An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Sigmund Freud and the Global Financial Meltdown: Prensa Libre of Guatemala

Does the work of Sigmund Freud have anything to teach us about the global financial crisis and how to extricate ourselves from its clutches?

Margarita Carrera of Guatemala’s Prensa Libre reminds her readers that Freud didn’t only study sex – but the psychology behind economics and finance as well.

Carrera writes in part:

In his analysis of dreams, he discovered that all – absolutely everyone – are ‘colossal egoists.’ That is, egoism, deeply tied to the instinct for self-preservation and narcissism implacably governs us all. But he also realized that if human beings give in these primitive and selfish instincts, civilization itself is endangered … No one can deny the following Freudian principle: “Civilization has been achieved thanks to the relinquishment of the satisfaction of the instincts, and it demands that every individual repeat that renunciation to himself again and again.”

So what to do – given that these safeguards have clearly failed? Carrera goes on:

“But there’s an instinctive need that could save us: our need to be loved. So there’s a solution in sight that could save civilization. The individual learns to value being loved, and that helps him renounce his selfish, egotistical instincts. The task of civilization is to overcome the voracity of the individual and put limits on his or her boundless ambitions. Civilization’s purpose is to subject the policies of neo-liberalism to an exhaustive review, so that the powerful individual and those who deny the need for a State regulator not be fortified against the bankrupt majority – and so these have a place to turn in order to save themselves. ”

By Margarita Carrera

Translated By Paula van de Werken

October 16, 2008

Prensa Libre – Guatemala – Original Article (Spanish)

During the last century and up to today, the erroneous idea has persisted that Sigmund Freud devoted himself uniquely and exclusively to research into the sexual life of the individual – from the moment of his birth until his death. While it’s true that all humans are governed by the “libido,” that doesn’t mean that Freud focused his research exclusively on that subject. He also worked in the world of economics and politics, to the point of making severe criticisms of the capitalist system.

In his analysis of dreams, he discovered that all – absolutely everyone – are “colossal egoists.” That is, egoism, deeply tied to the instinct for self-preservation and narcissism implacably governs us all. But he also realized that if human beings give in these primitive and selfish instincts, civilization itself is endangered. And as amazing as it may seem, he spoke of the immense evil that festers in society when impunity operates with such effectiveness that justice disappears. His actual words were:

READ ON AT WORLDMEETS.US, along with continuing translated foreign and English-language foreign press coverage of the unfolding financial crisis.

  • archangel
    Just two cent's worth:

    Common sense, not Freud, notes that humans can be self-interested often enough. Humans dont 'learn to want to be loved.' That is an innate drive in most all, as is the desire to love in many ways, also inborn.

    Freud did not 'discover' egotism as the center of dream content; he noted that his nearly exclusively upperclass white patients were consumed with the desire for and ambivilance about power and money and class status. Freud made some valuable observations which are not noted in this article, but his sampling was narrowest of narrow, and peculiar to his time and economic class.

    The desire to be loved will not save an economy. Asserting a need to be loved is even more of the narcissism that the author relegates as the cause of the problem to begin with.

    There are solutions to be sure. They will come from clear headed people, not from an anachronistic system that believed one ought lie down on a couch five times a week free associating.

    A sturdy psychology of culture is built not on theoretical premises, but on real time observation of human beings, the broad complexity of the species... and then on effective actions that rely on palpable facts and a vision that is pragmatic as well as far seeing.

    Many persons carry these qualities. They are currently roaring the solutions aloud to whomsoever will listen. I think many of us are listening hard to the living.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC