An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Of Dr. E., Me, and Dick Cheney

We call her Dr. E., one of the most remarkable women I have had the privilege of knowing almost exclusively through TMV and one delightful hour-long telephone conversation on her nickel. We share numerous ailments brought about by the scavenging effects of diabetes but, if you read her post today, it dwarfs my ailments to a mere pittance.

Dr. Clarissa Pinkola Estes in simple terms argues for insurance carriers to drop their nasty policy of denying coverage to patients with pre-existing medical conditions. If nothing else comes out of our national debate on health care reform, this evil practice must be legislated against and banned forever.

Dr. E has a compassion for mankind way beyond my wildest dreams on a good day. I’m just a cynical, washed up old newspaperman. I do know my politics. Consider this prospect:

If all members of Congress only had the health care and insurance coverage Dr. E and I can afford, do you think for one minute this on-going debate — started by President Truman — would still be going? I don’t think so. Consider this scenario:

Let’s say Dick Cheney had had his first heart attack as a Congressman under the coverage Dr. E and I now have. His coverage would have been dropped or his premium reset so high it would force him into bankruptcy. Instead, his coverage continued to pay for at least three more heart surgeries and an undisclosed number of relapses. Who knows? Without the health coverage the federal bureaucracy offers, would Cheney suddenly turn champion of — oh, my god — a single-payer system?

Preposterous, you say? Not so fast, my friends. Conservatives and Liberal Cheney bashers suffered apoplexy when he said in interviews he supported same-sex marriage. And why did he buck his president and the conservatives who consider the issue as un-Christian, sinful and every other imagined dastardly deed?

Because one of his daughters is a lesbian. Give the man credit. He saw in his daughter the pains she was suffering as a subject of his peers’ public disgrace. If it takes personal experience to enlighten one’s view on a hot-button issue, terrific.

My goodness, folks. If Cheney — the sultan of darkness — can announce his views on same-sex marriage, why couldn’t Congress come together on a reasonable health care plan if we had the power to jerk their current coverage as they have with ours?

Nothing like putting the shoe on the other’s foot.

The thing is, Dr. E and I do the best we can coping with what we got. It could be so much better that I hazard to guess.

  • D. E.Rodriguez
    My kudos, respect, sympathy, etc.,etc. to the author and Dr. E.

    But please don't bring Cheney into that "mix," because he doesn't merit it.

    Please spare me the : "Because one of his daughters is a lesbian. Give the man credit. He saw in his daughter the pains she was suffering as a subject of his peer’s public disgrace. If it takes personal experience to enlighten one’s view on a hot-button issue, terrific."

    Cheney must have known for years that his daughter was a lesbian. Yet only very recently did he "come out" in support of same-sex marriage--and then, with qualifications.

    I wonder how much legislation and policies he has been supporting all those years--while he knew his daughter was lesbian--against gays and lebians.

    (What is his position on gays and lesbians in the military?)

    Give him credit for a late conversion, but don't ignore the past.

    Added: To his credit, there are writings that Cheney has been somewhat tolerant towards gays in the military.

    This doesn't take away from the fact that he supports--by not speaking out against it--a party, an ideology that considers gays to be second class citizens..
  • Rudi
    The dropped coverage will continue as long as hospitals and insurance companies worry about profits over health care. Canada, Mexico and England don't do this to their citizens...
  • kritt11
    Its fun fantasizing about Dick Cheney experiencing the same woes as the ordinary Joe, but lets face it he's on a different planet entirely--- not even in the same universe as the rest of us.

    Cheney may have recently come out for gay marriage, but he hasn't been a vocal advocate for gay rights in the way he has been a vocal advocate of the Iraq War, and regime change for Iran and NK. Also, his revised stance has little merit, because he would never have taken it if his own daughter wasn't gay.

    I always wonder about these conservatives who are willing to deny rights to others until it affects their OWN families. Other examples of this include Nancy Reagan lobbying for stem cell research and the Bradys lobbying for stricter gun laws.
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    Krit:

    You took the words out of my mouth.

    Here we have one of the most powerful men in the world--some say even more powerful than the president at the time. Powerful enough to take our country to an unnecessary war. Yet, show me his speeches, show me his writings, show me his deeds when it came to standing up like a man, like a father, against those from the Religious Right, the right wing of his party--his base-- who implicitly and explicitly, through words or through legislation---or lack of it---demonized and discriminated against his own daughter and those like her.

    Thank you, krit
  • TT
    Cheney said that he supported same-sex marriages back in 2000 at least and maybe before that. His daughter was born in '69. So she would've been 30 in 2000. I guess everyone could be 'more' supportive about things they believe in but honestly I can't see slamming the guy for saying that he supports same-sex marriages. However he came to the decision to support same-sex marriages, because of his daughter or a friend or whatever, he still made the decision so saying that he doesn't *really* care for homosexuals or their issues, isn't really the point.

    We all tend to care about other people and support causes where we think or feel that it's the right thing to do.
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    TT

    You make a good point.

    The only thing I would say, is that if you truly care about a son or daughter who is homosexual, and really understand what they have gone through, are going through, and will go through, you might be a little more understanding of and sympathetic to those other sons and daughters who share the same sexual orientation, and the same discrimination.
  • archangel
    Just so you all know... Jerry Remmers and I were sort of the blind leading the blind regarding one another on our hour long phone call... came about mostly because Jer had just come onto TMV and was trying to wrangle dat wascally wordpress into letting him upload images. I knew about two minutes more than he did about it (a small miracle, regarding my on again/off again love relationship with WordPress, which is actually an amazing, if vast, open everything network) and so we held hands and got lost in the WordPress woods together. He is a man of great heart for others, and he has seen much... Much... An old style journo who could keep you rapt with his stories for hours.

    Thanks.
    dr.e
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    Thanks, dr. e.

    Because I think so highly of you and Jerry (from reading your thoughtful writings), is why I "bristled" when I saw your names lumped together with Cheney's.

    Dorian
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC