An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

McCain Says His GOP Role Model Is Teddy Roosevelt

071011_nobel_roosevelt_vmed12p.widec.jpg

Republican presumptive Presidential nominee Sen. John McCain’s interview with the New York Times is sparking much online discussion — and derision — for his comments about not being a computer user or big computer fan. But it skirts the interview’s key point: in this interview McCain answered the question about what kind of Republican he wants to be — and it is NOT in the mold of President George W. Bush.

In fact, McCain has noted what other journalists and biographers have long noted: his role model is early 20th century political maverick President Teddy Roosevelt, the GOPer who for a while redefined his party with his trust-busting and pro-environmental, conservationist policies.

This is no throw-away bit of information, because the American public has now seen several versions of McCain. The 2000 maverick McCain, the pre-campaign 2008 McCain who sought to win over Republicans who scuttled his 2000 chances, and now the McCain running for election who’s trying to appeal to several often conflicting constituencies at the same time while facing a different kind of Democrat.

It’s worth looking at a chunk of these quotes where McCain talks about TR:

Boldface is added here for a few of the more important points:

Q: How do you think of your self as a conservative. Do you think of yourself more as a Goldwater conservative or Reagan conservative or George W. Bush conservative.

Senator John McCain: A Teddy Roosevelt conservative, I think. He’s probably my major role model, we could go back to Lincoln, of course. In the 20th century Teddy Roosevelt. I think Teddy Roosevelt he had a great vision of America’s role in the 20th Century. He was a great environmentalist. He loved the country. He is the person who brought the government into a more modern – into the 20th century as well. He was probably engaged more in national security slash international affairs that any president ever been. I understand that TR had failings. I understand that every one of my role models had failings. TR became embittered at the end, we all know that. If you look at his presidency, if you looked at his reformist agenda from the time he was the police commissioner in New York City…..

Ask any member of a respected environmentalist group that is not a front group for the Bush administration and they will tell you that the Bush administration is considered to have one of the worst environmental records in American history. Also, this signals (again) McCain’s advocacy of a strong foreign policy, which supporters applaud and foes fear could be trigger-finger. MORE:

Q: You don’t believe in small government, the sort of classic conservative view of minimal government is not one you would necessarily share

Mr. McCain: I guess my view is I believe less governance is best governance and that government should not do what the free enterprise and private enterprise and individual entrepreneurship and ¬¬ the states can do. But I also believe there is a role for government. If there is abuses, TR was the first guy to enforce the Sherman anti-trust act against the quote trusts that were controlling the economy of America. Because I believe his quote was unfettered capitalism leads to corruption. So there certainly is a role for government but I want to keep that role minimal. And I want to keep it in the areas where only governments can perform those functions.

Government should take care of those in America who can’t care for themselves. That’s a role of government. It’s not that I’m for no government. It’s that I’m for government carrying out those responsibilities that otherwise can’t be exercised by individuals and the states — that’s the founding principles of our country — and at the same time recognizing there’s a role for our government and society to care for those who can’t care for themselves, to make sure there are not abuses of individual rights as well as the rights of groups of people and to defend our nation. And National Security is obviously No. 1.

Given this quote, it’s hard to believe how McCain — if he truly patterns himself after TR — can keep former Senator Phil Gramm as a) his adviser b) in consideration for any administration post, c) anywhere near him anymore. Gramm’s contention that people who see America in recession are suffering from some kind of political mental problem (”a mental recession”) and that critics of the state of the economy are “whiners” is the kind of old-school, cliched view of fat-cat “the economy looks great to me because I’m rich” Republicans that doesn’t fit into the TR mold.

The average American has to wonder if Gramm came up with his sound bite while his driver drove him to his interview.

To find out more about Teddy Roosevelt GO HERE.

So now voters have seen the McCain jumping through the primary and general election hoops and they know his stated role model. Another factor that could impress some independent voters: one of McCain’s most enthusiastic backers is California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, who still marches to his own independent drummer, even as his poll results nosedive due to California’s economic ills. It’s clear Schwarzenegger feels McCain is the real deal.

The question now becomes: which is the real McCain?

Is it the guy jumping through the political hoops?

Or is it or the guy who wants to be like TR — a President who did it HIS way once he got in?

The answer to this question could help determine how McCain does in the general election when he runs against a more nimble kind of Democrat and will need the votes of independent voters who don’t want Bush Lite.

McCain might get a better answer if he sends Gramm back to Texas to count Gramm’s fat bank account that most complaining Americans don’t have one or are now losing it due to the Bush recession — even if Gramm whines about it.

  • Neocon
    Its time for Presidents to realize that they must represent ALL Americans. For the first time in a long time Both candidates are trying to reach out to their bases but also to the other side of the isle.

    Good for them. The key will be in who is actually wedded to their party more. McCain or Obama. McCain is despised by the far right...........Obama is embraced by the far left.

    Guess who Im betting on?
  • JSpencer
    The "key" will be which candidate is most believable when it comes to representing the middle class. These are the folks who are in the majority, independent of party, and they are the ones who have been taking a beating economically. Are you better off now than you were 4 years ago? 8 years ago? (top 5% income earners need not answer)

    Also, when McCain claims to admire Teddy Roosevelt because, "He was a great environmentalist", take it with many grains of salt. Records compiled by the League of Conservation Voters show that Obama's voting stats on environmental issues are about 3 times better than McCains.
  • I don't think this is the first time McCain has mentioned Teddy as his role model. I know he's said it somewhere before. Might have been one of the debates.
  • He can claim to be a fan and model himself after TR all he wants, doesn't make it true. TR was the first to recognize the need for national parks to protect this nations natural wonders from corporate exploitation. He also supported government regulation and oversight of the food industries, and was well known for busting monopolies. Judging by McCain's position on issues is Bush's position on issues 95% of the time (that is of course, when he actually votes on something). All those positions are the exact opposite of what TR stood for.
  • Jim_Satterfield
    To claim a previous president as role model is one thing. To actually implement the 21st century equivalents of that president's policies is another. When it comes to specifics McCain does not necessarily stand for what TR would want done if he could analyze our current world.
  • superdestroyer
    Jspender,

    Neither party represents the private sector employeed middle americans with children in pubic schools. Since both support open borders and unlimited immigraiton, neither care about trying to raise real wages. Since both are liberal on immigration neither care about the quality of public education. SEnator Obama does not appear to care all about that academic education since he is beholden to the teachers unions and openly promotes social engineering instead of academic education.

    It is hard to believe that either really care much about the environment since they support open borders and unlimited immigraiton. If candidates reall believes in spending less time in traffic and preserving open space, they would not be promoting such large number of immigrations each year.
  • Republicans would be politically smart to adopt TR's populism but the influence of fanatical free market types like the Club for Growth on the GOP is just too strong. A significant share of electorate has been poorly represented by either party. There are a lot of voters in the middle with economic populist views and moderate to conservative on social issues. Democrats are finally paying attention to this voting block and this is likely to make a critical difference in '08.
  • DLS
    McCain is not believeable. He is no Teddy Roosevelt.

    "the influence of fanatical free market types like the Club for Growth on the GOP is just too strong"

    I dispute that, given the GOP's free spending in Washington. And they're not so much even fanatical free market types (about which there is nothing wrong at all) but instead all too often are nice pals of the business community, lobbying in a way I have long called "corporate whoring." (I beat the Lefties to it years ago.)

    C'mon, that's what they're doing, no matter how tearful or impassioned they are when they say "Goddammit, anyone who risks death to come here [illegally] has earned the RIGHT to be here [exploitation by business to follow]!"
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice/Joe Gandelman | Designed by Elegant Themes | Customized by Tyrone Steels II/Enxit Group, LLC