An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

An Obama Election Day Blowout: The Thing That No One Yet Dares Speak The Name Of

01aaa_obama_conv.jpg

My capacity for being surprised has somehow endured despite writing thousands of news stories, commentaries and blog posts about pretty much everything from the fact that pigs really can fly (in reserved USAir seats) to O.J. Simpson being acquitted for murder (despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary). And so it is with signs that Barack Obama may be on the verge of blowing out John McCain.

This outcome, which if it is sustained would easily rank atop a fairly hefty list of surprises in the nine presidential campaigns that I have covered, is heightened by the fact that:

* Going into the campaign, McCain was a widely known and hugely respected veteran campaigner while Obama was a near unknown.

* Obama has had to contend with the bitter aftershock of beating Hillary Clinton and the bitter stain of racism.

* McCain has had at hand shrewd, battle-tested managers, many of them magna cum laude graduates of the Karl Rove School of Divide-and-Conquer Politics.

* Even with the widespread disaffection for all things Bush, Obama’s change-and-hope mantra was vague and seemingly naive.

* The ability of the Republicans to rally around a candidate in contrast to the Democrats’ hard-earned reputation for grabbing defeat from the jaws of victory.

I’m not a high-stakes gambler like McCain, and I’ll hedge my sense of surprise by noting that the signs of a blowout come in the closing weeks of a campaign distinguished by enormous swings. This may yet have the effect of neutralizing a truisim of presidential politics — that voters pretty much make up their minds by the beginning of October.

That so noted:

* Virtually all trend lines favor Obama.

* Obama has broken 50 percent in most national polls and despite the ping-pong dynamic of the polls this season, McCain has had no discernible bounceback in days.

* Obama has moved ahead in Florida, Colorado and several other states crucial to McCain.

* McCain is pulling campaign staff out of the battleground state of Michigan. (Obama has pulled out of North Dakota.)

* Obama’s favorables are increasing in tandem with McCain’s unfavorables, and at a time when President Bush’s unfavorables have reached an historic low.

* Sarah Palin’s disapproval ratings have converged with and are passing her approval ratings, while last night’s exercise in lowered expectations changed few minds.

And the numbers that ultimately matter the most — Electoral College projections — average out at 327 for Obama and 201 for McCain. That, my friends, is a blowout.

It is way too early for post mortems, but try this pre-mortem on for size: McCain may have run out of road because he has based his campaign on shock, smoke and mirrors. And is guilty of grand theft in shamelessly appropriating his opponent’s change meme.

In running a campaign a mile wide and an inch deep, McCain has left himself vulnerable to events on the ground, as they say, and nothing is playing bigger on the ground in states like Michigan than the economy. As it is, Obama has had trouble connecting with blue-collar voters in that state and elsewhere, but McCain has proven to be so inept when it comes campaigning on the economy that he had to cut his loses.

It is now way too late for McCain to pull another robbery. That would be stealing a key ingredient that has gotten Obama to where he is — substance.

One more thought in squaring the surprise circle:

Obama, like the man that it increasingly looks like he will succeed, is largely untested. Like that man, he will need to depend to an extraordinary extent on advisers who are tested.

In that respect voters are rolling the dice just as they did in 2000. Pretty scary, eh?

Photograph by Rick Wilking/Reuters

  • Wow. Talk about jinxing your candidate. If I had written that, McCain would suddenly and mysteriously surge and win by a landslide.
  • DLS
    Shaun, you need either to boost or replace your Thorazine.

    Normal people simply have this to say about McCain: We see McCain's pullout from Michigan (which hands plenty of electoral votes to Obama) as _possibly_ the beginning of the end. More states conceded later, more signs like Speer saw in 1944-45.
  • superdestroyer
    The real quesiton now is how much the down ticket Republicans will be affected by the incomptence of the McCain campaign. Realclearpolitics.com has the Democrats winning at least 58 seats. As McCain continues to slide, it is conceivable that the Democrats will get to 60 seats in the Senate (something that the Republicans never achieved from 1994 to 2006).

    The other question is how much longer will the Republicans be relevant to the political process. Given the collapse of the Republicans, the obvious incompetence, and the changing demographics of the U.S., it will be virtually impossible for a conservative party to remain relevant in politics.
  • Blowout? I respectfully disagree with you. I just can't see how "the black dude" can pull that out. If it happens, I will buy you a fine bottle of wine of your choosing.

    Maybe I'm just like other black folks. We just can't believe Obama will pull it out no matter what the polls say.
  • elrod
    I would hesitate before predicting any major electoral victory for Obama. There are two more Presidential debates left and outside events could intervene.

    Sillhouette's dreamed Larry Sinclair video could prove true...ahem.

    The economy could stage a massive recovery in the coming weeks and focus will turn to Obama's inexperience.

    A relentlessly negative culture-war attack from McCain could sow new doubts in the minds of conservative Democrats.

    Yes, many things can happen to change the race in the next five weeks.
  • Given the recent trend lines in the key swing states I'm watching, while I''m not ready to call the election "over" yet, I do find it harder and harder to see a path to 270 for McCain. On the other hand, 538.com is currently predicting 331 EV for Obama with McCain barely breaking 200, which I think is a bit optimistic. October is traditionally the month when the vast majority of people who will eventually make the actual trip to the polls and vote begin fully paying attention and the numbers start to congeal. Of course, they use the phrase "October surprise" lightly. There could still be a major game changer coming, but I'm not bright enough to see what it might be.

    Absent such a change, though, as I said, it's getting harder and harder to see a path to victory for the McCain campaign. If the economic crisis is "handled" and somehow fades from the news in the next two weeks, *perhaps* McCain cold see a resurge, but it's hard to picture.
  • superdestroyer
    T-Steel,

    The blow out will be bigger than people believe because this may be the first eleciton where black turnout as a percentage of registered voters could exceed white voters. McCain has alienated many traditionally conservative groups and the incomptence of the McCain has turned off many white voters who would vote for him.

    However, black voters will probably turn out in record numbers even in states where Obama is a sure winner or were the polls show that McCain should win.

    The increase in black voter turnout will probably cause Elizabeth Dole to lose her seat in North Carolina and could affect the Senate seats in Kentucky, Mississippi, and Georgia.

    McCain's only issue is that he is not Obama and that is not a good enough reason for moderate, rural, white swing voters to put the effort into voting.
  • DLS
    I simply believe much will depend on how McCain does in the remaining debates. That, and what else may go wrong with the economy in the next month. (How I hope the GOP House contingent rejects the second bailout bill!)
  • GeorgeSorwell
    Am I the only one who thinks copious quantities of mud are about to be flung at Obama?
  • superdestroyer
    In July, I wrote that the only way that Senator Obama could lose is to be caught in bed with a live boy or a dead girl. I can see that others realize that has always been the case.
  • mw
    "Pretty scary, eh?" -sm

    Way.
  • jwild
    Yes a blowout and I am afraid the turnout will be so huge that they will have to turn people away that is why I encourage people to vote early. While as a Senator in Illinois, I encourage Barack to run because I saw qualities in him to be a great leader (also confirmed now by Bill Clinton). I encouraged him to pick Biden and I especially like the smart people that he has picked to run his campaign and I am very confident that his cabinet posts will be people of high calliber as well. He already said that things will be not perfect and has the ability to level with the American public.
    As the article summed it up, the stars are all in alignment for this monumental change for Barack. Please give Barack the kudos for running an excellent campaign. The man is smart and has good instincts. The world will be a better place. Many Americans do not realize how important this election is to people from other countries, On Jan,2009 we will finally be able to say that America has finally lived up to their ideals by electing the first Black President of the United States of America because he will have to be both an Abraham Lincoln to bring this country together and a Franklin Rosevelt to clear up the economic mess.
  • I don't know what constitutes a "blowout" but I see 330 EV's for Obama as the floor.
  • Lit3Bolt
    I think, in future elections, Republicans will heed this lesson and pick an an anti-war candidate.
  • mw
    During the primaries, there was no clearer indicator that Obama was at a popular peak, then when Obamites started trotting out the inevitability meme. Right before New Hampshire, Super Tuesday, Ohio etc. But he did squeak through as the Dem nominee - so I guess the Obamites were right in the end.

    BTW - Shaun I never followed up on the prediction of an Obama blowout in PA that you posted here a few days before the primary vote. How did that turn out?
  • superdestroyer
    lit3bolt,

    In four years, the Obama administration could be trying either to stay in Afghanistan or why the chaos is the middle east is not worth bothering about. Either way, it four years, a position on a war will be pointless.

    What has happened is that the Republicans have stopped standing for anything. The republicans spend at a faster rate than Democrats and are just as corrupt. The Republicans are also too stupid to understand the demographic wave that will bury them.
  • jkarczek
    Just based on experience, I have a tough time believing that what we're seeing now in polling will hold up throughout the next four weeks, much less once Presidential voting closes. The truth is that with the possibility that global events will intrude at any time, relating to the economy or national security, as they did in '04, and knowing the day to day capriciousness of "registered voters", I cannot believe we won't see at least one sea change in the next couple weeks. When it comes time to place their votes, I think a lot of people will break for McCain when their ideal image of themselves and what they want retreats to be replaced by habitual patterns of thinking. People lie all the time, whether they mean to or not. Obama may win, but I think just as with the primary campaign, it will turn out to be extremely close.
  • Obama, like the man that it increasingly looks like he will succeed, is largely untested. Like that man, he will need to depend to an extraordinary extent on advisers who are tested.

    In that respect voters are rolling the dice just as they did in 2000. Pretty scary, eh?

    Even more scary is the idea that McCain could still win. McCain has been tested, and he failed.
  • jkarczek
    The old breaking at the end rule is less significant now that people are voting early. It is estimated that one third will vote before election day and people are voting now.
  • jkarczek
    RB,

    That's a fair point, but I still can't imagine how this race won't tighten up dramatically in the weeks ahead. The other question is who is likely to cast their vote early? Not undecided voters in battleground states most likely. They are the all important X factor. All it takes is for a few percent of them to waver in a couple of critical states like Pennsylvania, Florida or Ohio to rewrite the election map.
  • DLS
    Prior to Palin's choice for VP I foresaw the possibility of such a blowout. That would apply to not only the Presidency and Vice Presidency but the Dems versus the GOP in Congress. I have revised that, though I believe the Palin swoon is overwith (and so is the latest large exposure we may well see -- the media may relegate her now all the time the way they underreport or neglect to report the crowds she draws and what that means for GOP voter turnout; the media may also now overcome its fear of Biden gaffes and start broadcasting once more appearances by Biden as well as appearances by Obama, while failing to do the same for McCain).

    If we want to return to my previous threshold for what is substantial -- again, it's the "golden" or "divine" proportion. Will Obama beat McCain by more than 61.8 per cent to 38.2 per cent? Prior to Palin's choice, I said it was possible. I don't believe it is so now, but the margin is likely to increase now, given problems with the economy.

    Look at the current divergence in the two following trend graphs, and look at the graphs again around the middle of next week to see if there is any more divergence, or if Palin gave a number of GOP voters enough hope that McCain could still prevail, in the end, that you'll see a reversal and actually see some measure of convergence.


    http://iemweb.biz.uiowa.edu/graphs/graph_Pres08...

    http://iemweb.biz.uiowa.edu/graphs/graph_Pres08...


    (If all voters were smart and moral, there would be a crossover as early as today! Biden actually said that his team wants to let judges rewrite loans and actually go so far as not only to reduce interest, but principal! What an Evo Morales-style stunt.)
  • DLS
    (If you analyze it, that proportion I listed above is the threshold of a true supermajority vote. The ratio of the smaller to the larger value is the same as the larger value to the whole or sum or total.)
  • mlhradio
    If today was November 3rd instead of October 3rd, then I would be thinking about the possibility of a blowout.

    But so, so very much could happen in a month's time. Go back to September 3rd, could anyone here imagine all that has happened in the past month? Not just the dozen or so improbable political twists and turns, but also the rollercoaster of the economic blowout, the hurricane aftermath, the gas shortages?

    Ten points ahead a month before the election means nothing. I've said it before, I'll say it again -- The old saying goes, Overnight is a lifetime in politics. Therefore, one month equals thirty lifetimes. Don't start hoping for a blowout just yet, there's a long way to go before we reach that stage.
  • StockBoySF
    While it's always fun to read about a major blowout for one's candidate I'm not holding my breath. McCain will become increasingly negative as his poll numbers go down and outside events will continue to shape the race. However if McCain holds true to form, McCain will make rash decisions around those events that will hurt him.

    There was a cartoon earlier this summer (I think around the time Obama was in Germany) and the punch line was (around some significant event), "What is Obama doing?" (The idea being Obama made good decisions and the Republicans wanted to make a good decision, but didn't know how.) McCain may start following Obama's lead around outside events.... McCain really came across as a novice politician around the bailout bill and throwing his eggs in the basket so hard that they broke going in....
  • Leonidas
    I expect the popular vote to be within a few percentage poits one way or the other. Obama has a slightly larger lead in polls recently but we will see if it can last. Also, I'm skeptical about how much of Obama's polled support will show up to actually vote. His campaign is pretty skilled at mobilzation but we have heard about how this is the election that the youth vote will finally turn out for before. We will just have to wait and see. I give it about a 50/50 chance of either result.

    As far as being the thing noone dares speak of, not true at all, the propaganda is all over the liberal web sites and they are trying to sell the eminent victory of their candidate before the votes to discourage McCain supporters. THe fact is although Obama has added a bit to his polling leads, for what thats worth, this election is still incredibly close.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC