An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

A Tiny Irony: A Lost Story about Trees and Human Beings

picture-3.JPG

Trees
By Joyce Kilmer

I think that I shall never see
A poem lovely as a tree.

A tree whose hungry mouth is prest
Against the sweet earth’s flowing breast;

A tree that looks at God all day,
And lifts her leafy arms to pray;

A tree that may in summer wear
A nest of robins in her hair;

Upon whose bosom snow has lain;
Who intimately lives with rain.

Poems are made by fools like me,
But only God can make a tree.

The trees in the picture:

These trees you see in the picture, lived along the coast of New Zealand. They were felled by a group of human beings who determined the trees were terribly diseased, rotted at the core, and therefore in danger of falling over and harming cars and drivers that might drive near them. So the trees were cut down. To keep humans safe.

A tiny irony: As you see in the pictures, the trees were living strong, the heartwood, which goes hollow in some trees, is not rotten. Instead, it is firm and lush and tightly-packed. The rot and disease claimed by those with faulty X-ray vision, was non-existent.

Another tiny irony: Along this particular highway over the last decade, over 240 persons have been killed or injured by driving into trees… that were not in the way, nor in the right-of-way, trees that did not fall over, trees that were not rotting or diseased, and which could neither walk nor run into the road, either.

The last word: Long ago, Mr. Alcott, back to home, used to sit out on his washcloth-sized porch on summer nights, and play his banjo or Tennessee slide guitar and sing the most bloody horrible ballads of drownings and union-busted heads, and lovers murdering lovers down at the river… At the end, he’d smile that gold tooth-missing toothed smile around his wet old cigarette and mutter, “Human beings, aint they wondrous.”
_____________

CODA

The poet behind the poem: Joyce Kilmer was born 1886. This poem is in strict iambic pentameter which has the effect of forcing it into simple formalized lines. At the time of his death, Kilmer was considered a devotee of nature, and the leading American Catholic poet and lecturer of his generation. Critics often compared him to British contemporaries G. K. Chesterton and Hilaire Belloc.

However, Kilmer’s work yet to come (many artists bring their most refined work during their 40s, 50s, 60s and 70s) never arrived, for in the summer of 1918 he was sent to the Marne. There, in the second battle, he was killed by a sniper’s bullet. No one knows the name of the combatant who killed the poet, only that the poet was awarded the Croix de Guerre by the French Republic in gratitude, that Kilmer was buried in an American cemetery on French soil, and that he was only 31 years old.

  • Mike_P
    A striking post, Dr. E., on several levels. (Not least of which, to me, is I hadn't realized Joyce Kilmer was a man!)

    You've made me contemplate - uncommon for such a short piece of writing. Thank you.
  • river
    Dr. E. . .this story and picture is Wabi Sabi in the best Japanese sense. . .thanks, it is good contemplation . . .i looked at the picture and saw a half way reminder of something, perhaps something forgotten or something yet to come?. . .Then read the Wabi Sabi story and the richness of nature and all to often the folly of man. . .

    I have a small tree story. The park across the street where i live has some ancient trees. They have been there since before the Civil War. I call one Grandmother Tree. She is much like the poem you wrote and shared in dedication to Senator Kennedy. All kinds of people find their way to her. People come and say prayers around her both morning and evening, People come and have long soulful talks with loved ones. Dog people meet under her branches each day while they allow the pets to play. The pet people knows all the pets names but sometimes it the process of learning the human's name is slower in knowing, even though the human connections formed under Grandmother Tree are the most gentle and kind because people have entered the relationships with open naked hearts of loving their pets. There is an art institute nearby, so often young art students come to draw the many fantastic creatures that morphs from the many large goiters on Grandmother tree.

    A number of years ago we had a micro-burst and many trees where destroyed. Grandmother was topped and she looked like a huge stalk of celery. . .But people continued to go to her, and the next two seasons she started to slowly venture her arms out again. At thsi time i realized Grandmother had an invasion of black ants. Being concerned for her i called the Parks and Rec. to bring her medicine for the insects. The Dept. Head was very cordial, but a few days later Grandmother had a huge red X marked on her as well as several other trees nearby, to signal their plan demise. I felt devastated for i had wanted to help her not to lead to her demise. For days the people gathered and everyone was so sad about Grandmother, she had become an altar and a sanctuary or so many.

    So, somebody made the decision to take a piece of her bark to the nearby art supply shop and get a perfect paint match of Grandmother. The next morning Grandmother stood original with no red marks. In a couple of weeks the Park and Recreation Contractors came and took the other trees but Grandmother stood unnoticed. Somebody went to the garden store and got her some medicine. Every couple of years since that time one of the Park and Recreation tree inspectors will come and paint another red X on Grandmother, but somebody kept the paint, and soon Grandmother is back to herself. Grandmother is still standing and Park and Recreation right hand does not know what the left hand is doing. This had been going on for about 15 years. . . .
  • GeorgeSorwell
    Thanks especially for the coda.
  • Ghostdreams
    Hey Doc!
    Life is filled with odd coincidences.
    Right before logging on and coming to read your blog, I finished the last few chapters of the book, "The Forest Lover" (a biography about Emily Carr by Susan Vreeland).
    I'd spent the last day or so tripping happily through the book and I came to really like the woman that Emily Carr was, predominantly because of her love of nature (in particular her love of trees).
    I love all that is green in our world ....the felling of any tree is heartbreaking to me. Whether it's for fuel, housing, or any other thing.
    As soon as I could walk, I was climbing tree's and sitting for hours in our backyard, watching the day go by....I owe them so much.
    I learned how to think on my own and for myself while sitting in their arms.
    I will light a candle for these incredible Tree people that lost their lives due to human stupidity.

    An aside: I'm lucky enuff to be able to live in this little secluded area that is off the beaten path (or on the back alley, as I'm always having to tell people) of the small city I live in. In front of my wee, teeny house there are tree's everywhere and to the sides of my house, it is the same - TREES).
    The tree's provide me a constant strength and are home to so many different critters. It's just wonderful!
    Five years ago, I had my satellite TV subscription canceled rather than take any of them down. Of course, that was no real loss to me as I rarely watched TV but you should should see some people's faces when they find out why I canceled my service. They're so shocked ...until I tell them to go stand in the middle of the glen that is my front yard. Within a few minutes, they "get it."
    Heeh

    Ghosty
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC