An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Is Iran’s Theocracy Imploding?

Is Iran’s theocracy imploding? Jamsheed Choksy — Professor of Iranian Studies and former Director of the Middle Eastern Studies Program at Indiana University, and a member of the US National Council on the Humanities at the National Endowment for the Humanities — makes the case that it is in this MUST READ on RealClearWorld. Here’s a small part of the beginning:

Swept up by revolutionary fervor in the late 1970s, many Iranians assumed Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini was a pragmatist. However, Khomeini had assimilated theocratic ideas unsuccessfully expounded by Ayatollah Fazlollah Nuri during the Constitutional Revolution seven decades earlier. Khomeini went on to augment Nuri’s belief-that clergymen must rule because secular governance fails to follow divine will-with Maslaha or fundamentalist Muslim interests.

Khomeini then used his personal popularity and revolutionary authority to install an absolutism centered on velayat-e faqih or guardianship of Islamic jurists headed by an autocratic supreme leader. The current supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei follows the tenets of his late teacher, regarding himself as God’s singular representative on Earth.

To a growing number of Iranians, however, religious fundamentalism is a luxury they can no longer afford. Half of them are under the age of 40 with no ideological connection to the Islamic Revolution of 1979. Their difficulties and desires of life take precedence over doctrine and dogma. At least 12 percent of adults are unemployed. An inflation rate of about 20 percent saps their meager purchasing power. They face a housing shortage. They are frustrated as well by 30 years of sociopolitical repression impinging on all aspects of daily life in the name of religion. As a result, orthopraxy is equated with fundamentalism by them-and both are rejected.

He provides an analysis and then predicts at the end:

Historical and current circumstances suggest Iranians eventually will succeed in separating faith from state. They will not reject Shiism, but return it to its appropriate place in society. Iranians know well too that they are not under the spell of interfering foreigners. So circumstances suggest that leaders and peoples of other nations should assist vigorously those Iranians striving for liberty from ever-present religion.

There’s a lot more so read it in its entirety.

  • tidbits
    Without having the knowledge base to comment intelligently on the substance of Choksy's piece, thank you for providing the link and advancing our "western" understanding of the history and current situation in Iran.
  • Silhouette
    I quoted from the Koran yesterday as an example to show that the theocracy is no more. Once the leaders delude themselves and become servants of the underworld daring to use the word of Allah to promote their diabolical powerholds, they no longer speak for Allah. And then they themselves have become the infidels.

    There will be no virgins and lands of spleandor waiting for them at the end of their days. Quite the opposite. Using the word of Allah falsely commands the highest of punishments. Their mistake, as is many of religions around the world is to concentrate on manmade fine print that justifies their cause and ignore the top Commandments of their God in doing so.
  • shannonlee
    Great comment Sil...well written.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC