An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Clinton, Obama, McCain, and Shakespeare: Relentless War Silences Those Who Demanded Peace

Shakespeare is a greater psychologist and political strategist than most famous others.

Shakespeare spoke more insightfully and poignantly about what happens when a republic/ empire becomes mired in war than the current candidates, Senators Clinton, Obama and McCain, who essentially speak of timelines only, “100 years” if need be, or “Out” right now. Their points are useful for placing each candidate’s view somewhere on the ‘war graph’ for measuring runners.

But Shakespeare spoke about the real cost of war, not to the treasury and the tax payers only, but to the human heart and soul of all the people of a nation. Maybe, Shakespeare for Veep?

More seriously, from the play “Julius Caesar” (Caesar was a dictator, ‘appointed in perpetuity’ who also had, it might be said, ‘a perpetual war sickness,)’ …Antony is speaking:

“Blood and destruction shall be so in use
And dreadful objects so familiar
That mothers shall but smile when they behold
Their infants quarter’d with the hands of war;
All pity choked with custom of fell deeds:
And Caesar’s spirit, ranging for revenge,
With Ate by his side come hot from hell,
Shall in these confines with a monarch’s voice
Cry ‘Havoc,’ and let slip the dogs of war;
That this foul deed shall smell above the earth
With carrion men, groaning for burial.”

Antony speaks of how USUAL war has become, so much so, that the people have become senseless, inured, flattened of real emotion and thought; that they will accept anything now…

– that mothers no longer shelter their babies from being fed to the maw of war, but only have one reaction left to them: they smile solely to see their offspring with weaponry in their hands,

–that mothers’ highest hopes are that their children will rise into the ranks along with the minds that love war, living in the same room with the War God. No God of Love in sight.

–that ‘dreadful objects’ images and ideas of ever more weaponry being built–

weaponry meant to gut and poison the enemies– that these ideas are good

– that stories and images of torture and maiming of children, young men and young women, and old people– shall become so common, that no one is any longer shocked

–that it has becomes a tradition, a national custom to menace and pillage others,

–that ill deeds have become so exciting, and thus have doused elements that make a human, human: feelings of tenderness for and pity on other human beings

–and that the leader of the nation, ranges about looking for places to take revenge, rather than defending the home country

–and that the leader does so with the ‘Ate from hell’ at the leader’s side. Ate, is the Greek Goddess of Folly, Lack of Restraint, Lack of Thought, Bumbling and Delusion

– that the leader shall use the ancient cry, “Havoc!” meaning abject permission to lay waste to all in one’s path, and to revert to “animal only” nature to do so without one dit of reason or mercy, as one sees in vicious fighting and ripping that wild dogs do.

–and that this all is exciting to the leader(s) because it shall be seen and heard about by the entire world

– so that the smell of iron blood, acrid smoke and stink of decaying bodies after shall rise up so far, it will reach heaven

– and those with devastating wounds, of loss of body parts and loss of jaws and shot in the spine by arrows so they will never walk again, will be understood after the battle, as only meat for the buzzards, and that those men will beg to die

In those few lines of Shakespeare, the entire excitement and laying waste to the psyche through incessant war… is laid out sharply.

_____________
h/t Neocon

I am sorry, I accidentally did not cut two articles apart, so they originally ran as one under a tentative title instead of a final title as you see above. The second article posted just now is higher up on the TMV scroll. And it is on “normalization of violence” and Orwell’s 1984. Again, my apologies. Have to keep my elbows off the keyboard.

  • runasim
    Excellent article, Dr. E

    In thinking about war as a state of mind, I found myself returning once again to the theme of evolution and the progression from the animal instict to kill in order to eat to killing for any number of reasons.
    Is it in our DNA?

    Invent steel, and man forges swrods.
    Create atomic energy, and man develops super bombs
    Create the Internet, and man uses it for cyber attacks, our virtual killing..

    The evidence does not speak well for how we use our superior (to beasts) brain power.
    But we have choice on a level far above that of animals. We can contemplate death, not just experience it. We can imagine suffering, not just experience it.
    Why don't we use our ability to contemplate, to think, to make better choices?
    I don't unerstand. it.

    Right now, I think peace is much easier to demand than to deliver. Laying down our arms in Iraq is no guarantee that violence will stop. Since we unleashed the dogs of war, should we not take some responsibility for putting them back in cages?
    Everyone is reading tea leaves as to what will happen if we do this or do that.
    I envy those who are absolutely sure one way or the other..
    .
    I think the war state of mind has done its work on me.
    I'm just afraid.
  • archangel
    dear runasim; yes, wired in, instinct to kill, true for all.

    but

    in animals who are not in famine, and not 'meat drunk,' as I wrote about in Women Who Run With the Wolves, they kill only for as much food needed. Not slaughter far out from own terrain. Fights over close in territory sometimes, certainly to protect pups and often mate. But extremely rare seeking resource at far far distance, unless environs destroyed... usually, rather, adapting to the home terrain and whatever its resources are.

    Invent anything and some will use broadly for ill, but also good. True again. The good gets less press. But it is not less, it is often unseen.

    you hit it: a more effective peace is to consider trajectories, long, short, and unintended effects ...before acting on facts and insights... in a word, consciousness

    that's where your, my, and others hopes flow most stongly. Imperfectly perfect striving toward consciousness trumps thoughtless and reckless any day.

    We can be frightened and strong at the same time runasim. I think you and many others who often comment here and at other places I file my columns, are indeed exactly both.

    dr.e
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC