An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Little Iraqi Madonna: What Reality the News Media Suppresses When It Only Says “15 People Killed by Car Bomb Outside of Baghdad, November 16, 2008″

iraqi-madonna.jpg

The innocent; the children, the old people, the young policemen lying in their own blood, the relatives made instantly insane with grief.

Seeing/ knowing of these events, I’d like to humbly suggest an exhortation for us all. The exhortation starts with “Never never never never ever ever ever …” then, you please personally fill in the blank with whatever will preserve your sanity whilst allowing you to keep speaking up, acting up, never standing down about egregious matters.

For me, I think mine would go, “Never never never never ever ever ever … let the slaughter of innocents be taken to the cultural desert and buried in an unmarked political grave… and “Please, never never never never ever ever ever …” allow me to become inured, no matter how events in war grab and twist my tripes.

It’s so much easier to be inured, I think. So much easier. Mullen and I talk alot late a night about what a withdrawal from Iraq may presage, what slaughter of even more innocents might occur. We both remember the fall of Saigon intimately, people trying to throw their children over the walls of the embassy to save them, people trying to cling to the sled legs of the American helicopters in a desperate attempt to escape Saigon’s immanent bloodbath, but falling to their deaths instead.

If you would, please join me in praying for this father and mother of this little Iraqi madonna. In the photo, that is the child’s father. Please pray for all of us to be somehow impossibly wise, to be granted unlimited miracles in Iraq and Afghanistan and throughout the entire world. I am praying for you too, for your sanity, for your heart, for your endurance. That’s a promise.

______
CODA
Thank you Andrew Sullivan for passing this so very sad photograph forward. Many of us have come to believe that we cannot sanitize war’s realities by withholding horrendous images, that we are past being, must be past being careful about people’s visual sensitivities. In Latin, Horrescere, to act, to stand on end, bristle, be rough; to reveal the reality to prompt action. I regret deeply that that’s the exact ticket needed to roll hot at present.

  • Dave_Schuler
    Requiem æternam dona ea, Domine,
    et lux perpetua luceat ea.


    It's so much easier to avert your eyes.
  • archangel
    makes my eyes fill with stars, thank you dear Dave_Schuler for such a powerful heart prayer for the dead, praying in the final line, "May Perpetual LIght Shine upon her"... this little madonna.

    continuan, compadre.

    dr.e
  • spirasol
    You are brave to publish such pictures, Dr. E. We have been at war in Iraq for longer than WWII, and major media, the govt. do not print who the greatest victim of war is: the innocent. Who are the perpetrators? Put a blind fold on and let them spin you round and round. No matter where you point your finger..........yes it was them, and them, and they too.

    Where are the pictures of the Wedding party in Afghanistan?

    Yes, don't forget, and never let them tell you it was worth it.

    Ps: hats off to your husband and yourself for helping the ones who are cast out, the old GI's who can't live with themselves for what they have seen, experienced.
  • Silhouette
    One thing I hate most about wars, especially illegal ones like BigOil's invasion of Iraq on our tab, is that they try to hide the faces of death from us.

    Death is a sobering reminder of the cost of war. How many pro-life republicans could look on that picture and still continue to justify the breaking of most of the 10 Commandments all in the name of oil? I guess since that girl isn't a fetus, they don't care as long as there is capitalism to worship..

    This picture evokes anger, rage...but most of all astonishment. I am utterly astonished how voting members of the GOP can live double lives. One as "devout" christians who ostensibly revere all God's creations (even this little ethnic girl in the photo), and yet consistently line up behind politicians and policies that affect the exact opposite of reverence for life.

    Pro-life? My ass..

    I'd like a print of this picture to turn into a postcard to send to every member of Congress who still thinks this hostile corporate takeover (Iraq for Oil) is a good idea..
  • river
    Thank you Dr. E. for posting this horrific image of war and the ravage of innocence. . .with this photo the well constructed and enforced military strategy by invading countries to keep the other as, 'impersonal--strange--and foreign' (other than who and what we are)'. . . ALL dissolves. . .

    With deep knowing. . . we cannot deny every Dad which views the reality of this photo also is experiencing the beating heart of this collapsed Father. . .and although we cannot hear. . . we know every Mother's heart is filled with the grief and inexpressible anguish of the Mother of this beautiful young girl that has brutally been taken. . .A Mother that is struggling this moment and many many more to come to. . .and too many more like this young girl and her family. . . we can not see them yet this image is strong enough to stretch the far corners to envelope all of the innocent. . .

    Perhaps for a few minutes we lose words. . . and fall into the silence. . . We that are from this Nation with our vast military complex. . . our predominate National economic enterprise. . .which insures we have power and position in the world. . . So sad and so hard to look at. . .

    With this photo. . . perhaps we can truly see the "other" is not impersonal, foreign or strange. . .but we the collective are so very impersonal, foreign and estranged from our own hearts and soul that could allow such as this. . .

    I hope you continue to post these kinds of photos for they speak volumes. . .And yes, i will join in prayers for this sacrificial 'Christic Child' Madonna. . . and her family. . . and all. . . .
  • river
    dear Silhouette. . .i re-read you comment a couple of times. . .i think you make a poignant point about war photography and the Pro-life/Pro-choice ongoing debate. . .There really is a similarity. . . that which is not seen is so much easier to legislate for or against. . .i have many feminist leanings and have stood with Pro-choice. . . but as i saw this picture and sat in the silence the words that came for me were, "yes, it is time for the "seamless garment" for all peoples and all contexts. . . .both seen and unseen. . .
  • Ghostdreams
    Doc,
    I'm very glad you posted this pic but ....I worry.
    We've seen pictures not unlike this one before...
    Pictures of children in Viet Nam running naked, burning, napalm all over their little bodies.
    Pictures of children starving to death in "put name of third world country here"....
    Pictures of children thrown down, like so much trash, piled up in ditches during the Holocaust....
    and so on and so forth. The list is, as we all know, endless.

    I think that until the human race, as a whole, realizes that even one person dying as a consequence of war is too much ...
    Until the human race, as a whole, realizes that no amount of money is worth even one persons life ...
    Until the want and need for justice overcomes the wanton greed of money ....
    We are doomed to re-live these nightmares over and over and over again.

    One life = a whole universe of possibility and if only the people who start these insane military campaigns could see this.
    A whole UNIVERSE of possibility ...one child ....one person....
    A trillion dreams are undone before they had the chance to be dreamt and all in the blink of an eye.
    That is the true horror....the end of a life for ...
    What?
    A political agenda gone terribly awry? An oil deal too good to pass up and we can do it behind the guise of a "war against terror? A "Them" vs. "Us" war that lost track of who the good guys were supposed to be (as in the end, all to show for the war is a lot of dead people who only wanted to live their lives in peace)?

    It needs to stop but I have no answers and that is so frustrating.
    What happened to the good old days (when I was 20), many years ago and I had the answers for everything! All such surety is gone now.
    I find I have to stay hidden and stay to myself or I'll be overwhelmed with the need to just stop the world and get off. :(
    There's one thing I am sure of ....
    I hope the rest of the human race isn't as gutless as I am.
    I'm glad you posted this picture as it gives us much to consider, reflect on, and hope/pray our gov't isn't going to make the same mistakes that we've made before...
    We can but hope.

    Thanks for post doc!
    Ghost
  • spirasol
    What this photo and Brian DePalma's film "Redacted" have in common is the wonton killing of innocence. The film tells the true story of a 15 year old Iraqi female student who had to walk past an American checkpoint daily on her way to school where she was searched and remembered for her beauty.

    The movie also depicts the soldiers for who they are: young and immature, bored, horny, frightened, taught to hate their enemy, etc. In the movie as in real life they search the young girls house arresting the men of fighting age. They decide, despite much internal conflict, to return to the house at night to rape the girl. At the platoon level some participate some don't, and some can't live with themselves after. They rape her repeatedly, kill all her family members, including a baby, then they shoot her and throw gasoline over her body, lighting her up. Needless to say it was an incredibly uncomfortable film to watch.

    The soldiers too, are innocent, pumped up immaturity ready to spring in hatred. You need only point them and they will destroy what is in the way. It is what they are taught. The tragedy as I have read elsewhere is that there is nothing noble in their cause, in the war, and because of that the soldiers themselves have witnessed or participated in this kind of behavior so much they are coming home traumatized and killing themselves in epic proportions.

    It is when all laws, all morality falls to the wayside, a dark night of the soul, a place where all is lawless, much like the the film Apocalypse Now! where a once worthy General breaks down in his effort to understand the insanity of war, where he breaks away from central command to create his own army where rules and laws no longer matter, anarchy rules the day, and who lives and who dies can be decided by the animal instinct of the person beside you, who may suddenly develop an attachment to your ear as a souvenir of war.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC