An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Michael Steele: The Republican Harry Houdini

The “Man of Steele” has swooped in to save the G.O.P. Whoa, Nellie, not so fast… there is only enough room in this town for one Messiah and he lives at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue. I live in Maryland and until five years ago knew newly elected RNC Chair Michael Steele very well. There are only a handful of prominent African-American Republicans in Maryland so we tend to know each other pretty well. Michael is smooth, charismatic, and has a knack for being in the right place at the right time. Ten years ago, when I ran for Congress, he was Prince Georges’ County chair and there was a tax lien against his house… it is amazing how ten years is a lifetime in politics.

Michael’s problem is that he lacks credibility. His success has come at the expense of monumental failures of others that he has miraculously escaped with his reputation enhanced. If there is a Harry Houdini of Republican politics, it is Michael Steele. Here is a short list of his most notable escapes:

1) 1999 – After Ellen Sauerbrey’s second defeat for Governor, Steele as P.G. County Chair (one of three subdivisions that cost Sauerbrey her victory twice) was elevated to the office of State Party Chair.

2) 2006 – In his re-election year as Lt. Governor of Maryland, Steele and Bob Ehrlich split their successful pairing. Steele ran for the U.S. Senate and both men were defeated by sizable margins. The following year, Steele is appointed to be the head of GOPAC (the state and local candidate recruitment and training arm of the RNC).

3) 2009 – As Chair of GOPAC, it was Steele’s job to train Republican candidates for the 2008 election cycle to win elections… HE FAILED MISERABLY! Republican candidates were defeated across the board at all levels of government. However, he is once again rewarded for his failure by being tapped to be RNC Chair.

This is the time to put up or shut up. The Chairman position is not a forgiving one. In my opinion, Steele has to surround himself with people who are not going to pat him on the back and smile in his face. If he does not succeed in winning back Congressional seats in 2010, he may find that all the smoke and mirrors in the world will not allow him a clever escape from Capitol Hill.

  • While I wish Michael Steele good luck in his new position, I see his selection as a ploy for the GOP to make Blacks and other minorities feel like the party is suddenly pro minorities and anti racists.

    Please color me "UNIMPRESSED".

    Until the party adopts SUBSTANTIVE steps rather SYMBOLIC ones to address its INHERENT problems, it might as well be whistling DIXIE! OsiSpeaks[dot]com
  • I don't know my about Michael Steele. Unfortunately for him he will just be seen as a "me too" appointee. In any case I hope he brings some reason to the GOP
  • kritt11
    Yes- I live in Md, and he did nothing as Lt Gov.

    After promising to research whether the death penalty is applied more often to African-Americans than to whites, he failed to reach any conclusions or suggest any legislation to the legislature.

    Steele then failed to win the US Senate when people found out he had been recruited by Karl Rove and had received money from Bush/Cheney fundraisers (that he was afraid to attend, LOL) Its just a new face on the same old policies.
  • Terp
    Kritt11, actually the death penalty was pursued more in last century against whites than African-Americans if you do the numbers per capita charged with murder, but hey who cares about the actual evidence. Say whatever your Dem talking points are (whats next, digging up the Oreo incident?).

    The criticisms on this post of Michael Steele aren't fair at all. He, like others, have had their share of mistrakes, but criticizing him for Sauerbrey's 98 loss? And more so, becauce they lose Prince George's (or as most of us affably know it, PG) County? Anyone with just the slightest hint of Maryland politics know that there have always been the Big 3 for Dems for a while-- MoCo, PG, Balt City. Ehrlich/Steele '02 didn't win either. And Sauerbrey lost in 98 because Paris Glendenning read the tea leaves and took her wildly popular 25% income tax cut and decided to push a 10% income tax cut himself so he could steal the mantra of tax cuts.

    Steele is a dynamic speaker, motivator and visionary. If your charge is that he is not always the most detail-oriented then sure there is some credibility to that, but lets be fair, we all have our strengthes and weaknesses. Give the guy a chance before you dismiss him.

    And I really don't think Republicans picked Steele because he's Black. They picked him because he repudiated the policies of GWB and even said Bush was the scarlet letter (or at least thats what he meant). He said Bush mismanaged Iraq and Katrina, and that is something most Independent-minded Americans and conservative Democrats--people we're striving to win over--would agree with.
  • kritt11
    Gee he wasn't saying any of that when Bush was campaigning for him in the '06 race--- don't tell me he's a flip-flopper! Steele called him his "homeboy". It was his close relationship with the WH that Marylanders disliked the most.

    Now that Bush is out he has become the RNC's boogey man- and Steele suddenly has plenty to say.

    BTW-- my point wasn't about the death penalty it was about his promises to do something about it ---and eventual inaction as Lt Gov. He talks a very smooth talk but doesn't walk the walk.
  • gabrielpdansby
    And I really don't think Republicans picked Steele because he's Black. They picked him because he repudiated the policies of GWB and even said Bush was the scarlet letter (or at least thats what he meant). He said Bush mismanaged Iraq and Katrina, and that is something most mocospace.com Independent-minded Americans and conservative Democrats--people we're striving to win over--would agree with.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC