An Internet hub for moderates, centrists, and independents, with domestic and international news, analysis, original reporting, and popular features from the left, center, and right

Why American Blacks May Be Obama’s Great Problem

What is it about Barack Obama that makes it so hard for American Blacks to get behind him – even those with a similar backgrounds? According to this analysis of his candidacy from South Africa’s Business Day, ‘It may well be that it’s Black America and not America in general, that isn’t yet ready for a Black president.’

By Jacob Dlamini

January 12, 2008

South Africa – Business Day – Home Page (English)

I FIRST heard of Barack Hussein Obama about three years ago. My informant was a young American whose family was a part of the Black political establishment in the U.S. The family originally came from the U.S. south and could speak directly of slave ancestors and cotton pickers on both maternal and paternal sides.

My informant’s parents, whose roots in the Black political elite could be traced to the Black church and the civil rights movement, were proud members of the generation of Black Americans who benefited from the success of the civil rights movement of the late 1950s. These successes included the gradual dismantling of Jim Crow discrimination , the meaningful extension of the franchise to Black voters, especially in the South, the desegregation of schools and universities, and of course, the advent of affirmative action.

And my informant had done better than his parents, attending for his education, private schools and Ivy League institutions. He had, on the face of it, gone beyond the Black political establishment and become a member of America’s integrated political elite.

Yet my friend saw himself as an outsider. He saw himself as a civil rights campaigner still fighting old battles.

He was very suspicious of Obama, the young senator from Illinois. Obama was not a senator then, but was starting to make waves within political circles. My informant said he was automatically suspicious of any Black politician who looked like he was the darling of the White political establishment. “What’s the catch!” my informant demanded. “Why do they like him so?”

My informant’s suspicions made no sense to me. First, both he and Obama were from a similar class background and both had gone to Ivy League universities. Obama might have had a White mother, but he proudly identified himself as Black; Obama might not have had direct and immediate experience of segregation, but he proudly embraced the civil rights movement and acknowledged his debt to it; he might not have known the life of a poor Black boy growing up in an inner-city project, but upon graduation he threw himself into community work.

None of this mattered to my informant. Obama wasn’t Black enough for him. He wasn’t militant enough. In fact, my informant suggested, any Black politician who made White folks feel comfortable should be distrusted. It didn’t seem to matter that Black America, which constitutes only about 13 percent of the American population, can only succeed politically through coalitions with other interest groups and communities. It didn’t seem to register that Obama looked like the sort of politician who could help build those coalitions.

READ THE REST OF THIS ARTICLE AND MUCH MORE ABOUT THE WORLD’S REACTION TO OBAMA AT WORLDMEETS.US

  • StockBoySF
    From the post: "Yet my friend saw himself as an outsider. He saw himself as a civil rights campaigner still fighting old battles.

    He was very suspicious of Obama, the young senator from Illinois. Obama was not a senator then, but was starting to make waves within political circles. My informant said he was automatically suspicious of any Black politician who looked like he was the darling of the White political establishment. “What’s the catch!” my informant demanded. “Why do they like him so?”' And this, "Obama wasn’t Black enough for him. He wasn’t militant enough. In fact, my informant suggested, any Black politician who made White folks feel comfortable should be distrusted."

    In my opinion black politicians (like the informant in the posting) who are militant want to make whites feel uncomfortable will not become President. Jesse Jackson, while he does necessary work in fighting for the civil rights of blacks, will never be elected President.

    I think the country needs someone like Obama to lead as President. Obama may not have grown up in the black ghettos, but this is exactly why he is not an angry black man. Obama embraces his background, has been on the end of racial biases, and as community organizer has seen first hand the crippling effects of racism on the black community. But he's not militant in his attitudes and approach. In fact he's the opposite- he tries to pull people together, whether they are white, black or brown, Democrat, Republican, Independent, or other.... Unlike the black militant politicians whose demands are basically for their own community, Obama rightly understands that we're all in this together and if the country is going to address the problems of the black community (which makes up about 12% of the population) then he can't alienate the rest of the population.

    America needs a leader who has the courage to stand up and say, "This is our country and we must work together for the benefit of all of us." The black militants are so in your face that it's difficult to work with them and their demands.

    One of the reasons I support Obama is that the problems of African-Americans really do need to be addressed. I'm ashamed of the way my country treats African-Americans and I think we can do better. I feel that of all the candidates, Obama cares most about the good of the people and he can work to close the huge rifts amongst the various groups in America. I truly believe that for America to succeed we all need to succeed. I believe that anyone who believes in freedom and equality (especially the religious folks) should address the social ills of our country. I'm a staunch believer in liberalism- that everyone should have equal opportunity and individual rights. For me, Obama is the politician who can best make this happen. All other candidates either owe big corporations too much or use divisiveness as a wedge against people to gain power. In order for America to "go to the next level" we need someone like Obama- a politician who brings people together.
blog comments powered by Disqus
© 2005-2009 The Moderate Voice | Site design by Elegant Themes | Site customization, hosting, and security by Enxit Group, LLC