An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

For The Love Of God, Where’s The Progress?

In Israel-Palestine, high-level peace efforts appear to be going nowhere. It has been two months since the international meeting took place in Annapolis to jumpstart negotiations but the general feeling “is that talks between Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and Palestinian negotiator Ahmed Qureia are taking place in an alternate universe.” (Haaretz) The meetings are irregular and, to most observers, far too infrequent. Livni and Qureia are meeting only once a week, while Olmert and Abbas talk merely once every two weeks. Nor does either side have proper negotiating teams (Israel has only five people involved, for instance) and the discussions have been criticized for being conducted largely in secret.

Both sides have come under fire for their failure to make any visible headway. Haaretz reports one Knesset member as saying: “This is not what a serious negotiation looks like. Where are the negotiating teams? Weekly meetings will not lead to an agreement even in 20 years.” Furthermore, it is not clear, given the fragility of Olmert’s government, whether any agreement reached could actually be carried out. The Israeli Shas Party, a key political partner, has indicated that it will leave Olmert’s coalition if talks lead to a division of Jerusalem.

Not much to hope for in the near future, I’m afraid.

  • DLS
    Don't forget that the Livni talks were in secret, and they have purportedly included the possibility of partitioning Jerusalem. This has offended many in Israel.

    I sure hope Obama or Clinton don't do this, either with the likes of Hamas or with the Iranian government.
  • Slamfu
    Ralph: So, will you quit strangling our economy so we can eat and live with some electricity?

    Sam: Maybe, can you get Hamas stop firing rockets indescriminantly into our civilian neighborhoods?

    Ralph: Not likely. Can we have back the land you took in '68?

    Sam: Maybe, can you promise not to try wipe us out with your neighbors like you did in '68?

    Ralph: Also not likely. But if we did can we have half of Jerusalem?

    Sam: No way. Thats ours now. Besides, God says that is ours.

    Ralph: God says its ours too.

    Sam: Ok well then, see you in another 6 months?

    Ralph: You bet.

    Sam: 'Nite Ralph.

    Ralph: 'Nite Sam.
  • Holly_in_Cincinnati
    Jerusalem MUST NOT be divided again. I am willing to sacrifice my life to prevent one square inch of Jerusalem from being given away to terrorist thieves. Hundreds of thousands of US citizens feel the same way I do.
  • jdledell
    Holly - I am an American Jew with dozens of relatives living in Israel. I might make Aliyah myself to fight for a fair division of the land, including Jerusalem. If Israel wants Peace - it must be done in a fair and equitable manner. Israel can continue to try to hog the land with it's settlements but eventually us jews will pay the price. Remember, we have lost Israel several times over the past few thousand years - it can happen again.

    I desparately want Israel to be a safe haven and homeland for Jews but our greed for land will one day destroy that dream. Do you really expect that the 6 million of us who live in Israel will, in 100 years, be able to fend off 1 billion angry muslims in Israel's neighborhood? Given the disparate birthrates that is a distinct possiblity.

    Israel's future can only be guaranteed by a JUST peace agreement with israel becomming the economic hub of the mideast. Our intelligence , educational system and commercial experience makes it a natural. If the surrounding Arab nations come to depend on Israel for their economic livelyhood peace will last and the mutual hatred will slowly dissapate.

    While I will not claim too much expertise, I have been in Israel over 50 times in the last 41 years and know and have talked with hundreds of Israelis (Arab and Jew) as well as many Palestinians.

    So Holly someday we may meet in Jerusalem, on opposite sides, but I certainly hope the death of either one of us is not the result.
  • Don Quijote
    Too late, Terrorist thieves have already taken over the land, what do you think Irgun and Haganah were? if not Terrorist groups?

    More proof that one man's freedom fighter is another man's terrorist...
  • Slamfu
    And Holly's attitude neatly sums up why there will be no peace in the region for the forseeable future.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC