An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

The Republicans Have Nothing to Party About


by Walter and Rosemary Brasch

Every House Republican and 11 Democrats voted against President Barack Obama’s $819 billion stimulus package. It still passed by a vote of 244 to 188.

There are enough votes in the Senate to pass the bill, but the obstructionist Republican minority, still nursing the wounds inflicted by the public in the November election, can block it by endless political maneuvering and a filibuster.

The Republicans wail that the President’s stimulus package is laden with spending proposals that don’t directly attack the recession. However, instead of debating the merits of the package, instead of proposing amendments to add to or subtract from the $819 billion, the Republicans ganged up, voted as a bloc, and placed party loyalty above the needs of the nation.

These are the same “fiscally responsible” Republicans who weren’t reluctant to give away billions of taxpayer money to Halliburton, KBR, and other corporations favored by the Bush–Cheney Administration. These are the same Republicans who did little to control runaway spending that brought the nation from a surplus when Bill Clinton left office to the largest deficit in the history of the nation. These are also the same Republicans, unfortunately assisted by a large chunk of complicit Democrats, who most assuredly weren’t reluctant to create a $750 billion bailout package that benefited banks, insurance companies, and the Wall Street millionaires of greed, and was lacking adequate oversight or accountability.

These are the same Republicans who came up with two tax cuts or rebates, most of which helped Big Business, with some chum thrown to the masses before the 2006 and 2008 elections. Rebates, which the Republicans demand be placed in the new stimulus bill, didn’t work then; they won’t work now.

And, now they oppose President Obama’s plan that would save or create about three million jobs, improve the nation’s infrastructure, provide health care for the uninsured, fund clear-water and environmental projects, provide housing assistance, improve mass transit, provide additional funding for special education programs, and assist both the workers and the nation to recover from a Recession that began more than a year ago.

The Republicans sniff that the President didn’t take their feelings into consideration.
However, unlike the previous “My way or the highway” President, this President met several times with the Republicans, got their advice and concerns, and included some of their suggestions into his proposed legislation. Apparently, the Republicans think bipartisan support means that the minority party must throw temper tantrums until they get everything it wants.

What these politicians don’t acknowledge is that their constituents, the American people, wanted Barack Obama to become president and lead the nation out of its myriad problems. One week after the inauguration, scientific polls showed President Obama with about a 70 percent popularity rating, the highest of any president in his first week. Only 12 percent were negative—the lowest of any president, and that includes George Washington.

In his inaugural address, Barack Obama told the nation “the time has come to set aside childish things.” A core of Republicans don’t understand this—they have dug in their heels and like Peter Pan are belting out the verse that they don’t want to grow up.

If the Republican minority continues to whine, complain, and try to block the nation’s recovery, they will cement their future as defenders of corporate greed and petty politics at the expense of the needs of the people.


[Rosemary R. Brasch is a former secretary, Red Cross national disaster family services specialist, and labor grievance officer. Walter Brasch is an award-winning journalist and university professor. You may contact him at brasch@bloomu.edu, or through his website, www.walterbrasch.com]

  • CStanley
    Those polls also show that a plurality of the American voters don't support the stimulus package in its current form.
  • DLS
    Most of us do NOT support the stimulus in its current form, not only because of bad experience with the bank bailout but also because of the nature of this "stimulus" gimmick-and-pork-laden monstrosity coming out of the House.

    No doubt about the Dems' current popularity (a natural supermajority or true majority currently -- greater than 61.8%), though not for Congress (about which a number of Democrats are out of touch -- many actually viewing the Democratic Congress favorably).


    http://pewresearch.org/pubs/1098/democratic-fav...


    And while Brasch regresses to his usual poor behavior, a more reasoned (and also critical) assessment of Bush can be found here.


    http://people-press.org/report/478/bush-legacy-...
  • Davebo
    If you wonder whether or not the GOP is serious about the economy and need for stimulus you need look no further than Republican congressional aides meeting with Joe the Plumber to gain his insight into the matter.

    They could care less.
  • DLS
    "Those polls also show that a plurality of the American voters don't support the stimulus package in its current form."

    In fact, a true supermajority (62%) in this country does NOT support the stimulus package in its current form. This is the important news, which this "moderate" [site] site has chosen to de-emphasize (while selecting extremist Brasch for publication) for some strange reason.


    Pass as is ................................ 38%

    Pass with major changes ..... 37%

    Reject ........................................ 17%

    Don't care ................................. 8%


    http://www.gallup.com/poll/114097/Americans-Sup...
  • CStanley
    Now if the GOP would stop the nonsense with Joe the Plumber and come forward with some serious ideas (even just taking the approach of supporting anything that's actual short term stimulus and relief and insisting that the rest be taken out so that it can be debated in normal time, they would be likely to have the support of the majority of Americans.
  • treen
    Oh, for the love of God. Like Pelosi gave the Republicans any other options than to vote No as a bloc. She wouldn't even accept amendments, so when was anyone supposed to propose anything. Whatever you think of Republicans in general, the House Democrats did nothing to win my support of this joke of a "stimulus" bill. And Pelosi's smug grin when she gaveled it closed? That was just as despicable as anything Limbaugh or Palin could say or do. This is neither the time nor the place for playing games with legislation, but Pelosi and Co. are not rising to the occasion any more than anyone else is or isn't.

    The Democrats appear to have no interest in fixing this country either with their wish list crap, so spare me your whining about "obstructionist" Republicans.
  • roro80
    The R's threw a fit about about the family planning -- it was taken out, even though any adult who's had a kid knows that getting ahead financially with them around is nearly impossible. They threw more fits about tax cuts -- now they're a full 1/3 of the package. Billions of dollars so that each adult can get $500 extra tax dollars -- that worked out *so* well last time. Thank goodness so many folks have last years' $600 saved up now that they don't have jobs. That's gonna pay a full week's rent! If the Republicans could come up with better ideas than "tax cuts" and "tax cuts" and more "tax cuts", maybe there could be some discussion here. What I've heard from the onslaught of right-leaning pundits is the same crap that got us into this mess in the first place -- tax cuts, deregulation, blah blah blah about bootstraps.

    I keep hearing terms like "pork" and "wish list". Let's be honest here -- if the Dem's wish list includes getting people back to work and being able to get by with lower health care costs and some extra unemployment checks, well, that's pretty much my wish for this stimulus too. Tax cuts are super, but that extra $500 isn't going to stem the job losses, it isn't going to pay for medical bills, it isn't going to get people out consuming again.

    And pork. "Pork" is a cute term for "infrastructure projects in my area that give people jobs". So I would encourage everyone from a Republican district to call your Congressperson and make sure none of the stimulus "pork" comes to your area to create jobs and give you better roads and bridges and cheaper health care. Because "pork" is bad, bad, bad.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC