An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Should Turkey Ignore Europe’s Advice On Democracy?

Map_Turkey.gif

Should turkey ignore Europe’s advice on Democracy?

Michael van der Galien, writing in the Turkish Daily News, raises the issue in an op-ed piece. Here’s part of it:

The moment Turkish secularists started raising their collective voice against the plans of the Justice and Development Party (AKP), the European Union and individual European countries followed the suit. They immediately starting railing against these secularists, saying they were anti-Democratic forces who should accept the wishes of the majority.

Although this reaction was understandable from a Western perspective, Turks should not be influenced by it.West-Europeans love to talk about Turkey, and we love to tell Turkey what to do.

That even though the far majority of West-Europeans have never visited Turkey, let alone talked to members of Turkey’s opposition. Not only that, when some European politicians have visited Turkey, they often project their own principles and the history of their own country on this young republic. By doing so, they often choose to support forces within Turkey that are not focused on the future, but on the past. Forces that do not want to turn Turkey into a modern, secular state, but that want to turn this beautiful country into an Islamic state.


Read it in its entirety.

There’s some spirited blog discussion on this article here. And also here.

  • runasim
    The debate at MVDG's site is interesting, but no one really addressed the question about foreseeable consequences in the future.
    In the past, suppression by force was much easier.Today, with the Intermet, cellphones and easy travel, it's much harder.
    Michael likes force, but I wonder if he is not depending too much on history without considering the ways in which history can not be repeated.
    If the minority builds a dam to hold back the majority, there is always the risk of the dam bursting more violently than iit need have done if there were vents to relieve the pressure. .

    I do agree, though, that it's a problem for Turkey to solve, and Westerners should be more humble in offering opinions.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC