An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

The Center is a moving target

Ross Douthat writes in the Atlantic.com blog about Lieberman Democrats and the challenge of finding, and staying in, the political center

…the American “center” moves around a lot (and varies wildly on an issue-by-issue basis), and thus a party that moves leftward or rightward on the hot-button issues of the day can sometimes find a new center that nobody realized was there. This tends to leave the inhabitants of the old middle – the Rockefeller Republicans in the ’70s and ’80s, and perhaps the Lieberman Democrats of today – flummoxed and out-of-step, unable to figure out that just because they’ve always considered themselves “centrists” doesn’t mean the American people will always agree with them.

Ain’t that the truth. It is harder to create agreement on a centrist position than for any other position on the political spectrum.

Instead of firing arguments into a crowd with your back against the wall one is in the middle firing back in all directions. No wonder Centrists are relatively scarce – they tucker out faster.

But it seems to me that by shifting the geometry a bit we can mark out a relatively stable place form which Centrists can join the fray.

We Centrists tend to embrace positions that are relatively in the center of the political spectrum, and embrace collaborators who are relatively pragmatic and open minded. As a group, we could align behind adjustments to public policy that focus on process such as promoting candidates who are more pragmatic and less beholden to special interests. This might be achieved by reducing the amount of money a candidates needs to raise for a campaign while increasing the amount a candidates needs to work to build consensus among a wider range of constituents.

This is the mind-set of the Founders – how to set up a process to optimize the chances for consensus.

  • Lieberman has some liberal domestic views, and then a batsh*t insane foreign policy agenda. The fallacy was in ever thinking he represented the political center.
  • Marlowecan
    But what is a "Centrist"? It seems most everyone, and all 3 candidates, consider themselves Centrists and those who disagree extremists.

    But if we only focus on views...for example: I consider myself conservative. However, while my partner is American I am not. My politics are better described as "Tory".

    Accordingly, I find both Obama's and HRC's Health Care policies...(no offense)...to be appallingly right-wing (we will not speak of McCain's).

    So maybe you are right, Paul...perhaps it is more effective to focus on "process" rather than "views" in promoting centrism. I am not really sure how that would manifest in practice across the board though.
  • PaulSilver
    It could manifest in practice as an extended non partisan reform agenda. Campaign Finance reform for all levels of government including the judiciary, non partisan redistricting, voting operations to increase integrity and expand participation, Earmark and budgetary reforms, revisit the wisdom of congressional seniority, government transparency, and perhaps even Constitutional reforms to adjust to modern times such as revisiting the need for the electoral college.

    Larry Sabato, Norm Ornstein and Thomas Mann have a long list of areas to reconsider.
  • runasim
    Larry Sabato, Norm Ornstein and Thomas Mann have a long list of areas to reconsider.

    There are all sorts of ideas being raised, and some being tried out in states. about how to reform process. That's commendable.
    The flip side is, that many of the proposals, like Sabato's, touch on such complex subjects that it's difficult to digest in all at once. "Selling' these ideas would certainly be a formidable task, given the innate resistance to change in large swaths of society.

    I would prefer to see concentration on single areas followed by moving on to new items in a step by step process. Campaign finance reform and redistricting have been in the news enough to softern up the public's receptiveness. to reform on these areas.

    I wish our politicians could draw back from the election a bit, to pay more attention to how the government funcions. The only way any politician or active citizen can get media attention these days is to make a provocative statement about the campaign.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC