhere in between. What does this mean?

    It means that a lot of former Democratic-leaning Independents now call themselves Democrats after having participated in the Democratic primary. If they supported Obama (as most did) then they are very fired up about the election. Many of these folks still call themselves Independents, though, even if they are much more closely linked to Obama than the Republicans.

    If they supported Clinton, they probably don't support Obama at all. The key is that a big chunk of the "Democrats" not supporting Obama are actually former Independents who aligned with the Dems recently to vote for Clinton in the primary. The number of lifelong Democrats not supporting Obama is extremely small. And I bet many of these Clinton Independents have gone back to Independent status and are part of the "frustrated" members of that group. I see them sitting the election out, however, rather than voting for McCain.

    Then there are the Republicans who quit their party over Bush's failures. They fall into two major groups: first are conservatives angry at Bush's spending, religious right ties, and incompetence. For many of them McCain is the only Republican they would support. They are newly Independent and are excited for McCain. But they think the GOP needs a real makeover. The other group includes paleo-con Republicans angry at Bush over the war. McCain, to them, is actually worse than Bush because of his neocon beliefs. These conservative Independents are unenthusiastic about the election though some may be crossing to Obama.

    Then there are the uninformed who don't even think about politics enough to identify with a party. They will never be interested.

    Finally, there are the true swing independents. How large this group is is a constant question among analysts. Most people believe it's around 8% a most.

    When Independents are seen this way, the numbers make sense. The real issue is probably turnout. If Obama consolidates Dems and breaks even on Independents, he will win easily.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC