An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

McCain Gets Flagged in South Carolina

01aconfedflag.jpgI will begin this post by noting that I am not qualified to write about the quadrennial controversy regarding the Confederate battle flag flying over the South Carolina statehouse.

This is because even though I was born and bred in a border state (Delaware) my sympathies, which have only deepened over the years, lie with the Union.

And that I still don’t understand the Viagra-like kick that some South Carolinians and certain other people of the white Southern persuasion get over seeing a Confederate flag flying in town squares, over football stadiums, on many a pickup truck rear window and at the occasional pig roast.

While it took a suspension of belief for me to come around to the view that displaying a Confederate flag is not necessarily endorsing slavery and the other less savory aspects of the Old South, which was helped along nicely by reading Tony Horwitz’s marvelous Confederates in the Attic, I now have a more nuanced view of a controversy that is again a tiresome staple of campaigning for tomorrow’s South Carolina Republican primary.

But nevertheless am offended that my main Republican man, John McCain, is being dogged by protesters waving Confederate flags in his face when he’s out on the stump because they are (still) in a lather over his brave call after the 2000 primary to remove the Confederate flag from the top of said statehouse.

McCain, who seems to get hung up on that principle thing more than most of his GOP presidential wannabe peers, does not pretend that the flag issue hasn’t been damaging to him:

“Probably the worst piece of advice I’ve ever given to myself . . . And I decided that I would say it’s not an issue I should be involved in, that it should be decided by the people of the state of South Carolina. I knew it was a symbol that was offensive to so many people. And afterwards, I went back and apologized. But it was needless to say, by saying that I wouldn’t have anything to do with an issue like that was an act of cowardice.”

More here.

  • pennywit
    The irony is that any Southerner who calls that flag the "Stars and Bars" doesn't understand his own heritage. The Star and Bars was this flag. The flag flying above the Capitol (and popularized by the Dukes of Hazard) is the Confederate battle flag.

    And, honestly, I'm more or less with McCain's original position on that. If the people of South Carolina want their Capitol roof topped with a flag that symbolizes racism for millions and millions of Americans -- not to mention a substantial chunk of South Carolinians -- then that is South Carolina's business.

    --|PW|--
  • shaun
    Pennywit:

    Thank you for the clarification on the flag. Fix made.
  • pennywit
    Shaun -- Not a problem. Anytime you need an insufferable pedant, I'm your man.
  • DLS
    The Confederate battle flag is another demon of the PC and far Left.

    It's South Carolina's business alone.
  • DLS
    And there's no excuse for going there and seeing the South for yourself, rather than foolishly believe leftist myths. Among the places I've lived is Atlanta -- the city itself is invaded by Northeasterners and transplants from as far away as California, but it's a fine place (in the center of the region) from which to travel around and see the region for yourself. (I've gone as far as Florida and back in one day, and New Orleans and back in one day, used to get away routinely to Chattanooga, etc.).
  • kritt11
    DLS- If you take that to an extreme- then slavery was a states rights' issue, as was civil rights and voting rights. The South has come a long way, but very slowly. The Confederate flag is a hurtful reminder to many of slavery and the Jim Crow years. States rights was code for segregation, and that flag was a symbol of an unequal society. The flag belongs in a civil war museum, not at the statehouse.
  • Jim_Satterfield
    The South hasn't come that far or else they wouldn't insist on flying a Confederate battle flag that insults millions. And don't believe a word that DLS types on the issue. Been in the South, seen it and my relatives that still live there. Yep, racism still there. Worship of the Confederacy, ditto. But of course DLS ascribes all of it to bigoted leftists. No myths, folks. Just the facts. DLS is as accurate on this issue as he is on the influence of the Religious Right on the Republican Party.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC