An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Bob Barr goes for the privacy vote

CNet calls it a long-shot bid for the geek vote:

Speaking [in Las Vegas] at a political conference on Friday, Barr focused almost exclusively on privacy and eavesdropping–and argued that both major parties are far too surveillance-happy. “Both of them will continue down the same track,” Barr said, noting that both McCain and Obama supported last week’s bill to immunize telecommunications companies that illegally opened their networks to government snoops.

Congress’ legislative rewrite of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act is “not about surveilling Al Qaeda,” Barr said. “It’s about surveilling U.S. citizens in America.” He added, for good measure: “This administration is the most anti-privacy, the most anti-individual freedom, in our nation’s history, certainly in my lifetime.”

This is hardly a Bush-McCain species of Republican speaking. It underlines Barr’s appeal: If you’re a traditional conservative who disagrees with the big-government policies, the surveillance, the inflation, the deficit spending, and the unnecessary wars of the Bush administration, vote for me. I was one of you, once.

It might work. More precisely, it might work well enough–think a Republican equivalent of Ralph Nader–to make a difference in states that would have tilted toward McCain otherwise. It’s certainly a more attractive message than the Libertarians’ 2004 candidate, a telemarketer-turned-programmer, had to offer.

Barr has an arch-conservative voting record, but claims he’s an honest-to-goodness convert to the cause:

He said a long time ago that he regrets voting for the Patriot Act; he wants an Iraq withdrawal “without undue delay”; the head of the Marijuana Policy Project formally nominated Barr at the Libertarian convention; Barr even endorsed a Libertarian presidential candidate in 2004. He founded a group called the American Freedom Agenda that opposes the White House’s policies in the so-called war on terror, and his supporters note he embraced a wealth of privacy measures while in Congress (see our coverage from 2002). [...]

Barr also likes to swipe at the Real ID Act, a law creating a federalized identity card that’s effectively on hold until December 31. “It was passed by the Congress not as a national ID, which it is in every way except a name,” he said. “It is a national ID for the first time in our nation’s history…If certain people were elected president it would not go into effect.”

During the Libertarian Party’s presidential debate in Denver, the candidates were asked what they’d do about Real ID and the Patriot Act. Barr’s reply was captured on video by C-SPAN: “Fear has become the driving force behind all public policy in our country…(For the Patriot Act), I’d drive a stake through its heart, shoot it, burn it, cut off its head, burn it again, and scatter its ashes to the four corners of the world.”

RELATED: Posted on Barr’s website, his appearance on CNN’s Newsroom addressing the spoiler question.

Er, if it looks like a duck and quacks like a duck…

  • DLS
    It's more like the Childish Vote. The word "privacy" is ridiculously abused. This actually has next to nothing to do with the misbehavior of the Bush administration.
  • dkmeller
    Thank you for an intelligent and well-written account of the Libertarian positions regarding Privacy and overzealous surveillance. Obama and most of the Democrats are far too weak, vaccillating and inconsistant on these issues to be of any use to the American voter, and McCain and most Republicans are flatly HOSTILE to civil liberties, privacy, and Due Process!

    It is time that we Americans started evaluating new and better candidates for the Presidency and other offices. Both McCain and Obama may be good men in their private lives, but they are utterly inadaquate for the Presidency even in normal times, much less the crises which seem to be looming both in the economy and Foreign policy!

    PEACE AND FREEDOM!!
    David K. Meller
  • dkmeller
    to Cnet:

    Privacy, due Process, and overzealous surveillance are issues which involve all of us, NOT only the "geek vote"
  • runasim
    Making a fetish out of privacy, or any other single right or liberty is as silly and dangerous, as ignoring the importance.
    I don't buy the Pope's absolutism, and I'm not swayed by the obsessions of Libertarans like Barr.
    Give me a pagmatist every time.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC