An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Building Bridges

Terry Teachout writes in the Wall Street Journal Five Myths, Direct From Pyongyang about the recent performance of the New York Philharmonic in North Korea. Basically he feels that we enhanced Kim Jong Il’s hometown prestige without meaningfully impacting our image with the average North Koreans.

I remember almost 30 years ago I moved from Los Angeles to an almost rural suburb of Houston to open up a business. I hired about a dozen 18-20 year olds. After a few weeks, one of the girls came up to me and confided that I was the first Jewish person she had ever met and she was surprised at how normal I seemed. This was apparently true for the rest of the team as well. I would like to think that, in a small way, their world was expanded to allow for the possibility that they could share values and interests with people different from themselves. Since mine was a service business, I thought it essential that my staff learn to give each customer the benefit of the doubt in all interactions.

To me it is always worthwhile to interact with people with whom I disagree. Because we can discover those areas in which we do agree thus making the conflicts seem relatively less intense. Some fraction of the Philharmonic’s audience may soften to the idea that the USA may not be as much of a threat as they have been lead to believe.

But almost as important is the audience in the rest of the world, including allies and moderates in oppressed societies, that sees the USA making the effort to reach out to adversaries, to try to build a bridge.

  • domajot
    The WSJ thinks we enhanced Kim Jong's standing? What a silly thing to worry about in a country where his exaltation is part of the air they breathe from cradle to grave.

    Rather, the people were allowed to see a group of Americans making beautiful music, without blood dripping from theri instruments. No fangs, either.
    By all accounts, the audience gave ovations, and no fist shaking has been reported.

    An hour of good feeling is an unadutterated success in my book.
    I hope this isn't the last such overture to people-to-people contact.
  • pacatrue
    Unfortunately, I don't think reinforcing Kim Jong-Il's position among North Koreans is anything to worry about. I have seen absolutely no evidence that his regime is going anywhere within his lifetime. The only chance for the end of that regime is if the entire country collapses economically to such a degree that a significant part of the army opposes Kim. In such a situation, the token gesture for Kim would have no relevance. The NY Philharmonic is playing for the future. One day there will be an end to the regime or a new dictator who has inclinations to change his nation's future. When that day comes, maybe some of the kids who saw the orchestra today, who are in government tomorrow, won't have such a horrible opinion of America.
  • Jim_Satterfield
    I also don't see how a performance by the Philharmonic enhanced Kim's position either, especially given that he wasn't even there.

    Paul's story reminds me of the first person I ever met that I found out was Jewish. She was the cutest, most attractive freckled, blond haired, blue eyed girl in our high school in my opinion and I had a crush on her that I could never, ever mention as a terminally shy overweight kid. Think I didn't learn something about stereotypes? But of course I started young on that one with the black family next door that shared my love of dogs and were just the family next door as far as I was concerned. Nothing like the older brother of one of my playmates whose hobby list needed to include B&E. Or the kid whose brother encouraged him to beat me up because I was the last white kid in the neighborhood.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC