“Divide Pakistan to eliminate Terrorism”: A Controversial Book
To view the CNN ad regarding this book please click here…
Amazon.com provides the following ‘Book Description’:
DIVIDE PAKISTAN TO ELIMINATE TERRORISM is Syed Jamaluddin’s vision to address issues related to combatting terrorism emanating from Pakistan which have dramatically transformed the entire region into a systematically controlled network having vicious effects to the global peace.
“This book gives an indepth analysis about the role of Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) and Tablighi Jamat which are involved in producing future terrorists. The book provides specific information about the actual tactics of ISI and Tablighi Jamat and their strategy to disrupt the international peace in the name of Islamization of the world through holy war and martyrdom.
“The book is an effort to provide an inside story of Pakistan and stories of its military dictators and religious cults who are busy day and night to commit corruption in the name of war-on-terror. The writer declares General Musharraf as a Terrorist-in-Uniform.”
“About the Author: Syed Jamaluddin is an active writer on issues concerning Pakistan’s involvement in various terrorist activities in the South Asian region. He was forced to leave Pakistan after the military coup of General Musharraf in 1999. He liaised with political and religious parties of Pakistan as well as Government Agencies.”
The South Asia Analysis Group web site carries a Guest Column by this book’s author, Syed Jamaluddin. Please click here to read the full interview.
You may also click here “CNN airs mysterious ‘Divide Pakistan’ advertisements”.
You may read an earlier post ‘Is Pakistan a failed state’…here…
opinions powered by SendLove.to
5 Responses to ““Divide Pakistan to eliminate Terrorism”: A Controversial Book”
The author starts with a reasonable premise:
India’s democratic strength for the last 59 years has proved that its existence was fully justified. On the contrary, Pakistan emerged as a failed state for one single reason that a country which was founded by assembling almost eight different nations in the name of Islam, was unable to justify its existence.
However, the claim is unsatisfactory. India is also an assemblage of numerous “nations” (including various Mulsim groups). Yet it has worked. Why not Pakistan? It is almost self-evident that East and West were not going to be viable in one state. But, only in hindsight, is it “obvious” that Balochis and Sindhis (etc.) can’t coexist in one state.
And the author uses a very bizarre definition of “fascism” which, for me at least, undermines the rest of the argument he presents in the summary.
In my opinion, Syed Jamaluddin’s vision to disintegrate Pakistan has some important dimensions. Firstly, Pakistan being hijacked by its brutal military dictators cannot be termed as a successful country. Hence, calling Pakistan a failed state is fully justified. On the contrary, India has proven its worth. I believe that only Pakistan’s division can pave way towards controlling terrorism in the region.
In my opinion; what Syed Jamaluddin has said in his book is totally correct and fully justified. Syed Jamaluddin’s recent column as reproduced below for the readers is also very interesting:
QUOTE:
“Regardless of the fact that the advocates of two-nation theory have finally realized after half a century that the division of United India was not a good idea for international peace, there is a need to correct mistakes. India’s democratic strength for the last 59 years has proved that its existence was fully justified. On the contrary, Pakistan emerged as a failed state for one single reason that a country which was founded by assembling almost 8 different nations in the name of Islam, was unable to justify its existence. Since its formation, Pakistan has been a country full of conspiracies, discrepancies, controversies and corruption. Pakistan could not prove its worth as a state and remained just a piece of land occupied by certain opportunists who turned the entire country into their personal property.
The military rulers of Pakistan captured power of this country on numerous occasions thereby proving that the country was not founded for welfare of people living on its soil but for the beginning of a new era of fascism under the disguise of Islam. Fascism is a religious conception in which man is seen in his imminent relationship with a superior law and with an objective Will that transcends the particular individual and raises him to conscious membership of a spiritual society. Whoever has seen in the religious politics of the Fascist regime nothing but mere opportunism has not understood that Fascism besides being a system of government is also, and above all, a system of thought. Pakistan, therefore, became an example of such Fascism. The military dictators turned the country into a paradise for looters, corrupt politicians, greedy bureacrats, incompetent administrators, uneducated reformers, militant jihadi groups, religious cults, bogus scholars and above-the-law intelligence agencies.
The socalled democracy which prevailed for almost 13 years out of 59 years of its existence in Pakistan produced sophisticated looters of national wealth who used new mechanisms to deprive the country from standing on sound footings. Similarly, the socalled politicians of the country who were rather farmers-turned politicians or businessmen-turned politicians or retired-army-personnel-turned politicians controlled the fate of this country. Such people called the shots. The result is very visible that Pakistan has now become a danger to the entire humanity. Had it been a matter limited within the jurisdiction of Pakistan, there would have never arisen any need to raise any voice, but, the situation is more worse than that.
Today’s Pakistan has turned into a typical Fascist regime without any ideology. The President of this country wears an army uniform, the Chief Justice of its Supreme Court is treated like an ordinary clerk and pushed on the road by local policemen, the Intelligence agencies rule the country and function beyond any legal boundaries, the socalled religious scholars have become preachers of radical Islam through brainwashing techniques with an aim to produce terrorists, bureacracy has become a tool in the hands of those who use money to do what they want, foreign policy is nothing but pretence and false statements, economy is based on assumptions and above all, this country has gained nuclear power through backdoor.
The whole world has become vulnerable to terrorism. The question is who is masterminding such terrorism? Who is providing all possible support to terrorism? Who is creating terrorist minds? Who is a threat to international peace? The answer is very simple…………Pakistan. Pakistan’s religious groups are responsible for masterminding the international terrorism. The Tablighi Jamat has been busy for the last 75 years in producing brains who hate Non-Muslims and as such the militant Jihadi groups based in Pakistan are nothing but “fruits” of such brainwashing techniques used by Tablighi Jamat since long. Similarly, support in terms of financial and otherwise is coming from state-owned intelligence agencies. Creation of Taliban and Al-Qaeda are glaring examples of such support by the Pakistan-based intelligence agencies. World’s most wanted man is considered as a “Guest” on the soil of Pakistan. Now that Pakistan has nuclear power, is it not correct that entire humanity is vulnerable to any possible disaster? A country which is possessed by forces which are not answerable to any one and which is beyond any legal system is indeed a great threat to the entire world. Pakistan has, therefore, become a burden. This burden needs to be off-loaded by way of its disintegration. Pakistan should be divided into 5 parts or more to crush the terrorist network which has gained its deep roots in present geographic form of Pakistan. My book titled “DIVIDE PAKISTAN TO ELIMINATE TERRORISM” advocates necessity of Pakistan’s disintegration. An Independent Pakhtoonistan, Baluchistan, Sindhudesh, Jinnahpur and Punjabistan will prevent the current nourishment and spread of terrorism from the soil of Pakistan.” Written By Syed Jamaluddin (source: http://www.saag.org/papers22/paper2170.html)
The country which has been obtained by so much hardships cant be divided for matters which dont exist or exist on a very small scale………..As saying this that all terrorism occurs through PAKISTAN is utterly wrong………..THE author of this book if is a pessimist & has negative feelings about his own country (I suggest)should not live in it & must not hurt the LOVE of other Pakistanis for it…….Pakistan has always produced the best professionals in the world & wants peace in the world…………MAY GOD always keep PAKISTAN together…………AMEN
Not a single country in world is free from a little bit of Terrorism like Pakistan…………..The author has wrongly joined all the worst things to Pakistan in an exaggerated manner which dont even exist………….
OPEN LETTER TO ALTAF HUSSAIN BHAI
Dear Altaf Hussain Bhai
Please dont make any mistake for any short term benefit. Please stop giving excuses about your patriotism. Nobody in this PUNJABI PAKISTAN will ever believe you. The entire Urdu Speaking Nation depends on you and MQM for their existence in Pakistan. If there had been no ALTAF HUSSAIN or MQM, Urdu Speaking Nation would have been living like poor Palestinians living under Israeli siege with no external support. If there was no ALTAF HUSSAIN or MQM, people of Karachi would have never been able to attract the attention of the world community towards Karachi and its development undertaken by Mustafa Kamal who is none other than but an Urdu Speaking Resident of Karachi. Had there been no ALTAF HUSSAIN and MQM, all youth of Karachi would have been like ORPHANS. If ALTAF HUSSAIN was not born, Pakistani Army from Punjab would have vanished Urdu Speaking Nation in line with the agenda of Dictator AYUB KHAN who wanted to throw away Urdu Speaking Nation into the ARABIAN SEA. If there was no ALTAF HUSSAIN and MQM, Karachi would have become a colony of Urdu Speaking Nation in similar fashion like those AFRICAN BLACKS who are still treated as THIRD CLASS CITIZENS in United States of America. ALTAF HUSSAIN and MQM have given an immortal IDENTITY to the Urdu Speaking Nation………the identity which NO PAKISTANI GOVERNMENT GAVE TO THEM IN LAST 62 YEARS for sure. Today, leaders of other political parties have acknowledged power of MQM and ALTAF HUSSAIN not because they really want to do this but because they want to save the remaining part of PAKISTAN. These political leaders very well know that Pakistan's existence depends on KARACHI and Urdu Speaking Nation. In 1988, it was Qaim Ali Shah who was PPP's nominated Chief Minister. In 2008 it is the same Qaim Ali Shah who is PPP's nominated Chief MInister. In 20 years, PPP could not produce a single politician to take charge as CHIEF MINISTER OF SINDH. This fact shows that all such political parties in Pakistan are basically run by feudals and their Masters in Uniform (Army). It was only ALTAF HUSSAIN and MQM which represented the masses.
Time has come for Pakistan to disintegrate. Please, please, please dont give your precious blood to this Pakistan which has finished its life and has become a land of terrorists which is being run with foreign aid conditional upon “specific services”. Urdu Speaking Nation will never be acknowledged as part of Pakistan no matter what you say or believe. Pakistan has never been for us. Pakistan will never be for us. We need our own IDENTITY. We want freedom. Please dont throw us into the siege of Pakistani Army. Please dont become ANWAR SADAT or YASSER ARAFAT. Please dont become KING HUSSAIN of Jordan. Please dont become HUSNI MOBARAK. Please understand our needs and care for our future.
Dear ALTAF BHAI, if you die today, who will give us our own homeland?? We need our own homeland no matter what may happen to Pakistan. Baloch freedom fighters have not given up their struggle for freedom. Pakhtoons have not stopped thinking of their freedom. Sindhis also remember DR. G.M. SYED. So, why should URDU SPEAKING NATION become “PATRIOTIC” when we all know that we can never be considered as patriotic.
WE WANT REPUBLIC OF JINNAHPUR NO MATTER WHAT PRICE WE MAY HAVE TO PAY. WE ARE BETTER, STRONGER AND MORE POWERFUL THAN OUR BENGALI BROTHERS WHO TAUGHT US A GREAT LESSON 40 YEARS AGO. TIME HAS COME TO TRANSFORM THIS LESSON INTO ACTION. LET HISTORY REPEAT ITSELF. LET REPUBLIC OF JINNAHPUR BE FORMED.
SYED JAMALUDDIN
France
Tel +33620868349