Historical Inquiry: What About Clinton’s Apparent Point?
I, for one, don’t believe that Clinton meant to draw an analogy between Senator Barrack Obama and Bobby Kennedy, insinuating that because the Illinois senator evokes the same sort of passion as Kennedy, he may be an assassin’s target, thereby presumably giving the New York senator reason for staying in the race for this year’s Democratic nomination. There was nothing to be gained by Clinton in making such a connection, especially among Democratic superdelegates, many of whom venerate Kennedy and his older brother, President John F. Kennedy, and, like most Americans, have just been saddened by the news that Senator Edward Kennedy is suffering from cancer. Clinton, in spite of what her many opponents may say, is not evil incarnate. She’s not stupid either.
Clinton’s apparent point was that suggestions that she depart early from the race were, as she put it, “unprecedented.” To buttress her case, she mentioned that her husband didn’t clinch the 1992 Democratic presidential nomination until mid-June.
She then noted that at the time of his death in early June, 1968, Robert Kennedy was still contesting–probably futilely, it should be added–for the Democratic nomination in the California primary. I believe Clinton meant to say that it isn’t outrageous for her to still be in the race in June, 2008.
That may be. But comparing, June, 1968 to June, 2008, is not so much comparing apples to oranges as it is apples to King Kong.
One big difference is that the entire primary season in ’68 began with New Hampshire’s primary, not on January 3, the date for the campaign-opening Iowa caucuses this year, but on March 12. That’s fully two months and nine days deeper into the calendar than this year.
The California primary, the last of a grand total of thirteen primaries held in 1968, was held on June 5.
Kennedy didn’t even declare his candidacy for President until March 16, 1968, four days after President Lyndon Johnson narrowly defeated anti-Vietnam War senator, Eugene McCarthy, in New Hampshire.
Kennedy therefore, on the night of the California primary, was still a candidate for president little more than three months into his campaign and just three months after the first contest. By contrast, Senator Clinton announced her candidacy on January 22. 2007!
The date of the California primary in 1968 would, if put in an analogous position on ths year’s election calendar, fall on April 3, a date that’s already two-and-a-half months past.
By June 3, 2008, when the Montana and South Dakota primaries end the long round of primaries for this presidential election season, a full six months will have passed since the beginning of the process.
Six months after Robert Kennedy declared for the presidency was September 16, two weeks beyond the traditional Labor Day start of presidential general election campaigns.
Senator Clinton has every right to stay in the race, of course. But her continuing to contest for the nomination in June, 2008 is clearly not the same as Bobby Kennedy remaining in his race in 1968.
An interesting, if unanswerable question, is what Robert Kennedy would do if he were in Hillary Clinton’s position? No one can know. But, as he was fond of telling his presidential campaign handlers when they put too optimistic a spin on his delegate counts and nomination prospects, he had done their job once, back when he’d managed his brother’s 1960 campaign. He knew, he reminded them, how to count.
[Here's a link to my personal blog.]
48 Responses to “Historical Inquiry: What About Clinton’s Apparent Point?”
[...] Paramendra Bhagat wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerptHistorical Inquiry: What About Clinton’s Apparent Point? May 23rd, 2008 by MARK DANIELS Something of a media firestorm has greeted Senator Hillary Clinton mentioning the assassination of Robert F. Kennedy following his June, 1968 victory in the California primary. I, for one, don’t believe that Clinton meant to draw an analogy between Senator Barrack Obama and Bobby Kennedy, insinuating that because the Illinois senator evokes the same sort of passion as Kennedy, he may be an assassin’s [...]
[...] Historical Inquiry: What About Clinton’s Apparent Point? [via Zemanta] [...]
I think what she meant is “anything can happen” even late in the contest. The example she chose was about the stupidest thing she has done, and could even incite some Clinton supporting whacko to attempt assassination.
I am no Hillary fan. However, I just do not believe she meant anything bad in her remark.
She is a product of the 60s and the Kenndy thing was probably something that has stuck with her since 68. I would imagine it is something that crossed her mind but, this time she spoke it outloud.
I just don't see her wishing anything of the sort or meaning harm in the remark.
It was unfortunate and having it tied up with her and Bill's race baiting this campaign has made it much worse thing then, normally would have been seen.
As a supporter of Obama, I just do not feel the overwhelming anger many seem to over this. I see it more as a foot in mouth thing more than anything.
I voted for Hillary in the primary, but that is about the stupidest remark she could have made. I thought the reaction to many of her previous gaffes (and her husband's) was overblown, but this time I think it is deserved.
It's possible she wasn't referring to the assasination, but many will assume that she was. If by some miracle she did get the nomination, Obama supporters would stay home, or even cross party lines to vote for McCain out of spite.
It was the remark of a political neophyte, which Clinton is definitely not. I'm wondering why she is getting such poor campaigning advice. Its akin to the terrible advice Bill got during the Lewinksi scandal.
kritt,
I, for one, don't think this had anything to do with advice from her campaign. Unless you mean it in the larger sense that her advisers should have forced her to quit by now.
Mark,
Thanks for the post. Her comment was as tone deaf as it was misleading.
[...] to many Ohio bloggers and blog readers, is a co-blogger with me at The Moderate Voice and wrote this post about Clinton’s [...]
I think she didn't mean anything by it and I think it was a comment that was totally off the cuff. I do think that she and her campaign had mentioned the Kennedy assassination when talking about the history of primaries. Though I don't believe anyone suggested that she actually utter what she did.
Its getting dull listening to Clinton scramble to reinvent reality. Bill Clinton cinched the nomination on June 2, 1992, not mid June.
He was leading in delegates after the New York primary in April and had effectively crowded out all his opponents save for California. Although Brown was doing well in his California campaign he still didnt have the delegates to get the nomination or pose any sort of challenge to Clinton.
By May of 92 Clinton had stopped effectively stopped campaigning against his Dem rivals and had turned his attention to refining his GE bid against Bush
[...] caucuses this year, but on March 12. That??s fully two months and nine days deeper into the calenhttp://themoderatevoice.com/politics/democratic-party/19879/historical-inquiry-what-about-clintons-a…agende, calendare, cadouri, personalizari, tampografie, serigrafie …Agende, calendare, cadouri, [...]
[...] may occur? No, I don’t believe she wants that, but she didn’t think before she spoke. And, oh yeah, she gets her facts WRONG. But then, that is not [...]
Amoxicillin….
Amoxicillin 875mg. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin kills acne. Amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium indications. Amoxicillin and alcohol. Amoxicillin soar throat….
Percocet….
Buy percocet online. Long term use of percocet. Percocet….
Vicodin online….
What does vicodin look like. Vicodin withdrawl. Vicodin. Vicodin detox….
Vicodin….
Vicodin hp. Vicodin. Buy vicodin online. Cheap vicodin cod. Vicodin with no membership fees. Drug vicodin. Buy vicodin….
Adderall hematuria….
Adderall side effects. Adderall overdose. Adderall sideaffects. Adderall. Snort adderall xr. No prescription adderall….
Acyclovir….
Usage of acyclovir for ramsay hunt syndrome. Acyclovir. Acyclovir to stop poison ivy. Acyclovir information for patients….
Vicodin….
Vicodin side effects. Vicodin….
Tamiflu dosage….
Tamiflu. Dosage tamiflu. Getting tamiflu in 48 hours….
Tamiflu….
Tamiflu shortage in physician offices. Tamiflu. Tamiflu warning….
Cheap percocet….
Percocet….
Percocet….
Percocet. Generic percocet. Percocet dosage….
Percocet dependency….
Percocet online. Percocet….
Soma….
Cheap soma….
Best online pricing for soma….
Soma next day. Soma sonic music. Soma side effects. Soma next day delievery. Soma. Pornstar soma. Ashes of soma lyrics….
Soma….
Soma-fitness. Aura soma products. Drug soma. Soma online sales. Soma prozac. Soma triathlon. Ashes of soma….
Prescription drug called soma….
Effects of soma. Suicide with soma how many does it take. Soma intimates stores. Soma triathlon….
Buy cheap meridia….
Meridia back pain. Meridia. Meridia weight loss meds. Prescription weight loss medications – meridia. Meridia drug information meridia side effects. Meridia generic….
Meridia diet pills….
Meridia. Meridia diet pill….
Meridia meridia best prices on the net….
Meridia. Meridia coupon. Meridia weight loss meds. Meridia and wellbutrin….
Meridia….
Meridia. Buy meridia with out prescription. Generic meridia. Meridia diet pill. Cheapest price on meridia diet pill. Pictures of meridia….
Ativan narcotic….
Buy ativan online. Ativan withdrawal symptoms. Ativan side effects. Buy medication ativan cheap 34542. Ativan….
Ativan half life….
Ativan. Order ativan fast local delivery wholesale price. Ativan without prescription….
Meridia….
Meridia side effects. Meridia r ductil sibutramine rss feed. Meridia online….
Online doctors perscibe meridia….
Meridia overnight. Meridia. Meridia drug….
Amoxicillin no prior prescription….
Bleeding and amoxicillin. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin acne….
Amoxicillin….
Amoxicillin and drowsiness. Amoxicillin 875mg. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin expiry. Amoxicillin maximum pediatrics….
Buy amoxicillin without prescription….
Amoxicillin online….
Zovirax side effects….
Zovirax for cold sore. Zovirax side effects. Side effects of zovirax. Zovirax….
Zovirax cream….
Zovirax side effects. Zovirax….
Zovirax method of action….
Zovirax for cold sore. Zovirax method of action. Zovirax….
Amoxicillin for acne….
Can i drink alcohol if i m taking amoxicillin. Amoxicillin price. Amoxicillin. Amoxicillin and strep b. Can greyhounds take amoxicillin. Buy amoxicillin without prescription….
Zovirax….
Zovirax. Zovirax method of action….
Zyban….
Zyban side affects. Zyban. What is zyban….
Acyclovir chicken pox….
Compare acyclovir prices. Acyclovir and pregnancy. Acyclovir….
Zovirax….
Zovirax side effects. Cost of zovirax. Zovirax. Zovirax used for. Zovirax otc….
Zyban depression….
Does zyban make you gain or lose weight. Zyban. Zyban success rates. Reviews for zyban for quitting smoking….
Acyclovir medication….
Acyclovir. Prescribing acyclovir….