Pages Menu
TwitterRssFacebook
Categories Menu

Posted by on Nov 21, 2014 in Immigration, Law, Politics | 23 comments

Conservative Legal Scholars: Obama’s Immigration Move Legal

Kevin Drum reports on conservative legal opinion on the President’s immigration move on Mother Jones. [icopyright one button toolbar]

I’ve been paying only moderate attention to the whole issue of President Obama’s executive order on immigration, and it’s only over the past few days that I’ve started trying to learn more about the legal issues involved. And I confess that I’ve been a little surprised by what I’ve discovered. As near as I can tell, both liberal and conservative legal scholars—as opposed to TV talking heads and other professional rabble-rousers—agree that Obama has the authority to reshape immigration enforcement in nearly any way he wants to.

 

It’s an open question whether Obama’s actions are politically wise. It might force Republicans into an uncomfortable corner as they compete loudly to denounce Obama’s actions, further damaging their chances of appealing to Hispanics in future elections. Alternatively, it might poison any possibility of working constructively with congressional Republicans over the next couple of years, which might further degrade Democratic approval ratings. There’s also, I think, a legitimate question about whether liberals should be cheering an expansion of presidential power, whether it’s legal or not.

 

That said, Obama’s actions really do appear to be not just legal, but fairly uncontroversially so among people who know both the law and past precedent. Republicans may not like what Obama is doing, and they certainly have every right to fight it. But they should stop spouting nonsense about lawlessness and tyranny. That’s just playground silliness.

Cross-posted from The Sensible Center

http://thesensiblecentercom.blogspot.com/2014/11/conservative-legal-scholars-obamas.html

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com