Republicans De-hero Scott Brown: Soon Just Another “RINO”?

scott_brown1.jpg

Frank Sinatra had that song “That’s Life” (watch it here) with the lyric “You’re riding high in April, shot down in May.” Switch around the months and it seemily to applies to Massachusett’s Senator Scott Brown. But he’s not being shot down by Democrats now as much as by GOPers.

Why? Brown’s election was greeted by Republicans and conservatives in particular as doubly delicious: he got the late Ted Kennedy’s old Senate seat (insisting it was the people’s seat, but in fact Kennedy was elected to fill it so it was Kennedy’s seat), vowed to halt health care reform by giving the GOP just enough numbers, and was photogenic. Within hours of his election, some Republican talking heads suggested Brown could be on a 2012 GOP ticket. And Brown started shopping around for a book deal for his bio (who cares if he hadn’t served three months in the Senate yet?)

But once in, he voted like a RINO on a key vote (some Republicans could look the other way on that) and a funny thing happened to the Republicans on the way to burying health care reform: it rose again out of the conventional wisdom grave (some Republicans can’t look the other way on that).

And now for a variety of reasons there is buyer’s remorse about Brown: emotional buyers’ remorse from GOPers who hoped having Brown fill Ted Kennedy’s seat would mean a political turning point and beginning of the political end for Barack Obama and the Democratic party majority. More literal REAL buyers’ remorse from those who gave money to Brown but now feel it meant little in the end. Meanwhile,several analysts pointed out an irony: Brown’s election shell shocked the Democrats, but it also caused them to take a deep breath and press harder than ever for health care reform one final time.

The best summary — one that needs to be read IN FULL — is from Jules Crittenden. Crittenden not only summarizes why Brown seems to have fallen from grace but he also provides a meaty blog roundup of health care related posts from conservative bloggers.

Crittenden also has some wise words suggesting that perhaps it’s time for the GOP to extricate itself a bit from the talk radio political culture. Here is one paragraph:

As surprising and unexpected as Scott Brown’s win in Massachusetts may have been to the Democrats, the lesson in the Democrats’ last minute, unexpected victory for the GOP is exactly the one Brown administered on a hapless Martha Coakley in January. If conservatives think America is full of rage and Congress will be theirs in November, and they plan on taking that for granted, they might be in for a surprise. November is a long way off. Talking health care for seven months when people have had to listen to it for a year might work, but I doubt it. If it was my campaign to take over Congress, I’d talk fiscal responsibility and government accountability. Everyone will know exactly what you are talking about. Elected leaders that don’t listen, spend too much and think they know better than you do.

Read it from beginning to end.

P.S. Unless his present status among Republicans changes (and it could in this mega volatile political climate — Sinatra’s song also talks about “pick myself up and get back in the race”), should we take bets now for how long it’ll take for Brown’s new book to be remaindered at Borders if it’s published?

When he signed he first floated the book deal he was hot stuff; right now to many GOPers he’s tepid room temperature.

Now you can follow Joe Gandelman on Twitter.

9 Comments

  1. I like RINOS and DINOS for the most part. They usually give me a warm feeling inside.

  2. I think many of the people that celebrated a R taking Kennedy's old seat didn't really understand his politics. Now that he is actually voting, the truth is hard to ignore and they have found that he is not pure as would like. A RINO is the only R that could win that seat….they should happy he is there and leave the man alone.

  3. How fickle these Republicans. One day a hero, next day a villain.

    Stupack: One minute a god, next minute (literally) a devil…

  4. “devil”

    I think you mean baby killer.

    ( and I think that was a slow pitch :) )

  5. That will do, too

    Another one could be, “One minute a baby saver, the next minute–literally–a baby killer”

    Thanks

  6. Seriously, what did these Tea Party folks – who I've viewed to be mostly southern and white – expect out of a Massachusetts Republican? I have an affinity for New England Republicans – they appear to be the last element of that party that actually thinks about their votes rather than blindly siding with the party.

  7. I love the RINO bit – simply a convenient way that extremists have come up with to bash those that won't tow the party line – No room for those who insist on holding their own opinion…

  8. How fickle these Republicans. One day a hero, next day a villain.

    Tell it to former Democratic Vice Presidential candidate Joe Liebermann.

Submit a Comment