An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Susan Boyle And Great Britain (Guest Voice)

mail.google.com.jpg

Susan Boyle And Great Britain

by Dalitso Njolinjo

Part of me is happy for Susan Boyle’s world wide viral success and part of me is dreading what the video on YouTube will tell the world about Great Britain.

Although Susan’s moment might have been a life changing experience for her, it really did not capture ‘Britain’ (and myself) at its best.

Like the audience, when I saw Susan Boyle enter the stage I thought, ‘Oh no, not another disaster story’. I mean, you have seen them a dozen times on reality talent contests. An ‘out of sorts’ character who is portrayed as being ‘odd’ has a seemingly improbable dream of being a singer. She is adamant that she has the ‘X-Factor’ only to be told by the judges and the audience that she is in fact below average.

Well, what happened with Susan Boyle was the very extreme of this scenario. The above usually involves one critical aspect, the audience and the judge give the contestant the benefit of the doubt and judge her after the performance.

Susan looked odd, was a virgin in her 40’s and her closest companion was a cat that the audience (which included myself watching at home) and the judges (Simon Cowell rolling his eyes) dismissed and laughed off this woman without giving her a chance. All because she did not look like Liona Lewis or any other modern day celebrity and she didn’t live a social life of an ordinary person.

Now Ms Boyle is an international phenomenon, we find ourselves applauding her like she represents all that is good about Britain, and by applauding her we are really applauding ourselves, trying to reassure ourselves that we are actually a kind nation where women like Susan Boyle get the chance to shine. The way her story is being pushed over her talents also shows how hollow the praise for this woman is, are we captivated by her talent or is this charitable media coverage? Coverage that can make the whole country feel better about it self after what they put Ms Boyle through.

Well the dirty secret is this, Susan Boyle is 47 years old, she is a better singer that damn near 90% of females in the charts right now and it took a reality show in its 3rd year before she got her chance to shine. And even then she had to injure the barrage of insults from the audience members and the judges. It is also my personal opinion that there are a lot more Susan Boyles out there, being laughed at by the ‘normal’ in our society and too shy to pursue their dreams.

Even if she does win Britain’s Got Talent, I am not convinced that my Image obsessed country will look past its shallowness and support this woman past this seasons cycle. I really do hope that I am proved wrong.

But it comes down to this, for the first 2 minutes before Ms Boyle sang, I laughed and mocked Ms Boyle like everyone in that audience. I was wrong and for that I am truly sorry.

But I am also aware that this could very well happen again.

Another Susan Boyle could appear next year and could seem as ‘weird’ as Susan, how will I react then?

Dalitso Njolinjo lives in Northamptonshire, England. He is an aspiring writer and communications consultant. He writes that he “enjoys all things politics, sports and French. The ungodly trinity.” He also writes on his own blog.

  • I DIDN'T laugh or mock Susan when she came out on stage. I just thought, "here's another contestant."

    Two things are offensive: (1) shallow people like you who consciously or subconsciously judge other people by their outward appearances. That is just mean and often evil. You top that off by inditing yourself for not knowing better, but people like you never change (evolve) beyond token incidents like this one.

    (2) Media coverage was condescending and patronizing toward Susan Boyle. From ABC to CBS, NBC, Fox - all publishers led their pieces by stressing the following attributes: (a) looks - ugly, homely, unkempt, fat, obese; (b) age - middle-aged, old, "spinster" (yes, ABC actually used that pejorative which, historically, has been a condescending euphemism for a lesbian); (c) clothing - dated, dowdy, matronly.

    Would you ever see ABC News lead a story with this lead: "we bring you tonight the story of a beautiful 18-year-old young lady. She has the figure of a runway model and dresses the like. You wouldn't believe it but she has an incredible voice."

    Of course not! Not just the public at large but mainstream media has constructed an American Idol image of talent. And it's idiots like this author that buy into it - and find themselves shocked when a person who looks "different" has wonderful things about them.
  • casualobserver
    Susan was a great gift from Britain..........she almost makes up for the damage Simon Cowl has inflicted upon this world.
  • Dalitso, I think you're being needlessly parochial. The public reaction to Susan Boyle reflects on Britain very little (if at all) -- at least, in my own view.

    I saw her as representing the ordinary, the mundane, and the self-consciousness that is found in each and every one of us.

    She made me feel good about myself. And I'll bet she had exactly the same effect on millions of other people as well.
  • delardus
    After Susan Boyle discover now The Crisp bread dancing boys at the Sweden's Got Talent : http://www.newslicious.net/2009/04/susan-boyle-...
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    Methinks you "catharsize" too much.

    Enjoy the moment, enjoy Ms. Boyle, enjoy her voice, enjoy her success.

    Dorian
  • Lit3Bolt
    File under blogospheric navel gazing.

    Also DarcyK is right to call you out, despite your mea culpa, because it's implied that if Susan Boyle did not happen to have the voice of an angel her "redeeming" quality would be lost and mockery could then proceed, guilt-free.
  • Lynx
    Odd how different people can read the very same post and extract entirely different messages from them. What I see in this post is not someone justifying surprise at Ms. Boyle’s talent, nor letting himself or anyone else off the hook for their prejudice. In fact I’d say the opposite is true. The post seems to be saying that the cruelty was wrong, that the very fact that everyone was so surprised is just as damning and that the overflow of attention currently heaped on her is at least in part out of a wish to cover up these inconvenient facts.

    Speaking as someone who was judged on appearances quite cruelly in the past I see nothing wrong with the post itself. It seems an honest portrayal of how one person being idolized does not make up for a country and individuals far too used to judging on appearances. I would wager that virtually everyone does it at least sometimes in different situations and to different people.
  • dn86
    that was my point exactly.

    although, i am not that fussed about other peoples opinion, its just that, their opinions.

    the fact is this, i think it is horrible that no one outside of the 'reality tv' world would give her a chance if she walked through the door because of the way she looks. i think it is disingenous for people to say otherwise, but we are a society that puts appearance over substance.

    i am big enough to say i was biggoted in my views about ms boyle before she sang, and after hearing her i was ashamed that i even thought that way,because she has real talent.

    if people look at the audiences reaction to ms boyle before she sang then you will understand what i am talking about. if not, thats alright too.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC