An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Gas-Tax Vote Grab; or, McCain the Con Man’s Pathetic Pandering Populism

John McCain is yet again calling for a gas-tax holiday. Remember that terrible idea that surfaced a while back? (He and Hillary were for it, Obama was against it.) It’s nothing but pandering populism, and it’s been thoroughly criticized by everyone know who knows anything about it.

Here’s how I put it last month: “Obama is right not to sign on to this madness. And why is it madness? Because it’s ‘a crass ploy for votes’ that would stuff the coffers of the oil companies more than they are stuffed already, stuff the coffers of Middle East despots more than they are stuffed already, worsen global warming, and, and, and… and all without really doing anything substantial for those at whom the pandering and posturing is directed, namely, the American people… er, voters.”

In short, it’s terrible public policy.

Not that that’s nearly enough to stop McCain, of course. For while he has at least acknowledged that it isn’t “an answer to our energy problems,” he is now pushing the idea aggressively. Again. (Yes, he’s desperate. No, he really doesn’t have any other ideas.)

And I just can’t do better than the title of Steve Benen’s post from yesterday: “Like the villain in a bad horror movie, the ‘gas-tax holiday’ just won’t die.”

Not with McCain on board. Here’s Steve with some typically fine commentary: “McCain is pushing a ‘gas-tax holiday’ that he certainly realizes is ridiculous precisely because he has nothing else to offer… This, regrettably, is McCain the Con Man. He’s selling snake oil, hoping desperately that voters won’t know the difference. That his proposal wouldn’t do anything to help low-income Americans, wouldn’t lower the price of gas, and would boost oil company profits seems entirely irrelevant. A confidence man in the middle of a scam can’t be bothered with reality — it only gets in the way of the deception.”

McCain the Con Man, Republican candidate for president, BS salesman.

Get used to it. There are still five months to go before the election.

(Cross-posted from The Reaction.)

  • BBQ
    So is Obama a redeemed conman since he did the same thing in Illinois?
  • runasim
    BBQ
    That's why he knows it doesn't work.
  • BBQ
    My point is that McCain isn't a conman, he just hasn't researched it enough. He is wrong but that doesn't mean he is a conman. He thinks it will give drivers a little extra cash, this has nothing to do with energy or even long-term economics. Unless you think Obama was being a conman when he tried it that it was all a political pander. He even wanted people to put signs up saying that he helped lower gas prices. I don't think that but if you think McCain is a conman you must think Obama is too.
  • Jim_Satterfield
    But it has already been done and shown not to work. McCain certainly has the staff to do the research. He knows it doesn't work and doesn't care. Just like the fact that the numbers don't add up for his claims of responsible spending and tax policy.
  • runasim
    BBQ
    Nobody I can remember, and I've been around for a long time, has changed positions as much as McCain. The tax breaks he now brags about in his economy platform are the very tax breaks he opposed a few years ago when they were Bush's tax breaks. .
    He even went along with Bush's signing statement, rendering the torture bill meaningless, even though torture was McCain's signautre issue.

    Yet, I don't call him a conman. I don't know what's in his mind. or his reasons for all the changes. They happen to make me suspidious, and I could guess.
    But I wouldn't have voted for him, anyway, so I don't see the point of guessing or calling him a conman.

    Those who prefer MCcain should just go ahead and vote for him.
    No silly conman games necessary..
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice/Joe Gandelman | Designed by Elegant Themes | Customized by Tyrone Steels II/Enxit Group, LLC