An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

You Can’t be Half-Socialist (Guest Voice)

_50ED1181_93D9_4E59_973F_DA44512977C6_.gif

This is the first of two Guest Voice columns on Republican presidential candidate Sen. John McCain’s insinuations that Democratic candidate Sen. Barack Obama has socialist inclinations. Talk show host Michael Reagan, son of former President Ronald Reagan, believes Obama does. Guest Voice posts do not necessarily reflect the opinion of TMV or its many writers.

You Can’t be Half-Socialist

by Michael Reagan

The other day I went to a Hollywood luncheon crammed with producers, directors, writers and other film industry notables.

One of them, Larry Gelbart of “MASH” fame, spoke telling the group that since capitalism has failed, why don’t we try socialism?

Try socialism? Take a sip of it and see how it tastes? It doesn’t work that way.

There’s an old saying that you can’t be half-socialist any more than you can be half-pregnant; get knocked up with a socialist fetus and you’ll have to deliver a full-born Marxist. There’s nothing in between. Try it, you’ll like it, and if you don’t, as the lads in the Gestapo used to tell people, they had ways to make them like it.

Larry Gelbart gorged himself at the capitalist table and came away with untold millions, now safely banked, and continues to collect even more millions from never-ending reruns of the “MASH” sitcom. Having made his bundle from our capitalist free-enterprise system, he seems to be telling us now that the rest of us should get in the socialist bread-line and eat crumbs while he feasts on caviar.

One of the realities of this age is that the great mass of the American people haven’t traveled abroad to see how the rest of the world lives, a lot of it under dreary socialist regimes with stalled economies and no real chance for advancement for the ordinary citizen.

Moreover, our shoddy educational curriculum that has left most younger Americans so deficient in the study of history that vast numbers of them think George Washington was a Civil War general, or a lumberman who chopped down cherry trees. They have no real understanding of the economic system that allowed us to become the wealthiest and most powerful nation since the Roman Empire ruled most of the known world 2000 years ago.

Given that mournful reality, the moment the economic Rolls Royce engine that drove this nation to the top of the hill stalls, instead of installing new spark plugs to get it going again they go looking for an alternative mode of transportation.

In the present case, Obama and the Democrats are directing them to Larry Gelbart’s used-economic system lot where he shows them a jalopy with a fancy paint job on the outside and a one-cylinder motor inside that goes chug-chug.

Listening to the advice of a man who made his name and his money on a show about America’s military at war — yet told the same audience that our armed forces are nothing but “mercenaries” — doesn’t seem the smartest thing to do.

We are now a few days away from an election in which one of the presidential candidates is trying to sell that jalopy on Larry Gelbart’s lot and convince us that it is really a luxury limo that will get hundreds of miles to the gallon and carry us off to the promised land, where the rich will be impoverished and the middle class enriched and everybody will be deliriously happy.

Call Barack Obama’s program socialism, however and he’ll swear on a stack of Qurans it isn’t. He calls it change. He says it’s fairness, not Marxism.

Oh?

How does he explain the proven fact that he has been wallowing in a sty surrounded by fervent socialists and sharing in their swill for most of his life?

According to Fox’s Bill Sammon, his Messiahship recalled that when he attended Occidental College in Los Angeles: “To avoid being mistaken for a sellout, I chose my friends carefully,” he wrote in “Dreams From My Father,” his memoir. “The more politically active black students. The foreign students. The Chicanos. The Marxist professors and structural feminists.”

And that was his milieu for all his years in Chicago.

To anyone familiar with socialism, Obama’s programs fit comfortably within the pages of Karl Marx’s playbook, the root of which is the redistribution of the wealth, the key to the entire Obamian vault. What’s mine is yours, and he’s the middle man.

It’s socialism lite, and it can only evolve into socialism heavy. Remember, you can’t be half-socialist, and Barack Obama knows it.

Mike Reagan, the elder son of the late President Ronald Reagan, is heard on more than 200 talk radio stations nationally as part of the Radio America Network. ©2008 Mike Reagan. Mike’s column is distributed exclusively by: Cagle Cartoons, Inc.

Cartoon by Brian Fairrington, Cagle Cartoons

  • Amanda
    Geez. Michael needs a chill pill and a reality check. I can think of 3 programs off the top of my head that, technically speaking, are socialist. Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid have been on the books for decades, yet they haven't forced America into a full-blow Marxist state. Pure communism and socialism don't work - anyone who's at all familiar with 20th century history knows this. But that doesn't mean that certain aspects of socialism can't be blended into a capitalist, democratic society for the benefit of the entire nation.
  • D. E.Rodriguez
    Just anotherr case of typical Michaerthysm and McCairthysm
  • Why does anyone even give this guy a column? Oh yeah, it's so we can all see on the face how ridiculous and outdated his ideas are.

    Thanks for bolstering the credibility of liberal social-democratic hybrid policies by transparently flimsy, false-dichotomous arguments, Mr. Reagan.
  • SteveK
    It would be nice to see some of other brothers (Ron, the smart, thoughtful one) comments here, too.
  • JSpencer
    Any pretentious partisan fool could have written this. The only reason Reagan gets a soapbox is because of his name. He's just another in a long line of reactionaries trying to get mileage from misusing a word.
  • SteveK
    Looks like we've suffered another attack by the "Dastardly Down-rater"... too funny!
  • DLS
    What's more foolish is the overreaction to this.

    Milton Friedman correctly stated that our nation is roughly half socialized if you define this broadly or generally as being subject to government intervention, interference, or control. And people certainly can be less than 100% socialist. Even in the Soviet Union there was a concept (albeit very limited!) of private property (about which the State cared little, in fact).
  • edverb
    Barack Obama is talking about things voters care about -- education, energy independence, creating jobs, middle class tax cuts...and Michael Reagan is talking about Hollywood writers, the Gestapo (!), stacks of Korans, and poorly conceived car analogies that go on for too long.

    In this battle of ideas, Mr. Reagan comes equipped with little more than his last name and a badly written collection of right wing bugaboos.
  • kritt11
    All countries are a mix of capitalism and socialism. If you have a progressive tax system- that is socialism. Michael. even McCain does not favor a flat tax, and did not originally favor the George W Bush tax cuts. Either you are just trying to get attention like Ann Coulter or you've gone completely off the deep end. Being a liberal is not the same as being a Communist, a Marxist or a Socialist.

    We have had unadulterated rule by the markets for 8 years now with huge tax breaks for corporations and wealthy individuals. Not only does it not trickle down to the middle and lower classes, it doesn't even work for corporate America.

    BTW, I agree with Steve K. Your brother got all the brains and compassion in the family!
  • kritt11
    BTW, I forgot to add that McCain's plan to buy up bad mortgages and renegotiate the terms so that owners could stay in their homes falls way to the left of anything Obama has come up with! But that doesn't fit into your partisan worldview does it?
  • LGelbart
    Let me take a moment out of breakfasting on nothing but caviar, to remind Master (good taste forces me to use the diminutive) Reagan that what we have now is socialism for the rich. And that I wouldn't sell a used car to him or his father.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC