An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Buying Votes

The Sunlight Foundation profiles an example of how special interests trade cash for influence in Republicans Demand Campaign Cash for Votes

1) From the congressional Republican standpoint, it looks like they are getting stiffed in a tough election year by telecom companies even though they are voting to support the bottom line of those same companies. The Republicans expect that their support, by casting votes, should lead to campaign contributions. Conclusion: Voting a certain way gets you money.

2) From the telecom company perspective, Republicans are going to vote to support their interests no matter what, while Democrats are more likely to oppose them. Some of these Democrats could be swayed with cash in their coffers. So the money obviously goes to the members you need to influence, i.e., the Democrats. Conclusion: Money buys you votes.

No one is surprised by this standard operating procedure in government. What is fascinating are the semantic gymnastics legislators go through to ignore these shenanigans. A candidates needs money to run, and the source of those funds are the special interests who stand to benefit or lose by how a representative votes. I read one reform proposal in which special interests would make their contribution to a candidate through an escrow fund that would veil the source of the funds to help break the cycle of quid pro quo. There may be many ways of skinning the cat of special interest influence. But it is important that we keep skinning.

  • Veiling the source of the funds would require the cooperation of the donators to work? Right?
  • DLS
    We already know McCain-Renzi wasn't going to happen this year. [grin]
  • PaulSilver
    Veiling the source of the funds would require the cooperation of the donators to work? Right?

    The idea is that a donor can give money to a candidate who they support, but the candidate would not know who gave them the money. I imagine that a donor could simply write a note saying "Hey Bob I just donated $10,000 to you". Perhaps the escrow agent could release the funds in such a way that the link to the donor is harder to make.

    This is not my favorite remedy but I find it valuable to consider all the angles. My favorite so far is Public Financing in proportion to the number of small donors a candidate can attract, along with funds to match third party campaigns. With the Source of the funds mostly from the Media industry who are ultimately the main recipients of the campaign expenditures.
  • pacatrue
    Veiling the donation is interesting. Is it completely antithetical to the idea of sunshine reform in which we at least know which donors the politician is in the pocket of? I can't make them work together. I also can't see how veiling donations could possibly work with fund raising, in which the fund raisers primary goal is to build a personal relationship between the donor and the cause to be supported.

    This is sort of an aside, but Bush became almost legendary in his first 4 years by being able to hold dinners at $1000 a plate and packing the house. This had always been done by both parties, but the RNC became kings of it for some time. I assume Obama must do the same, but does he? Or is it almost all through the internet for him? Anyone know?
  • MSNBC reports half of Obama's take is from one million plus individuals giving average $50 donations, half from donations of $1k-2.3k
  • kritt11
    Greendreams- That is one of Obama's most appealing qualities. My biggest gripe with the GOP (besides rubberstamping Bush policies and appointees) has been their willingness to back industrial interests over consumers at every opportunity. They are forced to do this because their voting patterns do not benefit the average citizen---which is why their donations from individual donors are way down.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC