An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Palin’s Swipe at Obama Hits People Who Do Important Work

It was one of the most memorable lines in Governor Sarah Palin’s acceptance speech at last week’s Republican National Convention. Responding to accusations that her service as mayor of an Anchorage suburb doesn’t commend her for vice president, Palin referred to Senator Barack Obama’s work as a community organizer, “I guess a small-town mayor is sort of like a community organizer, except that you have actual responsibilities.”

The crowd roared. But is it fair to community organizers?

Take a look at this convincing column by Columbus Dispatch writer Ann Fisher and tell me what you think.

Why do pols feel that to defend themselves they must attack others?

[My personal blog is here.]

  • JSpencer
    Mark, there is only one reason why a crowd would roar at such a comment, and that is because they are letting their party do their thinking for them. It goes to a Thomas Jefferson quote one of my brothers mailed to me this morning:

    "Preach a crusade against ignorance.
    Let our countrymen know,
    that the people alone can protect us against the evils of kings,
    priests, and nobles who will rise up among us,
    if we leave the people in ignorance"

    One of my good Canadian friends suggested that many outside the country will interpret a republican victory this fall as the symptom of a nation in decline. I suppose that's obvious enough to those who have maintained their objectivity and awareness over the years, and it correlates with my own view of this election as being a sort of national IQ test. (another one)
  • RememberNovember
    Didn't you know? Politics in the Twenty First Century isn't about issues- it's about Fear/Smear and Cheer, at least according to Mark Davis- Lobbyist extrordonaire.

    We have a dichotomy- a candidate who has been working for the people, and a candidate who has been working the people over.

    JSpence- that is a great quote. One would add lobbyists and special interests to that list, I think.
  • jwest
    Although I know I’ll take more heat for this, the political tone-deafness concerning “community organizers” is nothing short of remarkable.

    To the vast majority of Americans, a community organizer is a political hack who sells victimhood for yearly installment payments of votes. Why is it that democrats have trouble realizing the image they are dealing with?

    Don’t bother with tales of heroic selflessness of community organizers you’ve known and loved through the years. This comment deals only with the public image, not the reality.

    Republicans were happy to take their swipe at community organizers in response to the democrat’s diss of small town mayorship. If people believe that they can make community organizers into a positive image, the right will roll out a tribute to the more famous ones – Jesse Jackson and Al Sharpton. This is the image Barack has fought to avoid.
  • DLS
    "Community organizer" is a name and a practice that has been tainted.

    To answer Mark Daniels's question _and_ the core issue: Next time, the instigator of attacks, the Obama campaign and the liberal media, should remember that the other side is free to rightly retaliate.
  • DLS
    "democrat’s diss of small town mayorship"

    Which, of course, failed among the intelligent to evade the real issue, that Palin has executive experience, not only as a mayor, but as a _governor_, the most relevent kind of experience for someone in a leadership position in the executive branch of the federal government, the kind of experience of which Obama has none -- "ZERO."

    Obama has been touted as having as an _asset_ that he is inexperienced in Congress, that he is not a fixture or establishment figure there -- until the selection of Palin by McCain for Vice President. Now he (with no executive experience, unlike Palin, and little in Washington) is touted (Biden is clumsily ignored) as "the one with experience." Poof! Another Obama campaign reversal of position presents itself.
  • The only quote I can offer- "Jesus Christ was a community organizer, and Pontius Pilate was a governor."
  • From DLS:
    Now he (with no executive experience, unlike Palin, and little in Washington) is touted (Biden is clumsily ignored) as "the one with experience."


    In all fairness, it is interesting that you "clumsily ignored" John McCain's lack of executive experience in that same thread of thought.

    There are enough difference between the actual candidates for President, Barack Obama and McCain, than to spend time on non-issues such as these. Our last Governor-turned-President was George Bush. Is this really a line that the Republican Party wants to encourage?
  • RememberNovember
    The only quote I can offer- "Jesus Christ was a community organizer, and Pontius Pilate was a governor."

    Pontius had Execution experience all right.

    and Palin's Pentecostal proslytizing gleefully pontificates on Alaska being a "refuge" for the End Times;;


    Do we really need a religious wacko a heartbeat away? Someone eager to push the button while she sits in a cabin on the North Slope with her Seccessionist buddies? That kind of Executive experience?

    Check her stumping for these yahoos as Executive majestrix Mayor of Wasilla:

    http://tw.youtube.com/watch?v=naXqE4dTxPA

    Is that before or after the Mud Flats run black with oil....



    Word.
  • Which, of course, failed among the intelligent to evade the real issue, that Palin has executive experience, not only as a mayor, but as a _governor_

    Not like Republicans have bothered mentioning any of the things Obama has done after being a community organizer. McCain was lying just last week when he said that Obama had not offered up any bipartisan legislation, or any major legislation at all.
  • jchem
    I guess my only questions would be what exactly did Obama do as a community organizer? What happened as a result? By what metrics were success measured? Looking at his website, the only thing I can find with regard to these questions is the following:

    "The group had some success, but Barack had come to realize that in order to truly improve the lives of people in that community and other communities, it would take not just a change at the local level, but a change in our laws and in our politics."

    http://www.barackobama.com/learn/meet_barack.php

    So are the people he went there to help any better off now than what they were when he began?

    I certainly applaud his work in this regard, but I just want to know what exactly happened as a result of his work.
  • jchem,
    Why do you even care? Seriously. Like I just said, Obama has done plenty of things since becoming a community organizer straight out of college.

    Do you care about Sarah Palin's performance as a sportscaster? How about John McCain endlessly crashing navy planes?
  • jchem
    Chris,

    jeez...so much for just asking.

    Of course I care because Obama uses that as experience. If Palin was out there trotting out saying that her sportscasting in some way qualified as experience, then by all means let's examine it. Let's examine it anyway, just for the fun of it. What did it gain her?

    Get a grip Chris; I'm just asking what I thought were some relevant questions. I wouldn't have asked otherwise. They still stand, unless they don't warrant any honest discourse.
  • My apologies for jumping down your throat.
  • jchem
    Chris,

    No hard feelings. Like you, I would prefer to talk about his work since his community organizing days, but I was just curious about the work he did do. My vote would certainly not be swayed by the outcome--I just had a few thoughts of my own that I couldn't seem to find any answers to.
  • roro80
    jchem -- I think yours was the best question asked here, personally. Ok, so what is community organizing, and what did it involve for this particular community organizer. So, I looked it up.

    http://newsweek.washingtonpost.com/onfaith/geor...

    http://www.thenation.com/blogs/campaignmatters/...

    What I see from this: he did a lot of good things, he was a kid just out of college trying to do something to help his community, and it's obviously not his most recent or significant experience as far as being qualified for the presidency. I think it's significant also that he hadn't even entered law school, and he most certainly wasn't running for any office at this time -- which pretty much debunks Gulianni's assertion that he was doing it to buy votes.
  • jchem
    roro80,

    Thanks for the links.

    The fact Obama stuck at it for the length of time he did on the meager salary given to him speaks volumes to me about the man's character. He notes that there were "some successes" but I get the impression that he wishes that somehow he could have done more.

    It seems a bit ironic comparing H.W. Bush's remarks back then to the current debate going on now with the Palin/Obama rift.

    By the way, if you're interested I also stumbled across a US News & World Report article from 2007 that could complement the NewsWeek article:

    http://www.usnews.com/usnews/news/articles/0708...
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC