An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Summer Fantasy Poll Question: Movies You’d Like to See Made

Thinking of all the books you’ve ever read, common stories passed down from generation to generation, the lives of real people who you find interesting, radio shows or more, what movie would you like to see made which has never been produced? Or, to widen the field a bit, we could include movies which actually were made, but were done poorly or before the technology was available to do them justice.

In the fiction / sci-fi field, I’ve been wondering for some time why we haven’t seen a big screen production of Ender’s Game. It just seems as if it would lend itself to the theater in this age of cinematic miracles and magic and would come with a built in audience by way of its established fan base. It’s been in the works on and off for a while now, and Orson Scott Card has developed at least three screen plays, but it just never seems to come to fruition. The latest rumors were circling around Odd Lott Entertainment picking up the project, but I’ll believe it when I see it.

From the real life / biography realm, I’d like to see a definitive work on the life of Curt Cobain, preferably without Courtney Love getting too heavily involved in the production of it. (She can do a cameo herself as the older widow if she likes, but we’ll need somebody else to stay sober long enough to play her as a young rocker.)

From the real flights of fancy, I’d love to see a historically accurate movie based on the Iroquois Nation native Americans and their initial dealings with the European invaders and their eventual betrayal by the French. Current history tells some truly twisted tales about how “wonderful” relations between the English and the Mohawks (among other members of the league) were, but the old men in the tribes laugh bitterly at those stories. That would make an eye-opening film.

  • Jim_Satterfield
    A decent adaptation, complete with powersuits, of Heinlein's Starship Troopers. Speaking of Heinlein, I would really like to see adaptations of Tunnel in the Sky, The Moon is a Harsh Mistress and Have Spacesuit, Will Travel. I think these and others could be successfully updated.

    I wonder if Ender's Game has rights issues? Late one night at a science fiction convention in L.A. about 11 years ago a similar discussion was taking place. I mentioned that Tunnel in the Sky was something I'd like to see and George R.R. Martin said that he agreed that it could make for a great visual story. He, however, was interested in turning it into a TV series but the legal rights were a hopelessly tangled mess. He had left the production end of Hollywood by then, not really returning to any film or TV work until HBO decided to make a series out of A Song of Ice and Fire. Now he's going to do some writing for the show but none of the other things he's done in the past. These kinds of legal issues aren't that unusual.
  • TheLid
    I would like to see a movie version of Arthur Miller's the Creation of the World and other Business, the funniest two acts of theater I have ever seen (but they should leave out the 3rd act)
  • After I did some more checking, it seems that there are *some* of what we would call "rights issues" regarding Ender's Game, but not the usual kind. Orson Scott Card has been very interested in seeing the film made and he still controls the rights. But he also issues a statement in 99 about how he wasn't going to "bend over for green screen Hollywood" and walked out of discussions. It seems that his vision of what it should be wasn't the same as what the money people wanted to do. Perhaps, with time ticking by, he may become more flexible. Thanks for the background on Heinlen, by the way. Another of my favorites and some of your choices would be great films if done well. If I could add to the list, I would also add his pairing of Methuselah's Children and Time Enough for Love.... even though it's such a massive story that it might have to be split up into three movies like Lord of the Rings was. Problem is, as wonderful as those books are, I don't think they have the built in fan base that Tolkien had.
  • Jim_Satterfield
    They definitely don't have the fan base to persuade the money people that they would work, Jazz. There are many Heinlein books that could make for good movies, though since they were written in the late '40s and '50s they would need someone to write them who could update them while still showing respect for the source material. Have you read Double Star, Citizen of the Galaxy or The Door Into Summer?
  • Jim_Satterfield
    And then there is the other Heinlein book that was made into a disaster because of their idea of adapting it, The Puppet Masters.
  • bks2plz
    Hi,

    I would like to invite you to read my new fantasy novel, "Gateway to DreamWorld." It has received rave reviews and has a shot at becoming a movie.

    http://www.eloquentbooks.com/GatewayToDreamWorl...

    Brenda Estacio
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC