Whether calculated or not, Hillary Clinton’s comments while appearing to fight away the tears has incited a global debate. According to this editorial from Switzerland’s Le Temps newspaper, ‘for a female politician, it may also prove a persistent difficulty to prove that her expression of emotion is not a measure of her incompetence.’
By Stéphane Bussard
Translated By Kate Davis
January 10, 2008
Switzerland – Le Temps – Original Article (French)
Will the sudden outpouring of emotion from Hillary Clinton be a turning point in the American presidential campaign? Under the bright lights a few hours before the Democratic primary in New Hampshire, the senator from New York expressed her commitment to America with a tremor in her voice and eyes on the verge of tears WATCH . The country’s media has dissected this moment in the battle for the Democratic nomination, since up to that point, Hillary Clinton was perceived as a cold and calculating politician – an attitude that contrasted with those of Barack Obama or John Edwards, who don’t hesitate to talk openly of their family woes. Now Hillary has broken with the image of an American Iron Lady, stoic in the face of her health care reform failure or the scandal of the Lewinsky affair. This radical change in style, whether spontaneous or calculated, played a role in the candidate’s victory, which contradicted very unfavorable polls. But it doesn’t explain everything.
Fascinated by Obama, who in comparison to George Bush most fundamentally reflects a new beginning, we too-hastily brushed aside the aspects related to race and gender. According to Gloria Steinem, America’s leading feminist figure, Hillary Clinton could never have been able to adopt the public style of Obama – or of her husband Bill – without provoking the ire of the Washington establishment. When a woman cries in public, it’s a sign of weakness. For a man, it is a sign of courage.
Hillary’s toughness could perhaps be a result of a pathological thirst for power. All indications are that after her defeat in Iowa, she seems to have cracked. But for a female politician, it may also prove a persistent difficulty to prove that her expression of emotion is not a measure of her incompetence. Her support for the Iraq War is, according to some, is a way to prove her “masculinity.”
Founder and Managing Editor of Worldmeets.US