An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Michael Jackson: The Black Tribal Funeral

1295571.jpgI’m steeped in the high stylizations of funerals of blacks and funerals of immigrants. Between them one could not decide which one was more ornate, symbolic and filled with near suicides, screaming, singing, clothing fit for high opera, even dancing on the rails of the pews, or afterward, getting dead drunk to celebrate the rising of the soul of the loved one into heaven.

It was because where I grew up those two groups, blacks and immigrants, were still deeply tribal in their recognition of the soul, the love-dependence between family members, whether they liked each other or not… they loved each other deeply.

They had all stepped –or been pushed– into the ‘melting pot’ but there were things the tribal people were made of… that would not melt into an undifferentiated pool, no matter how high the heat meant to force tribal people to merge with the greater masses who no longer remembered their ancient rituals and symbolic life.

What would not melt was high ritual, deep understanding of symbolic gestures being the language of the spirit and soul, the desire of the body to act out what the heart is experiencing, the decorum and decorating of the funeral attendees to show that in this day, they are not the usual selves;

… rather, on this day, the mourners are spirits, ghosts, who have, like the kachinas of the Hopis, come to accompany in full tenderness, the soul whose body has died to this world.

Today, some will say peope ‘performed and gave speeches’ at Michael Jackson’s funeral. That’s not it. In those funerals of my childhood, whomsoever could play music, sawed or thumped or blew violin, fiddle, metal barred slide guitar, silver tipped accordion, clarinet, country harmonica, before, during or after the funeral.

There were walking-processions behind the casket, often candle-lit and with singing and playing clarinet, fiddle, guitara. And when some of the people could afford old cars, then the procession became headlights during dusk for miles and miles to church, and then cemetery.

It was not lost on us that the ‘last ride’ of the body of the dead was in a hearse that outdid anything that soul had ridden in during their lifetime. That many families pooled coins to try to buy the ‘best’ castket they could manage. They understood the casket as the chair the soul would have in heaven. Often, no expense was spared, including mortgaging a parcel of farmland.

Whomsoever could sing well, sang at the funerals. The coloratura sopranos of the Hungarians and Poles and Czechs, the Lithuanians, Estonians, Greeks, Italians, soaring Ave Marias by rag-tag choirs made up of immigrants in mismatched dusty black dresses and suits and hats with whole partridges plastered on their sides, the women in veils with black velvet dots on them, the old men wearing white spats.

The dance of ‘stylin’ by the ministers at the end of funerals of blacks where the blackrobed men would strut down the aisle after the casket in a victory-soul’s-in-heaven-now dance… the full-lunged alleluia-ing that literally loosened the nails in many of a church’s ramshackle roof. The satin gowns of the singers stretched over round bellies and rounder breasts, the mirror-shiny boots of the ushers who held up fainting women and bodily kept other mourners back from jumping into the open grave in grief.

When I saw the Michael Jackson funeral today, I thought of home… I saw home played out in his funeral for and by the mourners…

all the music, all the leaping, all the stylized clothing, all the symbolic gestures like the sequined gloves worn to the funeral by MJ’s family. Some of the people breaking down and needing help to walk, needing to be held up under their arms… Michael’s children so young and so incredibly beautiful and clearly comforting of others

…and his daughter Paris, 11 years old, bravely speaking her love for her father straight from her little broken heart… you could hear the audience suddenly soft-wail for her…

and the family ladies in their big black picture hats and sunglasses worn indoors– that last being a symbolic gesture of ‘we are in the dark now during our mourning; even when it is daylight we are still in the other world with our loved one for now’)… you saw in them for Paris, grim-lipped strong-woman faces under their hat brims… that “I will protect you, give my life for you” mother love, that is in every woman who truly loves …

and seeing the praise-trance coming over so many mourners, and the casket looking like an entire rose garden had been planted on it, just right, just as it was long long ago in the tribes.

Some observers will rant, condemn, complain about MJ, his life, his funeral, saying it was this, that, claiming on ‘lost productivity’ or decrying that it was an unmerited extravaganza. It wasn’t. It was a small town funeral. Gary Indiana style. Attended by many world over.

It was also a tribal funeral in which mourners sang and danced their hearts out to create the wind to send the soul to Creator. Tribal. Sincere. With all the relatives liked and disliked, controversial and not, funny, and not funny, broken down… giving out their hearts on plates for everyone to see. Just like home. Birthplace home, and far far back tribal home, both.

Requiescat in pace Michael Joseph Jackson. Your people did you proud today… in the old ways.

CODA
Just background…

As a little girl I grew up in the backwoods of farms and factories where blacks, Latinos, poor ‘whites’ and newly arrived immigrants from Eastern Europe had migrated and all lived together because that’s where there were menial and labor jobs.. These diverse groups of poor were held together in the back-paining work, the tractor turn-over accidents, the falling through the iced over lakes, the meetings of small dark sedans with eighteen wheelers in white out storms, the overdoses of laudanum, the shootings, cutting with razors, the drownings…

I know many persons now, who say they never attended a funeral until they were adults, and that it seemed strange. But to me, funerals are like days, bound to come, important to live through, but also in… for my childhood contained a long string of funerals, often month after month, certainly season after season… friends, relatives, schoolmates dying way before their time, so devastating the injuries of big machinery, so unforgiving the rivers and big water, so little money for doctors… it was like a mantra often said, ‘nothing can be done’ when something could in fact have been done, but it cost money.

Thus, many funerals. And I, the funny looking child whose hair never looked right, whose dresses were always too long or too choking at the neckline and waist, scuffed shoes that were always too big or too small.. that child being filled with sight and sound and knowings about how raw and deep is the love human beings have for other human beings. That funerals open a door normally closed, showing the raw humanity of so many. Like we saw today. As always. Siempre.

Photo via WBZ Newsradio website

  • Father_Time
    Absolutely Bizarre. Very interesting though.
  • tidbits
    The ocassional interspersions of Faulknerian prose are a nice touch.
  • I, very purposely, didn't watch the coverage of Jackson's funeral. So I can't comment on specific aspects of it. The placing of Jackson as the most important thing in the world offends me, though, on a very deep and visceral level.
  • redshoebride
    Thank you Dr. Estes,

    I wept in acknowlegement that a bright light has gone out.

    What he managed to do with his love humbles me and I will have to say "no" to the naysayers because he was otherworldy and some will never see that.

    Soflty Breathing in Los Angeles
  • ordinarysparrow
    very interesting view, such rich imagery . . . a bit like New Orleans "first line" and "second line" . . . .truly magnificent funerals. . will always remember going to a funeral of a local African American Jazz musician. . .and it too was tribal, awesome, and a true celebration. . .

    also the children. . . i know all America is holding them in heart and prayer. . . was glad to see their faces, not for us, but for them. . .
  • What did I just read, or should I say attempt to read? Funerals of "the blacks and immigrants?" ..."your people did you proud?" wth are you talking about. What I saw was a ceremony, full of friends of family, but with very little stylized "tribal" tradition. I fear you were reaching here, and you really missed the mark. Your post sounds very much like someone working very hard to sound very smart. Sorry, but I think you missed the mark, by a long shot.
  • archangel
    denised2
    I think if one lived in groups that are immigrant and/or have patronistic /matristic cultural styles, one sees the groups know their own cultural histories from far back: they know their stories and old rituals pretty fully. But even if you didnt grow up amongst such groups, if you read, say some of Coles work for instance, or Terkel, even Royko, which are accessible to those who dont even like to read ....you might better see the old ritual underlayments in our modern times.

    Ordinary sparrow; the children, yes, they are so beautiful. A lot of people have remarked it was sweet to the heart to see them. And youre right the rituals are NOLA-like, or visa versa. Another part where the old ways are still holding forth through certain means that are new. I saw a footpath procession to the grave last time I was in NOLA that included a electrified trumpet on a battery pak worn on a red belt by an old gent in a black suit with red socks and a red fedora with a feather in it and spotted leopard hat band.

    Redshoebride: A good many people see matters the way you sense and see them. Evocative screen name by the way.

    ThurmanHeart, I dont think this is the most important thing in the world. But it has its importance today.

    Tidbits, I thought MJ was often Heinleinian, as per looking from the America/British side. But otherwise, in so many ways, aboriginal in various his various body mods and enhancements, including face dust, twirling, and mating dance choreogaphy etc

    FatherTime, There's a saying about those who find most everything interesting... that they often have the most acute intelligence.

    dr.e
  • Father_Time said: "Absolutely Bizarre. Very interesting though."

    I think that sums up a general feeling of those "not in the know" concerning certain ethnic funerals. Being a black dude, I've attended several funerals of family members that were celebrations. With my Creole roots, the funerals were colorful, lively, passionate, and invigorating. I remember a friend of mine being absolutely stunned at a particular funeral. He said he thought we were collectively insane. LOL! He wasn't being nasty just true as he saw things.

    I didn't watch the Jackson funeral because I burned out over MJ for various reasons. But I understand your post so much Dr. E. The whole "black tribal funeral" point just resonated deeply. Thanks for writing this.
  • ordinarysparrow
    Dr. E. tonite is the Full Moon. . . some can be highly prone to lunar affects and they just need to howl?. . .
  • spirasol
    Yea, while I appreciate MJ's accomplishments and did watch the funeral, I guess I felt unmoved. Perhaps it is easy to do watching the proceeding on the little box. Easy to disengage.

    Two additional Reasons:

    First because I was not a die hard MJ fan. As one loss stirs the bones of a sleeping loss, I found myself musing about the loss of John Lennon and into the future: What if it had been Bob Dylan. I'm sure I would have been blubbering in front of my TV had it been the latter, just as I found myself speechless for days after Lennon's murder.

    Second: because I felt this was meant to be a celebration of his life, which to me left out the other story. I know it may be in poor form, especially for the size and stature of this funeral, but in the funerals I have attended, people celebrate, but they also talk about the deceased as a whole; his foibles, mistakes, accidents, dreams, accomplishments and their are often tensions between family members that haven't spoken for years, etc.

    But what of the other story? On the topside an overwhelming success in capital letters, a KING of pop only of coarse, but the underside, what of that? To me he seemed to be a very unhappy man.........addicted to pharmaceuticals, boy prodigy hitting middle age, failed marriages, the issues with kids, ........The underside feels like he never turned the corner in his real life..........like Lennon appeared to..........
  • gallantKnight
    Dr. Archagel,

    I really liked your piece today, and your response. For me, it was some of the best writing I've read from you. You captured something that so many people will never see or understand, because it is so laid out in plain sight that it is difficult to see. Or, is it to frightening for people to see (so primal)? I'm not sure which. As a non-stereotypical American man who just happens also to be Black, I find many people miss the mark when they attempt to measure the psyche or actions of minorities. Today, you showed your history, your insight, and your soul, but most people won't see these gifts, because they are so caught up within their own perception of the world less traveled by...the world of themselves. Beautifully done.

    gallantKnight
  • TT
    GallantKnight -

    Thank you.
    So true.

    and

    Thank You Dr E.
    you brought back so many memories
    of so many passings.
  • tidbits
    Archangel - Sorry I wasn't clear. The Faulkner reference had to do with a few lines/paragraphs of your writing in the article. There was also a common death/funeral theme with much of Faulkner's work...withiout the mid-twentieth century southern racism that crept into Faulkner's literature. Your piece was beautifully written; I agree with gallantKnight.
  • DLS
    "I didn't watch the Jackson funeral because I burned out over MJ for various reasons."

    Worse than Jackson's "chronicle" by far was the media's celeb-obscession with him.

    I watched CNN (the worst circus of all), as they're the only 24-hour shot at news normally when I view a TV lately for news updates, and I feared the memorial could be a circus or worse, but actually it was a fine presentation (possibly a model for future celebrity memorial events -- mark my words -- as well as a big boost to the market fot the services of the guy who directed it). It's worth your reviewing sometime if you actually want to do it, T-Steel. This is coming from one of many who expected much worse and was surprised.
  • This is a beautifully written piece which resonates with those of us who know, and frustrates those who do not. The responses to this post highlight the divisions and alienation reflected back to us through our larger society - the judgment, the misunderstanding, at times disrespect. The failure of Anglo culture to completely sanitize birth and death and their accompanying rituals has been, and continues to be, a testimony to the strength of spirit of some and an irritating sign of defeat to others.
    The "norm" of "managing" the passage of souls into and out of this world is not normal. This is the work of passion and spirit. It always has been and always will be. Unless and until you have held someone back from the open grave, sang or played your heart out to send off a departing soul, or assisted a woman birthing her child naturally you do not know. At least have the presence of mind to read this offering with the intent to see an experience which is different from your own, for sarcasm and ridicule only serves as a reflection of a closed and woefully narrow mind.
    It goes without saying, but there are enough of those already.
  • ordinarysparrow
    K Moon Howe. . .so liked what you wrote. . .lots of wisdom there. . .

    denised2 . . .there is a UTube video that might help you to read some of Dr. E.'s post. . .sometimes it takes the linear brain a bit of stretching when one is not use to reading a person that is gifted with the mind of an artist and also a mind of a scientist working together producing a kaleidoscope of patterns into a synthesis that leaves others with a blunt pencil and no eraser. . .

    would suggest you read Dr. Leonard Shlain's book the Alphabet and the Goddess or if you have time here is a bit of a review on UTube of Leonard Shlain on Berkleys Conversation with History, . .it is long but around 27 minutes and forward he gets into some explanation of and/both brains that hopefully folks like you and are may evolve into somewhere further down the road. . .

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rOvtNLJL6mI
    Conversations with History Leonard Shlain
  • latonyaQB
    "Whomever" can only be used as an object: "Give the violin to whomever you would like to have it." "Whoever" is a subject" "Whoever left ten dollars in the hall is going to be sad, when he discovers it is missing." Whoever does the action, while whomever RECEIVES the action. I mean no harm in correcting you; the repeated error simply made following your article difficult.
  • archangel
    dear latonyaQB Thank you for the English lesson. I will try to remember it. As a writer I can use all the help I can get. I prefer to use the English we learned in the backwoods, 'whomsoever' is my preference. Standard English training is something we backward kids whose first language was not English were forced to, but I tend to write as we spoke originally, including amongst, betwixt, and dreampt, and other 'unacceptable' ways of speaking. I am sorry my syntax was difficult for you to follow. I also am a horrible speller to boot and consider each article a minor miracle if I get most spellings right. Boy.

    dr.e
  • archangel
    one of the things I like about your comments DLS is that you give a good picture of a person who when facts are added can change his/her mind. Good.

    dr.e
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC